WONDER — The Mystery
The Ball That Turns While Gravity Keeps Acting
A ball slows while rising, stops for an instant and speeds up while falling. How can a curved height trace, a straight velocity trace and a flat acceleration trace all describe this motion?
Model for every numerical question: near-Earth vertical free flight, no air resistance, constant g = 9.8 m/s². g is a positive magnitude; upward is positive, so a = −g. Height y is measured above ground. The example starts at ground level with v₀ = +19.6 m/s and ends just before impact. Launch, support, catch and impact are outside the free-flight interval.
Today’s Mission: connect height, velocity and acceleration graphs; find rise, height, travel and impact values; explain why zero velocity does not make gravity disappear.
PREDICT — Commit to Your Answer
DOK 2 — PredictA ball has been released after an upward throw and reaches its highest point. Air resistance is negligible. Upward is positive. Which velocity–acceleration pair applies at that instant?
Choose the pair at the highest point of free flight.
Step 1: Pick your answer.
STOP! Before revealing — why did you pick that?
Correct prediction: B) v = 0; a = −9.8 m/s².
The ball stops upward motion momentarily, but gravity still acts downward. Its velocity therefore changes from upward to downward. The correct WHY checks the force throughout free flight. On v–t, the line crosses zero with a non-zero negative gradient; on a–t, the value remains −9.8 m/s².
At the top, height is greatest while speed is zero. These are different quantities. A graph of height against time is a time record, not the spatial path of the ball.
▶ PLAY — Free Flight Graph Lab
DOK 2 — InvestigateWhat you will DO and OBSERVE
- • DO: set height and signed launch velocity, or set the desired upward rise. Set g, then play or step through the entire flight. Scrub to inspect an instant.
- • OBSERVE: the vertical ball and three graphs share one clock. Height stays non-negative until impact; velocity can be negative while the ball remains above ground.
- • DISCOVER: compare rise with height above ground, and displacement with distance. Inspect the turning point with the Top button.
Upward is positive; y = 0 is ground. Gravity alone acts during flight, with constant positive magnitude g. Earth presets use 9.8 m/s²; other values explore an illustrative uniform gravitational field. Calculated controls are disabled and labelled. Playback is accelerated. The endpoint shows values just before contact; impact forces and rebound are excluded.
Reading the diagram: cyan is height, green is velocity, gold is acceleration. Grey dashes show the planned flight. White dashes on y–t show the current tangent; purple marks the top of an upward throw. Shaded v–t regions show signed displacement. The lower scene shows the actual vertical path on a fixed height scale for this run.
Status: Ready
Live Readouts
Try these experiments
Choose a preset, predict the graphs and impact, then press Play. Presets do not start playback.
DISCOVER — The Golden Rules
DOK 1 — RecallYou've played with the Free Fall Graph Lab. Now flip each card to reveal the four golden rules for free fall motion graphs.
Rule #1
Launch and Graph Shapes
Click to flip
Shapes depend on the launch
During constant-g free flight, y–t is concave downward, v–t is a straight line of gradient −g, and a–t is flat at −g. Only an upward launch has a future peak; a drop or downward launch descends immediately.
Rule #2
Direction and Signs
Click to flip
Signs are a choice
Here g > 0 and upward is positive, so a = −g. On descent v < 0, while height above ground can remain positive. Choosing downward positive changes signs, not the physical motion.
Rule #3
Top and Contact
Click to flip
Top is still free flight
For an upward throw, v = 0 at the top and acceleration remains −g. Greatest height = launch height + rise. At ground contact other forces act; launch, impact and rebound are outside this airborne model.
Rule #4
Signed Areas
Click to flip
Areas and travel
Signed v–t area gives displacement; add the starting height to recover height above ground. Add area magnitudes for distance. Signed a–t area gives Δv = −gt. Returning to launch height gives zero displacement, not zero travel.
Memory: gravity keeps changing velocity throughout free flight. Rise, height, distance and displacement measure different things.
MISCONCEPTION ATTACK — Destroy the Myths
DOK 2 — AnalyzeChoose TRUE or FALSE for each claim. The explanation appears after an attempt; only a correct answer completes the claim.
Myth #1: “Negative acceleration means a free-falling ball is slowing down throughout its entire flight.”
Correct — the claim is false.
On ascent v > 0 while a < 0, so speed decreases. On descent both v and a are negative, so the magnitude of velocity increases. Negative acceleration describes a downward rate of change, not a universal reduction in speed.
Myth #2: “The curved height–time trace means the vertically thrown ball follows a curved spatial path.”
Correct — the claim is false.
Time is the horizontal axis of y–t, not horizontal position. The ball’s spatial path is vertical. The graph curves because its velocity changes with time.
Both claims corrected. Read direction, speed and graph axes separately.
THE SECOND 'AHA!' — Instructor Drill
DOK 2 — ApplyAnswer four independent free-flight questions. Use g = 9.8 m/s² and upward positive. Get all four correct; guides appear after an attempt.
Your free-flight toolkit
Question progress
Waiting for Q1...
Instructor Q1 — Speed During Descent
A ball starts 20 m above ground and has this free-flight velocity record. On its descending part, what happens to speed?
Instructor Q2 — Velocity from Acceleration
A ball is dropped from rest at 40 m. Its acceleration record is shown for the first 2 s. Which describes its velocity–time graph?
Instructor Q3 — Compute Signed Velocity
A ball is released from rest at 60 m and remains airborne for the first 2.5 s. Find its signed velocity at 2.5 s in m/s.
Instructor Q4 — Rise Above Launch
A ball is thrown upward from a 6 m ledge at +14.7 m/s. Find its rise above the launch point when it reaches the top, in metres.
4/4 — Graphs Mastered!
You distinguished speed, signed velocity, rise and height. Time to apply the ideas independently!
✎ PRACTICE — Free Flight Evidence
DOK 1–3 — PracticeChallenge 1: The Released Ball
A ball is released from rest at a height of 35 m. Find its signed velocity after 1.8 s, while it is still airborne, in m/s. Use g = 9.8 m/s² and upward positive.
Step-by-Step Solution
Set signs: v₀ = 0 and a = −9.8 m/s².
Substitute: v = 0 − 9.8(1.8).
Solve: v = −17.64 m/s, downward. Its height is 35 − 4.9(1.8)² = 19.124 m, so this instant is before impact.
Challenge 2: Just Before Impact
A ball is thrown upward from a 12 m ledge with initial velocity +18 m/s. Find its signed velocity just before it reaches the ground, in m/s. Use g = 9.8 m/s² and upward positive; neglect air resistance.
Step-by-Step Solution
Set the interval: displacement to ground is Δy = 0 − 12 = −12 m; a = −9.8 m/s².
Substitute: v² = 18² + 2(−9.8)(−12) = 559.2 m²/s².
Select the direction: just before impact the ball moves downward, so v = −√559.2 ≈ −23.65 m/s. Its speed exceeds the launch speed because it lands below launch level.
Challenge 3: Audit the Ledge Report
A ball starts at a height of 24.5 m. Its straight velocity–time record joins (0 s, +19.6 m/s) and (5 s, −29.4 m/s); the endpoint is just before ground impact. Upward is positive. A student writes: “At the top at 2 s its acceleration is zero. Negative velocity after 2 s means negative height. The positive v–t area is 19.6 m, so its greatest height above ground is 19.6 m.” Find the greatest height above ground and total distance travelled by 5 s, then explain all three errors.
Step-by-Step Solution
Acceleration: the v–t gradient is (−29.4 − 19.6)/5 = −9.8 m/s², including at t = 2 s. Zero velocity does not mean zero acceleration.
Height and direction: negative velocity means downward motion. Height remains positive between 2 and 5 s, then reaches zero just before contact.
Correct the height: positive area = ½(2)(19.6) = 19.6 m rise. Greatest height = 24.5 + 19.6 = 44.1 m.
Correct travel: descent area magnitude = ½(3)(29.4) = 44.1 m. Distance = 19.6 + 44.1 = 63.7 m. Signed displacement = 19.6 − 44.1 = −24.5 m.
☷ CHALLENGE — Rebuild the Ledge Flight
DOK 2 — ApplySix Steps from Launch to Impact
A ball leaves a 14.7 m ledge with upward velocity +9.8 m/s. Use g = 9.8 m/s², upward positive and negligible air resistance. Arrange six linked steps from launch through the top to ground impact. Select a card, then a slot; select a filled slot to return it.
Build the solution in order:
Available steps (shuffled — pick one, then click a slot):
Physics Insight — Same Gravity, Different Flight
Two balls released at the same height with the same velocity follow the same ideal free-flight record, even if their masses differ. Different starting velocities or heights give different records under the same gravitational acceleration.
On Earth, air resistance can make real motions differ. The constant-g model describes an airborne interval under gravity alone. A ball held still before release is supported; a collision after flight adds contact forces.
TEACH — The Feynman Technique
DOK 3 — TeachYour Final Mission: your younger sibling says that gravity switches off when a thrown ball stops at the top. Teach how the three graphs show what actually happens.
Distinguish zero velocity from acceleration, explain negative velocity during descent, and separate rise from height above ground. Type at least three short sentences, or draw a labelled explanation using at least three purposeful strokes. Exact keywords are not required.
Type Your Explanation (≥ 3 sentences)
Draw the y–t, v–t and a–t records for an upward throw, mark the top and label the directions. Add at least three purposeful strokes. This checks effort; compare the physics with the Vault.
Cyan pen selected.
Final reward below
Hidden exam secrets inside — Crest's private notebook.
📓 Crest’s Secret Notebook
⚽Mission 2.14 — Free Fall Graphs
Gravity keeps changing velocity.
a = −g; v = v₀ − gt.
y = y₀ + v₀t − ½gt²; Δy = y − y₀.
v² = v₀² − 2gΔy.
For an upward launch: t_top = v₀/g; rise = v₀²/(2g).
Greatest height = launch height + rise.
Signed v–t area = Δy; signed a–t area = Δv.
For launch above ground: T_impact = [v₀ + √(v₀² + 2gy₀)]/g. Use the positive physical root.
1. Define the airborne model
Free fall is motion under gravity alone. Near Earth, over small height changes, g is approximately constant. This mission uses g = 9.8 m/s² unless a simulator setting says otherwise. Use the value supplied in an assessment.
Upward is positive. Height y is measured from ground, so y₀ is launch height and a = −g. A released object can be moving upward, downward or momentarily at rest and still be in free fall.
| Graph | Airborne shape | Meaning |
|---|---|---|
| Height–time | Concave-down parabola; only an upward launch has a future peak | Tangent gradient = signed velocity |
| Velocity–time | Straight line of gradient −g | Signed area = displacement; graph value gives direction |
| Acceleration–time | Horizontal at −g throughout free flight | Signed area = velocity change |
2. Turning point: one quantity is zero
For an upward throw, v = 0 at the greatest height. Acceleration remains −g. The v–t line crosses zero; the y–t tangent is horizontal; the a–t line stays below zero.
For v₀ ≤ 0 there is no future upward turning point: the greatest airborne height is the launch height. The formula v₀/g must not be used as a negative “future time to top.”
3. Rise, height and travel
Rise is the upward change from launch to top. Greatest height above ground includes the launch height. A ledge throw therefore has y_max = y₀ + v₀²/(2g) for v₀ > 0.
On return to launch height, displacement is zero and distance is twice the rise. On landing below launch height, the descent is longer than the rise. Add travel magnitudes; keep signed areas for displacement.
4. Negative velocity does not mean negative height
During descent v < 0, but y can remain positive while the ball is above ground. Speed is |v| and grows during ideal descent. Negative acceleration slows an upward-moving ball and speeds up a downward-moving ball.
A y–t graph is not a drawing of the ball’s spatial path. Its horizontal axis is time; the actual spatial path in this mission is vertical.
5. Just before impact is the end of free flight
The equations predict height and velocity up to contact. Set y = 0 to find the airborne duration, then find the downward velocity just before impact. A ground launch with v₀ > 0 has a later positive impact time; a ground state with v₀ ≤ 0 has no airborne interval in this model.
Do not continue the free-flight parabola below ground. During impact, a contact force acts, so acceleration is not simply −g. An ideal rebound rapidly changes velocity from downward to upward while height remains continuous; a finite contact interval has a large acceleration pulse. The simulator stops before modelling that contact.
🚨 Crest’s Exam Secrets
Greatest height is not always v₀²/(2g)
That expression gives rise above launch for an upward throw. Add y₀ to obtain height above ground. Use coordinates consistently.
Top means zero velocity, not zero acceleration
The velocity graph has zero height there but still has gradient −g. Gravity acts during ascent, at the top and during descent.
Choose the physical root and direction
A squared-velocity equation loses direction. Choose the downward sign for an impact velocity. In a time equation, select the later physical ground crossing rather than a negative root or the launch instant.
Support and contact are different intervals
A ball held still is supported. A ball in the air after release is in free flight. A ball colliding with ground has a contact force. Use −g only within the gravity-only airborne interval.
🧠 Memory hooks
- g is a positive size; −g is a signed acceleration here.
- Rise + launch height = greatest height.
- Zero velocity at the top; gravity still acts.
- Signed areas give changes; magnitudes give travel.
- A curved time record can describe a straight spatial path.
✨ Bonus wonder — why mass does not enter
In a uniform gravitational field, gravitational force is mg. Using F = ma gives mg = ma, so the mass cancels and the gravitational acceleration has magnitude g. Matching initial height and velocity give matching ideal flight records, regardless of mass. Air resistance can change real motions.
✓ Crest’s Checklist
- I state the origin, direction, g value and neglected air resistance.
- I read all three graph axes.
- I distinguish height, rise, displacement and distance.
- I keep acceleration non-zero at the top.
- I choose physical impact times and downward impact velocities.
- I stop the gravity-only model at contact.
— Crest ✨ “At the top, velocity pauses. Gravity does not.”
Mission 2.14 Complete! · All 10 levels cleared · PHYSICS CREST
🏅 Master of Free Fall Graphs
Free-fall kinematic graphs — mastered: position, velocity and acceleration now tell one consistent airborne story.