WONDER — The Mystery
The Snapping Wire
A 50 kg painting is supported symmetrically by two cable segments. Why does making the segments almost horizontal require much greater tension even though the weight stays unchanged?
Model: Ideal massless cables and static loads; uniform g = 9.8 m/s². Angles are measured above the horizontal. Cable forces are treated as concurrent in the load model. A rigid body also requires zero net external torque.
PREDICT — Commit to Your Answer
DOK 2 — PredictThe same sign hangs from two symmetric cables. Setup A has each cable at 60° above horizontal; Setup B has each at 10°. Which requires the greater tension in each cable?
Commit to both a prediction and a reason before revealing the explanation.
Step 1: Pick your answer.
STOP! Before revealing — why did you pick that?
Correct prediction and reasoning saved.
The vertical components must provide the same weight. The flatter cable has a smaller vertical fraction, so its tension must be larger.
▶ PLAY — Hanging Sign Simulator
DOK 2 — InvestigatePredict, measure and compare
Record a two-cable comparison at the same mass with different angles. Then change only mass from one of that pair. Observe each setup for one second to record a measurement; the model remains static.
One cable means vertical support. Two cables are symmetric about the load. Arrows show actual tensions and weight using one force scale; components are read separately. This is a static force calculation, not a simulation of settling or cable failure.
Status: Ready
Playback: 1 simulation seconds per real second. Pause or Step for measurements.
Measurements
Load givens — then predict and run
Loading a setup earns no trial credit.
♢ DISCOVER — Rules of Equilibrium
DOK 1 — RecallFlip all 3 rule cards. Keep the quantities and model conditions clear.
Rule 1
Force balance
Click to flip
Force balance
Translational equilibrium means ΣF = 0. Velocity is constant; it may be zero. Forces need not have equal magnitudes individually: their vector sum must vanish.
Rule 2
Resolve and balance
Click to flip
Resolve and balance
For two symmetric cables at θ above horizontal: opposing T cos θ components cancel, while 2T sin θ = mg. Components are parts of an actual tension, not additional forces on the free-body diagram.
Rule 3
Check rotation
Click to flip
Check rotation
A rigid body in full static equilibrium needs ΣF = 0 and Στ = 0, with no motion. A concurrent-force particle model uses force balance because all forces pass through the model point.
All rules explored.
MISCONCEPTION ATTACK — Destroy the Myths
DOK 2 — AnalyzeChoose TRUE or FALSE for each claim. The explanation appears after an attempt; only a correct answer completes the claim.
Myth 1: “Equilibrium requires every cable tension to have the same magnitude.”
Correct — the claim is false.
False. Equal tensions follow from a symmetric arrangement, not equilibrium alone. Asymmetric supporting cables can have unequal tensions whose components balance.
Myth 2: “Zero net force means an object must be stopped.”
Correct — the claim is false.
False. It means constant velocity in an inertial frame. Static equilibrium means at rest; full rigid-body static equilibrium also needs zero net external torque.
Both myths corrected. Continue to the instructor questions.
✦ THE SECOND “AHA!” — The Sag Limit
DOK 2 — ApplyUse the force components to explain the ideal tightrope limit. Actual forces belong on the free-body diagram; resolve them in a separate calculation.
Instructor Q1 — Vertical Fraction
As a cable’s angle above horizontal decreases toward zero, what happens to its vertical fraction sin θ?
Instructor Q2 — Finite Tension
Can a perfectly horizontal ideal cable support a nonzero downward load through finite tension alone?
Instructor Q3 — Symmetric Support
A 500 N load hangs from two symmetric cables, each 30° above horizontal. Find the tension in each cable.
Instructor Q4 — Opposing Moment
A 70 N downward force acts 0.30 m to the right of a pivot. What magnitude of counterclockwise torque must other forces provide for rotational equilibrium?
4/4 — Instructor Questions Completed
Full static equilibrium of a rigid body requires both force balance and torque balance.
✎ PRACTICE — Support and Static Balance
DOK 1–3 — PracticeChallenge 1: The Simple Hang
A 12.5 kg painting hangs at rest from one vertical massless wire. Use g = 9.8 m/s². Find the wire tension.
Step-by-Step Solution
Weight is 12.5 × 9.8 = 122.5 N. Vertical force balance gives tension = 122.5 N.
Challenge 2: The Angled Gallery
A 7.5 kg sign hangs at rest from two symmetric massless cables, each at 37° above horizontal. Use g = 9.8 m/s². Find the tension in each cable.
Step-by-Step Solution
Weight = 73.5 N. Vertical balance gives 2T sin 37° = 73.5, so each tension is about 61.1 N.
Challenge 3: Audit the Beam Report
A horizontal rigid beam of negligible mass is pinned at its left end. A 180 N downward load acts 1.2 m to the right of the pin. A vertical cable supports the beam 3.0 m to the right of the pin. The beam is at rest. A student reports: (i) the load moment about the pin is 180 × 3.0; (ii) cable tension equals 180 N because the cable alone balances the load; (iii) checking net force is enough to establish full static equilibrium. Find the load-moment magnitude about the pin, cable tension and upward pin reaction. Explain all three report errors.
Step-by-Step Solution
Load arm: its moment is 180 × 1.2 = 216 N·m clockwise, not 180 × 3.0.
Shared support: torque balance gives 3T = 216, hence T = 72 N. Force balance gives R + 72 − 180 = 0, so R = 108 N upward.
Rigid-body condition: both ΣF = 0 and Στ = 0 are required for full static equilibrium.
☷ CHALLENGE — Order the Symmetric-Support Workflow
DOK 2 — ApplyOrder the Symmetric-Support Workflow
Arrange the six actions in the workflow taught here. Select a card, then its numbered slot. A slot holds one card; replacing it returns the old card. This is one valid calculation order; a rigid-body torque check follows.
0 / 6 correct
Physics Insight
Component balance solves the symmetric support; full static equilibrium also requires zero net torque.
TEACH — The Feynman Technique
DOK 3 — TeachYour Final Mission: A sibling wants to pull a clothesline perfectly straight while it supports a wet shirt. Explain why an ideal flexible cable needs a nonzero angle to provide upward support and why required tension increases as the line gets flatter. State that real cables can stretch or fail.
Use simple words and at least three short sentences. This checks effort; compare your physics with the Vault or your teacher.
Type Your Explanation (≥ 3 sentences)
Draw a labelled explanation with at least three purposeful strokes. This checks effort; compare your physics with the Vault or your teacher.
Cyan pen selected.
Final reward below
Hidden exam secrets inside — Crest's private notebook.
Crest’s Secret Notebook
Mission 3.13 — Equilibrium & Statics
Balance the forces. Check the moments.
1. Two equilibrium conditions
A rigid body in full static equilibrium is at rest and has zero net external force and zero net external torque.
ΣFₓ = 0; ΣFᵧ = 0; Στ = 0
Zero net force alone means no translational acceleration. Constant nonzero velocity also satisfies translational equilibrium. Do not infer rest from force balance alone, or ignore torque when a rigid body can rotate.
2. Actual forces and components
Draw weight and each actual cable tension. Components are projections used in calculation, not extra forces to add alongside the tensions. In AP Physics 1 free-body diagrams, actual forces originate at the dot; arrows in the same direction are side by side.
For θ measured above horizontal, one tension contributes horizontal magnitude T cos θ and upward magnitude T sin θ. Equal tensions follow from the symmetric configuration. In an asymmetric arrangement, solve horizontal and vertical balance together; individual tensions may differ.
3. Symmetric support
W = mg
2T sin θ = W
T = W/(2 sin θ)
At θ = 90°, each vertical cable carries W/2. At smaller positive angles, each tension exceeds W/2. The large horizontal components cancel one another and do not support the downward load.
Example: an 8 kg load supported symmetrically at 50° above horizontal has W = 78.4 N and T = 78.4/(2 sin 50°) ≈ 51.2 N per cable.
4. Why the line sags
As θ approaches zero, the upward fraction sin θ approaches zero and the required tension grows without bound in this ideal flexible-cable model. At exactly zero angle, no finite tension provides vertical support for a nonzero load. A real line can sag, stretch or fail; the ideal calculation does not predict a breaking strength unless that strength is supplied.
This conclusion concerns a flexible cable whose support forces act along its direction. A rigid horizontal beam can support loads through other forces and bending; it is a different model.
5. Moments and lever arms
Moment magnitude is force times perpendicular distance from the pivot to that force’s line of action. Assign clockwise and counterclockwise signs consistently. A force through the pivot has zero moment about that pivot.
Example: a 120 N load 0.75 m from a pin produces 90 N·m clockwise. An upward cable 2.0 m from the pin requires T = 45 N to provide 90 N·m counterclockwise. Vertical force balance then gives a 75 N upward pin reaction. Both supports share the load.
A zero resultant force can coexist with a nonzero couple. Two equal opposite forces along different lines can produce rotation without net force, demonstrating why a rigid-body torque check matters.
6. Operate the static lab
Choose one vertical cable or two symmetric cables. In one-cable mode the angle is irrelevant and is fixed to 90°. For two cables, change mass and angle. Observe for one second to record the setup; this observation interval is not a settling calculation.
Arrow lengths use one common force scale within each setup and adjust to fit its largest force. Do not compare pixel lengths across different scales; compare the numerical forces. Only actual tensions and weight are drawn. Horizontal and vertical projections appear in labelled readouts.
Finish a same-mass angle pair and a comparison changing only mass. Flatter cables require more tension; at a fixed angle, multiplying mass multiplies weight, tension and both components by the same factor. Identical setups do not add new trial credit.
✓ Crest’s Checklist
- I distinguish static from translational equilibrium.
- I draw actual forces and resolve them separately.
- I state the cable angle reference.
- I use each force’s own perpendicular moment arm.
- I check both force and torque balance for a rigid body.
- I state the ideal flexible-cable limit.
— Crest ☆ “Balance the forces. Check the moments.”
Mission 3.13 Complete! · All 10 levels cleared · PHYSICS CREST
★ Master of Equilibrium
Full static equilibrium of a rigid body requires both force balance and torque balance.