WONDER — The Mystery
The Pool-Table Mystery
A pool ball rolls horizontally off a table 0.60 m above level ground at 2.4 m/s. How can we find when it reaches the ground and how far it travels sideways?
Today’s mission: put horizontal and vertical data in separate columns, connected by one elapsed time. All numerical tasks and labs use uniform g = 9.8 m/s², no air resistance, +x right and +y up. The free-flight model ends at first ground contact.
PREDICT — Commit to Your Answer
DOK 2 — PredictTwo identical balls are released at the same instant from the same height. One is dropped from rest; the other leaves horizontally at 2 m/s. Both have initial vertical velocity zero. With uniform gravity and no drag, which reaches the level ground first?
Commit to both a prediction and a reason before revealing the explanation.
Step 1: Pick your answer.
STOP! Before revealing — why did you pick that?
Correct prediction: C. Reason 1.
Their vertical motions obey the same equation with the same height, initial vertical velocity and g. Changing only horizontal velocity does not change the time to the same ground level in this ideal model.
▶ PLAY — Two Columns, One Clock
DOK 2 — InvestigatePredict, run and compare
Complete a matched pair at the same height with different horizontal velocities. Then change only height from one of that pair. Finish at least three distinct flights. Loading a preset earns no credit.
Horizontal release means uᵧ = 0. Gold combines the cyan horizontal and green vertical constructions, which are not extra objects or forces. Both position axes use the same metre scale, fixed for each trial. Trails show elapsed motion. Ground-contact readings are just before impact.
Status: Ready
Signed Velocity Components vs Time
X-column
Y-column
TIME BRIDGE
Δy is measured from release; y is height above ground.
Compare completed flights: vertical conditions set the fall time; horizontal velocity sets sideways travel during that same time.
Load an experiment — predict, then launch
Predict the default flight, then measure.
0 / 3 matched flights completed
♢ DISCOVER — The Two-Column Rules
DOK 1 — RecallFlip all four rule cards. Keep the component data separate and the elapsed time shared.
Rule 1
Separate the axes
Click to flip
Separate the axes
Choose +x right and +y up. Put uₓ, vₓ, aₓ and Δx in X; uᵧ, vᵧ, aᵧ and Δy in Y. In this ideal model, aₓ = 0 and aᵧ = −g. Height y and vertical displacement Δy are different quantities.
Rule 2
Build the time bridge
Click to flip
Build the time bridge
Both columns describe the same object over the same interval. Find t from whichever column has enough data, then use that same t in the other column. Vertical-first is useful for unknown landing time; it is not a universal rule.
Rule 3
Horizontal release
Click to flip
Horizontal release
Here uᵧ = 0. From height h to level ground, −h = −½gT², so T = √(2h/g) for h > 0. Horizontal displacement is Δx = uₓT. A larger uₓ alone changes range, not the fall time.
Rule 4
Angled launch
Click to flip
Angled launch
For speed u at θ above +x, uₓ = u cos θ and uᵧ = u sin θ. Keep uᵧt in Δy = uᵧt − ½gt². T = 2uᵧ/g applies to an upward launch returning to its release level; use the actual vertical condition for another landing level.
All four rules explored. Choose the useful column first, then carry its time across.
MISCONCEPTION ATTACK — Destroy the Myths
DOK 2 — AnalyzeChoose TRUE or FALSE for each claim. The explanation appears after an attempt; only a correct answer completes the claim.
Myth 1: “Increasing only horizontal velocity makes the ball stay airborne longer.”
Correct — the claim is false.
False. With height, initial vertical velocity, g and landing level fixed, the vertical motion and flight time are unchanged. The horizontal displacement increases.
Myth 2: “At the peak of an oblique flight with a nonzero horizontal component, the total velocity is zero.”
Correct — the claim is false.
False. Only vᵧ is zero at the peak; vₓ remains nonzero, so total speed is |vₓ|. A purely vertical launch can have zero total velocity for an instant. In both cases, acceleration is still downward.
Both myths corrected. Now explore an angled launch.
✦ THE SECOND “AHA!” — The Angled Launch
DOK 2 — ApplyExplore a football’s ideal free flight from and back to the same level. This teaching lab displays the full trajectory. Resolve the launch, examine the peak and answer all four questions. Use uniform g = 9.8 m/s², no drag, +x right and +y up.
ANGLED-LAUNCH TEACHING LAB
Question progress
Waiting for Q1...
Instructor Q1 — Peak Velocity
At the peak of an upward flight with nonzero horizontal velocity, which quantity is zero?
Instructor Q2 — Landing Condition
If the landing is below the launch level, must total flight time equal twice the time to peak?
Instructor Q3 — Peak Acceleration
With +y upward, what is the signed vertical acceleration at the peak? Give m/s².
Instructor Q4 — Return Velocity
A ball has initial vertical velocity +12 m/s and returns to its launch level. What is its signed vertical velocity just before returning? Give m/s.
4/4 — Peak and Landing Conditions Checked
Keep the signed vertical component, horizontal component and total speed distinct.
✎ PRACTICE — Use the Time Bridge
DOK 1–3 — PracticeChallenge 1: The New Pool Table
A pool ball leaves horizontally at +3.6 m/s from a table 1.25 m above level ground. Its initial vertical velocity is zero. Use uniform g = 9.8 m/s², no drag, +x right and +y up. Find the time to ground contact and the horizontal displacement during that time.
Step-by-Step Solution
uᵧ = 0 and Δy = −1.25 m. −1.25 = −4.9T² gives T ≈ 0.5051 s. Δx = 3.6T ≈ +1.8183 m.
Challenge 2: The Sensor Reading
A ball is released 20 m above ground with horizontal velocity +8 m/s and an unknown initial vertical velocity. A sensor observes it in free flight at horizontal displacement +20 m and vertical displacement −5.625 m from release. Use uniform g = 9.8 m/s², no drag, +x right and +y up. Find elapsed time to the sensor and the signed initial vertical velocity.
Step-by-Step Solution
The horizontal column gives t = 20/8 = 2.5 s. Carry this time to Y: −5.625 = uᵧ(2.5) − 4.9(2.5)². Therefore uᵧ = +10 m/s. The sensor height is 20 − 5.625 = 14.375 m, above ground.
Challenge 3: Audit the Gate Report
A ball leaves a ledge 50 m above level ground with uₓ = +11 m/s and uᵧ = +14 m/s. A gate observes it in free flight at Δx = +44 m. Use uniform g = 9.8 m/s², no drag, +x right and +y up. A student reports: (i) t = 44/14 ≈ 3.14 s; (ii) Δy = ½aᵧt², with no initial-velocity term needed; (iii) aᵧ = +9.8 m/s² because the ball initially rises. Calculate the correct elapsed time, signed vertical displacement and signed vertical velocity at the gate. Explain all three report errors.
Step-by-Step Solution
Clock component: use horizontal uₓ = 11 m/s for Δx = 44 m, giving t = 44/11 = 4 s. The vertical 14 m/s cannot replace horizontal velocity.
Missing term: uᵧ is not zero. Δy = uᵧt − ½gt² = 14(4) − 4.9(4)² = −22.4 m.
Gravity sign: aᵧ = −9.8 m/s² even while rising. Thus vᵧ = 14 − 9.8(4) = −25.2 m/s. At the gate y = 50 − 22.4 = 27.6 m, so the point is still in free flight.
☷ CHALLENGE — Sort the Two Columns
DOK 2 — ApplyX, Y or the Time Bridge?
Select a card, then its category. More than one card belongs in each component column. Select a placed card to return it to the bank. All six placements must be correct.
0 / 6 correct
Physics Insight — Share the Clock
Horizontal and vertical data remain in their own columns. The common time connects their calculations; it is not an extra force.
TEACH — The Feynman Technique
DOK 3 — TeachYour Final Mission: your younger sibling says a heavier cannonball will stay airborne longer. Explain what changing mass alone does when launch velocity and levels stay fixed in the no-drag, uniform-gravity model. Then explain how changing the initial vertical velocity can change time aloft, and why changing angle at fixed total speed also affects horizontal velocity and range.
Use simple words to connect the two columns and their shared time. Type at least three short sentences. This checks effort; compare your physics with the Vault or your teacher.
Type Your Explanation (≥ 3 sentences)
Draw labelled component columns and a time bridge, with a mass comparison or an angle comparison. Use at least three purposeful strokes. This checks effort; compare your physics with the Vault or your teacher.
Cyan pen selected.
Final reward below
Hidden exam secrets inside — Crest's private notebook.
Crest’s Secret Notebook
Mission 3.11 — The Two-Column Strategy
Separate the axes. Share the time.
Two columns, one object, one clock
During ideal free flight, neglect air resistance and continuing thrust. Gravity is uniform and downward. Choose +x right and +y up. This mission uses g = 9.8 m/s² as a positive magnitude; its upward-axis component is aᵧ = −9.8 m/s².
aₓ = 0; aᵧ = −g
vₓ = uₓ; Δx = uₓt
vᵧ = uᵧ − gt; Δy = uᵧt − ½gt²
x = x₀ + Δx; y = y₀ + Δy
1. Build the two-column table
| Quantity | X-column | Y-column |
|---|---|---|
| Initial velocity | uₓ | uᵧ |
| Acceleration | aₓ = 0 | aᵧ = −g |
| Velocity at t | vₓ = uₓ | vᵧ = uᵧ − gt |
| Displacement | Δx = uₓt | Δy = uᵧt − ½gt² |
| Elapsed time | The same t | The same t |
Do not move velocity data from one component into the other. The horizontal velocity may be constant while vertical velocity changes. Both columns describe the same interval for the same projectile.
The general horizontal constant-acceleration equation is Δx = uₓt + ½aₓt². Here aₓ = 0, so its acceleration term vanishes. The vertical initial-velocity term uᵧt vanishes only when uᵧ = 0.
2. Choose the useful column first
Write the givens and requested unknowns, including signs and units. Find t from whichever column has enough data, then carry that t into the other column. A vertical calculation often supplies landing time; horizontal observations can also supply time.
For example, uₓ = +6 m/s and Δx = +18 m give t = 18/6 = 3 s. If the vertical displacement during that interval is −11.1 m, then −11.1 = uᵧ(3) − 4.9(3)², giving uᵧ = +11 m/s. Horizontal-first is useful here because the vertical initial velocity is unknown.
A measured time to a sensor is not automatically the total flight time. Check the event named in the question. Stop free-flight calculations at the first collision; later motion needs another model.
3. Horizontal release from a table
A ball leaving horizontally has uᵧ = 0, even though its horizontal speed is nonzero. From release height h to level ground, vertical displacement is −h. For h > 0:
−h = −½gT²
T = √(2h/g)
Δx = uₓT; vᵧ = −gT
Example: a horizontal release at +3.2 m/s from h = 0.80 m gives T = √(1.6/9.8) ≈ 0.4041 s and Δx ≈ +1.2930 m. Choose the positive elapsed-time root.
At fixed height, initial vertical velocity, g and landing level, changing only uₓ leaves T unchanged. Two balls released at the same instant from the same height with uᵧ = 0 reach the ground together in this ideal model, even if one has no horizontal motion.
4. Angled launches belong in two columns too
For launch speed u and an angle θ measured above the positive horizontal:
uₓ = u cos θ; uᵧ = u sin θ
If the angle is instead measured from the vertical, the sine and cosine roles exchange. State the reference direction. The total speed is not a substitute for either component unless the velocity is aligned with that component’s axis.
For an upward launch returning to its release level, uniform g and no drag give T = 2uᵧ/g. This is the later return time, not the t = 0 launch root. The shortcut requires equal levels and uninterrupted free flight to that return.
For a release height h above level ground, use the actual condition 0 = h + uᵧT − ½gT². When h > 0, first ground contact has T = (uᵧ + √(uᵧ² + 2gh))/g. A lower landing does not generally give twice the peak time.
5. Signs, displacement and height
Height y is measured above a chosen ground origin. Vertical displacement is the change from release: Δy = y − y₀. A ball released 30 m above ground with Δy = −8 m is still 22 m above ground. Negative displacement does not imply a position below ground.
Velocity gives the direction of motion. Acceleration gives the rate of change of velocity. A rising ball has vᵧ > 0 and aᵧ = −g. At the peak vᵧ = 0, but aᵧ remains −g. After the peak vᵧ < 0.
At the peak of an oblique upward flight, vₓ = uₓ. Total speed is √(vₓ² + vᵧ²) = |uₓ|. With nonzero uₓ it is nonzero. A purely vertical launch can have zero total velocity for an instant, while acceleration and weight remain downward.
On returning to the same height during ideal descent, vᵧ has the opposite sign and the same magnitude as the launch vertical velocity. At a different height, use the vertical equations instead of assuming that magnitude is unchanged.
6. Read the horizontal-release lab
The gold ball combines both component motions. The cyan construction has x = uₓt and stays at the release height. The green construction remains at x = 0 and has y = h − ½gt². They are component constructions, not additional projectiles or forces.
Changing height or horizontal velocity resets time to zero. Presets load givens without autoplay. Launch/Resume advances time; Pause freezes it; Step adds 0.25 s and caps at first ground contact; Reset repeats the selected givens. Reloading restores the paused state.
The position axes have equal metre scales, fixed during each trial. The velocity chart uses one signed scale for both components. Trails show only elapsed motion. Endpoint readings are limiting values just before impact; the collision is not simulated.
To continue, finish a same-height pair with different uₓ, plus a trial that changes only height from one of the pair. Repeating identical givens adds no distinct flight. A release at ground height with uᵧ = 0 has no airborne interval and earns no flight credit.
7. Read the angled-launch teaching lab
This lab displays a complete same-level ideal trajectory so you can inspect the peak and return. Adjust speed and angle above +x. The readouts show resolved components, peak time, total return time, range and rise. Both position axes use one metre scale.
At 90°, horizontal velocity is zero and the launch is vertical. At 0° from ground height, there is no airborne interval above the surface. These boundary cases help distinguish zero vertical velocity at a peak from zero total velocity.
Crest’s Exam Secrets
Mass and launch conditions
Changing mass alone does not change ideal motion at fixed initial velocity and levels: all objects have the same gravitational acceleration. With the same horizontal velocity and levels, increasing an upward initial vertical velocity increases time aloft and horizontal range. At fixed total speed, changing angle also changes uₓ, so longer airtime alone does not guarantee a longer range.
Keep every required term
For a launch with nonzero uᵧ, vertical displacement includes both uᵧt and −½gt². Omitting the first term silently changes the launch condition to a horizontal release.
Check the common interval
Use the same elapsed t in both columns for the same event. Do not combine time to peak in one column with time to ground contact in the other.
✓ Crest’s Checklist
- I state the ideal model and value of g.
- I choose axes and distinguish height from displacement.
- I assign each given to its own component column.
- I find time from the column with enough data.
- I share the same time across both columns.
- I retain the initial vertical term when uᵧ is nonzero.
- I keep gravity downward, including at the peak.
- I check levels, physical roots, signs and units.
— Crest ☆ “Separate the axes. Share the time.”
Mission 3.11 Complete! · All 10 levels cleared · PHYSICS CREST
★ Projectile Strategy Master
You kept component data separate, shared the clock and audited a gate report.