WONDER — The Mystery
The “Ghost Force” Mystery
After riding downhill, your snowmobile enters a straight, level, frictionless ice track. You release the throttle. In this ideal model, neglect air resistance and all other horizontal forces. Weight and support balance vertically.
Noah: “Without the engine pushing forward, it must stop.” Anna: “It keeps its existing speed and direction while the net force stays zero.”
The mystery: does continued motion require a net forward force?
Today’s mission: Newton’s first and second laws, in an inertial reference frame. Use constant-mass objects and signed horizontal quantities, with right positive. Newton’s third law is a separate topic.
PREDICT — Commit to Your Answer
DOK 2 — PredictThe two forces shown act on a cart on a straight, level track. There are no horizontal forces. Which statement can be true?
Commit to both a prediction and a reason before revealing the explanation.
Step 1: Pick your answer.
STOP! Before revealing — why did you pick that?
Correct prediction: B. Reason 1.
The force sum is zero vertically and horizontally. Acceleration is therefore zero. A stationary cart stays at rest; a moving cart keeps the same velocity while these conditions hold.
Balanced forces do not cancel velocity. They produce no change in velocity. Weight and support here act on the same object; their balance is a statement about that object’s motion.
▶ PLAY — The Inertia Lab
DOK 2 — InvestigateWhat you will DO and OBSERVE
- • DO: predict a trial, then Play or Step through four seconds. Compare force and mass.
- • OBSERVE: gold velocity can point opposite to cyan net force. Watch a moving cart slow, stop and reverse.
- • DISCOVER: finish three distinct trials, including a nonzero net force and a moving, zero-force coast.
Ideal straight, level track; no friction or drag. Mass is constant during each trial; weight and support balance. Right is positive. Changing net force starts a new timed trial from the current position and velocity. Changing mass or starting velocity starts fresh at x = 0. Reset returns to the current trial’s starting values. A preset loads givens; it earns credit only after four seconds of Play or Step.
The camera follows the cart. Metre positions remain continuous; the cart never wraps. Arrow lengths are schematic and independently capped; use labels for values. Net force is the resultant, not an extra force.
Status: Ready
Velocity–Time Graph
Time runs 0–4 s. The labelled velocity scale adapts to the loaded trial, then stays fixed. Zero velocity is the horizontal reference; graph slope equals acceleration.
Enter a finite value from −1000 to +1000 m/s for a fresh trial. After a force change, the displayed start retains the cart’s current velocity.
Live Readouts
Zero net force, nonzero velocity: coasting at constant speed and direction.
Try these experiments
Predict the default trial, then complete four seconds.
0 / 3 distinct trials completed
DISCOVER — The Golden Rules
DOK 1 — RecallFlip all four cards to connect inertia, net force, mass and acceleration direction.
Rule #1
First law: keep existing velocity
Click to flip
First law: keep existing velocity
In an inertial frame, zero net external force means zero acceleration. Rest stays rest; motion keeps the same speed and direction. Balanced forces do not erase velocity. Mass measures resistance to a change in velocity: inertia.
Rule #2
Second law: use the resultant
Click to flip
Second law: use the resultant
For a constant-mass object, ΣF⃗ = m a⃗. In one dimension: ΣFₓ = m aₓ. Add all external forces on the chosen object with signs first. 1 N = 1 kg m/s². Use positive mass in kg.
Rule #3
Compare force and mass
Click to flip
Compare force and mass
With the same mass, doubling the net force doubles acceleration. With the same net force, doubling mass halves acceleration. In general a_new / a_old = (F_new / F_old) ÷ (m_new / m_old), for nonzero original force and unchanged force direction.
Rule #4
Acceleration need not match velocity
Click to flip
Acceleration need not match velocity
Acceleration points with net force, not necessarily velocity. Opposite directions reduce speed at that instant. At v = 0, a nonzero net force starts motion in its direction. If that force persists, the object can reverse and then speed up.
All four rules explored. Identify the object, add its forces, then predict acceleration.
MISCONCEPTION ATTACK — Destroy the Myths
DOK 2 — AnalyzeChoose TRUE or FALSE for each claim. The explanation appears after an attempt; only a correct answer completes the claim.
Myth #1: “A cart moving right must have a net force to the right.”
Correct — the claim is false.
False. A cart can move right at constant velocity with zero net force. It can also move right while a leftward net force slows it. Net force determines acceleration, not the current velocity.
Myth #2: “If all forces balance, the object must be parked.”
Correct — the claim is false.
False. Balanced forces produce zero acceleration in an inertial frame. The object can be at rest or moving with constant velocity. On a real road, a drive force can balance drag and rolling resistance without either force being zero.
Both myths corrected. Distinguish an object’s velocity from the change in its velocity.
THE SECOND 'AHA!' — Instructor Drill
DOK 2 — ApplyAnswer two multiple-choice and two numerical questions. Keep the given right-positive convention and units. Guides appear after an attempt. All four correct answers are required.
Your force toolkit
Question progress
Waiting for Q1...
Instructor Q1 — Velocity vs Acceleration
A 4 kg cart is moving left at 6 m/s. Its net force is 12 N right. What happens to its speed at that instant?
Instructor Q2 — Mass Comparison
Two carts have masses 2 kg and 6 kg. Each experiences the same net force of 12 N right. Which comparison is correct?
Instructor Q3 — Signed Acceleration
A 6 kg cart has a net force of 18 N left. Find its signed horizontal acceleration in m/s²; right is positive.
Instructor Q4 — Net Force
An 8 kg cart accelerates at +2.5 m/s². Find the signed horizontal net force in N; right is positive.
4/4 — Newton’s Laws Toolkit Ready!
Now combine fresh forces and audit a report independently.
✎ PRACTICE — Calculate and Audit
DOK 1–3 — PracticeChallenge 1: Find the Mass
A cart experiences a net force of 24 N right and accelerates at 6 m/s² right. Find its mass in kg.
Step-by-Step Solution
Fₙₑₜ = m a. Therefore m = Fₙₑₜ / a = 24 / 6 = 4 kg. The force and acceleration point the same way, and mass is positive.
Challenge 2: Combine the Forces
A 6 kg crate slides on a level floor. A horizontal push is 39 N right; friction is 15 N left. Weight and support balance. Find the signed horizontal net force and acceleration. Right is positive.
Step-by-Step Solution
Take right positive. Fₙₑₜ = +39 + (−15) = +24 N.
a = Fₙₑₜ / m = 24 / 6 = +4 m/s², to the right. The balanced vertical forces give zero vertical acceleration.
Challenge 3: Audit the Robot Cart
A 5 kg robot cart moves right at +4 m/s. Horizontal forces are 18 N right and 33 N left; vertical forces balance. Right is positive. A student reports net force +51 N and acceleration +10.2 m/s², then says: “Rightward velocity means rightward acceleration, so its speed is increasing.” Enter the corrected signed net force and acceleration. Explain the force-combination error, the acceleration-direction error and what happens to speed at that instant.
Step-by-Step Solution
Force combination: the horizontal forces oppose each other. Adding their magnitudes to get +51 N is incorrect. Their signed sum is +18 − 33 = −15 N, left.
Acceleration: a = −15 / 5 = −3 m/s². Acceleration follows the net force, not the rightward velocity.
Speed: velocity is right while acceleration is left, so speed decreases at this instant. If these constant forces persist, v = 4 − 3t reaches zero after 4/3 s; afterward the cart moves left and speeds up. The instantaneous slowing claim does not mean it slows forever.
☷ CHALLENGE — Rebuild a Force Analysis
DOK 2 — ApplySix Linked Actions
An 8 kg cart moves left at 5 m/s. Forces are 42 N right and 14 N left; vertical forces balance. Rebuild this specified object-first analysis. Each action uses the previous result. Select a card, then a slot; select a filled slot to return it.
Build the solution in order:
Available steps (shuffled — pick one, then click a slot):
Physics Insight — Slowing, Stopping, Reversing
Fₙₑₜ = 42 − 14 = +28 N and a = 28 / 8 = +3.5 m/s². The velocity is initially −5 m/s, so speed initially decreases. If the force remains constant, velocity reaches zero after 5/3.5 ≈ 1.43 s. Acceleration is still rightward at that instant, so the cart then moves right and speeds up.
Stopping momentarily is different from equilibrium. A nonzero force can act when velocity is zero.
TEACH — The Feynman Technique
DOK 3 — TeachYour Final Mission: your younger sibling throws a ball straight upward. After the ball leaves their hand, ignore air resistance. They ask: “Which upward force keeps it rising? And when it reaches the top, is gravity switched off?” Explain what changes and what stays the same.
Explain the force after release, the difference between upward velocity and downward acceleration, and what happens at the top and on the way down. Type at least three short sentences, or draw at least three purposeful strokes. Exact keywords are not required.
Type Your Explanation (≥ 3 sentences)
Draw the ball rising, at the top and falling. Label the force and velocity at each stage; use at least three purposeful strokes. This checks effort; compare your physics with the Vault.
Cyan pen selected.
Final reward below
Hidden exam secrets inside — Crest's private notebook.
Crest’s Secret Notebook
Mission 3.5 — Newton’s First & Second Laws
Net force changes velocity. Balance preserves it.
The force toolkit
Inertial reference frame; constant positive mass.
ΣF⃗ = m a⃗; in one dimension: ΣFₓ = m aₓ.
aₓ = ΣFₓ / m; m = ΣFₓ / aₓ when aₓ ≠ 0.
Choose right positive. A rightward force is positive; a leftward force is negative. Mass is always positive.
1 N = 1 kg m/s². Zero net force → zero acceleration → constant velocity.
1. Inertia and Newton’s first law
An object at rest remains at rest, and a moving object continues with constant velocity, unless a nonzero net external force acts. Constant velocity means constant speed and direction. A changing direction is a change in velocity even if speed stays constant.
Mass measures resistance to a change in velocity. A larger mass needs a larger net force for the same acceleration. Inertia is a property of the object, not an extra force. There is no separate “force of motion” keeping a released object moving.
Use an inertial reference frame: one in which a free object has constant velocity. An accelerating vehicle frame needs extra care. All force analyses in this mission use an inertial frame.
2. Net force is the signed vector sum
Choose the object first. Include all external forces acting on that object. Do not add a force the object exerts on something else to its own force diagram. The resultant is the vector sum of those forces; it is not another interaction force.
For a cart on a level floor, weight acts down and support acts up. If vertical acceleration is zero and no other vertical forces act, support balances weight. This does not tell you whether horizontal forces balance. Equilibrium must be checked along every relevant axis.
Weight and support here act on the same cart. Their equality follows from the stated vertical equilibrium. Newton’s third law, which concerns interactions between different objects, is studied separately.
3. Newton’s second law
For constant mass, acceleration points in the direction of the net external force. Its magnitude is |ΣF|/m. The direction of the current velocity may be different. Use the resultant in the second law, not automatically the applied push or the largest force.
Example: an 8 kg crate has a 28 N push right and 4 N friction left. With right positive, ΣFₓ = 28 − 4 = +24 N; aₓ = 24/8 = +3 m/s². It accelerates right. Without its velocity, you cannot decide whether it is speeding up or slowing down at that instant.
4. Compare changes in force and mass
| Change | Condition | Acceleration magnitude |
|---|---|---|
| Double net force | Same mass and force direction | Doubles |
| Double mass | Same net force | Halves |
| Double force and mass | Same force direction | Unchanged |
| Reverse net force | Same magnitude and mass | Same magnitude, opposite direction |
| Net force becomes zero | Positive constant mass | Becomes zero; velocity is retained |
For nonzero initial net force, the magnitude ratio is |a_new|/|a_old| = (|F_new|/|F_old|) ÷ (m_new/m_old). Determine direction separately if the force direction changes. A ratio with zero initial acceleration is undefined; use the second law directly instead.
5. Velocity and acceleration are different
In one dimension, acceleration in the same direction as nonzero velocity increases speed. Acceleration in the opposite direction decreases speed at that instant. Zero acceleration preserves velocity. When velocity is zero, nonzero acceleration starts motion in its direction.
A cart moving right can accelerate left. If that leftward acceleration remains constant, it slows to rest, then reverses and speeds up leftward. “It is slowing now” does not mean “it slows forever.” A moment of zero velocity does not imply zero net force.
Suppose v₀ = +10 m/s and a = −2 m/s². Then v = 10 − 2t. At t = 5 s the cart is momentarily stationary, while acceleration and net force are still leftward. After 5 s, its velocity is leftward and its speed increases.
6. A ball after release
After the ball leaves the hand, the hand’s push is gone. Neglecting air resistance, weight mg acts downward throughout its flight. Gravity does not switch off at the top. Choose up positive: a = −g, approximately −9.8 m/s² near Earth’s surface.
While rising, velocity is up and acceleration down, so speed decreases. At the top, velocity is zero for an instant but acceleration remains down. While falling, velocity and acceleration are both down, so speed increases. The upward motion was acquired during the earlier push; it does not require an upward force after release.
7. Read the Inertia Lab
The lab uses signed horizontal net force in N and a fixed mass in kg during each trial. Position x is in m, velocity v in m/s and time t in s. The camera follows the cart; shifting the view never changes the cart’s physical position. Track ticks are always 10 m apart.
Each trial lasts four seconds. The exact constant-acceleration model is v = v₀ + at and x = x₀ + v₀t + ½at², with a = Fₙₑₜ/m. Playback changes time; drawing does not reset position. Pause freezes time and Step adds 0.5 s.
The velocity–time graph runs from 0 to 4 s. Its velocity scale adapts when a trial is loaded and stays fixed during that trial. Its slope is signed acceleration. A horizontal line can lie above or below zero: zero slope means no acceleration, not necessarily no motion. A sloping line crossing v = 0 shows a reversal.
Changing force begins a new timed trial from the current position and velocity, so setting force to zero preserves motion. Changing mass or starting velocity begins a fresh trial at x = 0. Reset returns to the current trial’s x₀ and v₀. Starting-velocity entries for fresh trials are limited to ±1000 m/s; the inherited velocity after a force change is retained.
Force and velocity arrows are schematic, use different quantities and have capped lengths. Compare labelled numbers and directions, not their arrow lengths. Net force is a resultant representation, not an additional force on top of the interactions.
Complete three different force–mass–starting-velocity trials, including a nonzero net force and a moving zero-force coast. Repeating identical givens at a shifted starting position earns no extra credit. Loading a preset alone never completes a trial.
Crest’s Exam Secrets
Identify the object and sum its forces
A single applied force equals the resultant only when other forces have zero resultant. With right positive and a rightward push opposed by leftward friction, ΣFₓ = F_push − F_friction. This subtraction is specific to those collinear directions.
Keep mass, weight and units distinct
Mass is in kg; weight is a force in N. Convert grams to kilograms before substituting. Signed acceleration is in m/s². A negative result describes the chosen negative direction; it does not mean negative mass.
Read “constant” carefully
Constant speed alone can still involve acceleration if direction changes. Constant velocity in an inertial frame implies zero net force. Individual forces may be nonzero and balance. “Frictionless” alone does not remove air resistance; state all relevant assumptions.
Audit more than arithmetic
Check the signed force sum, the acceleration direction, and the comparison with velocity. A correctly divided number can still come from the wrong resultant. A statement about speed needs both velocity and acceleration at that instant.
✓ Crest’s Checklist
- I choose the object, inertial frame and positive direction.
- I identify all relevant external forces on that object.
- I sum signed forces before using the second law.
- I use positive mass and compatible SI units.
- I distinguish velocity, acceleration and net force.
- I handle coasting, rest and reversal correctly.
- I check model assumptions and whether mass is constant.
— Crest ✨ “Object. Forces. Sum. Acceleration. Motion.”
Mission 3.5 Complete! · All 10 levels cleared · PHYSICS CREST
Master of Newton’s First & Second Laws
You balanced and combined forces, predicted acceleration, and distinguished acceleration from velocity.