WONDER — The Mystery
The Two-Ball Paradox
Two identical balls leave the same height at the same instant. Ball A is dropped; ball B is launched horizontally. Both start with zero vertical velocity. Neglect drag and use uniform downward gravity above level ground. Which reaches the ground first, and how could you calculate their flight time and horizontal displacement?
Today, calculate the horizontal and vertical components using one shared time. Check displacement signs and the limits of symmetry shortcuts. Numerical tasks and the lab use g = 10 m/s²; right and up are positive.
PREDICT — Commit to Your Answer
DOK 2 — PredictA ball is launched horizontally at +20 m/s from an elevated platform. Assume it remains in flight for at least 3 s. Neglect drag and use uniform downward gravity. What is its horizontal velocity 3 s after launch?
Commit to both a prediction and a reason before revealing the explanation.
Step 1: Pick your answer.
STOP! Before revealing — why did you pick that?
Correct prediction: B. Reason 1.
After contact ends, weight acts downward in the ideal no-drag model. Its horizontal component is zero, so aₓ = 0 and vₓ = uₓ = +20 m/s throughout free flight. Gravity changes the vertical velocity; it does not produce a forward acceleration.
▶ PLAY — The Two-Track Tracker
DOK 2 — InvestigatePredict, measure and compare
Complete at least three distinct flights: a pair with the same uᵧ and height but different uₓ, plus a flight that changes only uᵧ from one of that pair. Loading a preset earns no credit.
An ideal uniform field with no drag or continuing thrust; g = 10 m/s², +x right and +y up. Cyan shows horizontal motion at the launch height; green shows vertical motion at x = 0; gold combines both. Ghosts are component constructions, not separate force-driven objects. Flights stop at first ground contact; endpoint velocities and accelerations are flight values just before impact. Changing any given starts a fresh trial.
Gold: projectile. Cyan: x-component. Green: y-component. Both axes use the same metre scale, fixed throughout the trial.
Status: Ready
Velocity Components vs Time
One signed velocity scale and one shared time axis, fixed within a flight.
Live Readouts
Changing only uₓ leaves vertical motion and flight time unchanged. Changing uᵧ or landing level can change the flight time.
Try these experiments
Predict the default flight, then measure its first-contact time.
0 / 3 distinct flights completed
♢ DISCOVER — The Golden Equations
DOK 1 — RecallFlip all four cards to connect component equations, signs, shared time and the conditions for symmetry.
Rule #1
The horizontal track
Click to flip
The horizontal track
With no horizontal resultant, aₓ = 0. Thus vₓ = uₓ and Δx = uₓt. Displacement is measured from the launch point; x = x₀ + Δx. The general constant-acceleration equation remains valid and reduces to this form when aₓ = 0.
Rule #2
The vertical track
Click to flip
The vertical track
With +y upward and positive g, aᵧ = −g. Use vᵧ = uᵧ − gt and Δy = uᵧt − ½gt². Height above ground is y = y₀ + Δy. An upward velocity does not make acceleration positive; gravity remains downward.
Rule #3
One shared clock
Click to flip
One shared clock
Resolve velocity into components and use the same elapsed time in both equations. Horizontal velocity alone cannot determine vertical displacement. A horizontal release has uᵧ = 0; an upward launch can have uᵧ > 0. State the release and landing levels.
Rule #4
Symmetry has conditions
Click to flip
Symmetry has conditions
For an upward launch in uniform gravity without drag, tₚₑₐₖ = uᵧ/g. Return to the same launch level gives T = 2uᵧ/g. Landing on a different level requires the vertical position equation. Equal time offsets around the peak give opposite vᵧ and equal speed when both instants are in flight.
All four rules explored. Choose the correct component, sign convention and landing level.
MISCONCEPTION ATTACK — Destroy the Myths
DOK 2 — AnalyzeChoose TRUE or FALSE for each claim. The explanation appears after an attempt; only a correct answer completes the claim.
Myth #1: “A projectile slows horizontally as it rises, even without drag.”
Correct — the claim is false.
False. In the stated ideal model, the horizontal resultant is zero, so aₓ = 0 and vₓ is constant. Gravity changes vᵧ; total speed can decrease during ascent without any decrease in vₓ.
Myth #2: “At the peak of an oblique projectile with nonzero vₓ, its total velocity and acceleration are both zero.”
Correct — the claim is false.
False. Only vᵧ is zero at the peak. Horizontal velocity remains, so speed is |vₓ|. Weight still acts and aᵧ = −g. A purely vertical launch can have zero total velocity for an instant at the peak, while its acceleration is still downward.
Both myths corrected. Keep total speed, velocity components and acceleration distinct.
✦ THE SECOND “AHA!” — The Symmetry Secret
DOK 2 — ApplyUniform downward gravity changes vertical velocity by equal amounts in equal time intervals. Explore the same-height symmetry through four guided questions. Guides appear after an attempt; all four correct answers are required.
Your projectile toolkit
Question progress
Waiting for Q1...
Instructor Q1 — Matched Heights
A ball takes 3 s from launch to its peak. It returns to the same launch height in uniform gravity without drag. How long does the downward part from the peak to that height take?
Instructor Q2 — Shortcut Boundary
A ball is launched upward from a ledge 20 m above the ground. Can its ground-contact time always be found by doubling its time to peak?
Instructor Q3 — Flight Time
A ball is launched from level ground with uᵧ = +30 m/s. It returns to that same level. Use g = 10 m/s² and no drag. Find its total flight time in s.
Instructor Q4 — Signed Velocity
A ball starts with uₓ = +18 m/s and uᵧ = +25 m/s. It remains in flight at t = 3.0 s. Neglect drag and use g = 10 m/s², +y upward. Find its signed vertical velocity at that time in m/s.
4/4 — Projectile Math Toolkit Ready!
Now solve fresh scenarios and audit a report with three linked errors.
✎ PRACTICE — The G.U.E.S.S. Method
DOK 1–3 — PracticeChallenge 1: The Cliff Jumper
A rescue plane flies horizontally at +30 m/s and releases a package without a push. The package reaches level ground after exactly 4.0 s. Neglect drag. Find its horizontal displacement from the release point.
Step-by-Step Solution
With aₓ = 0, Δx = uₓt = 30 × 4 = +120 m.
Challenge 2: The Water Fountain
A fountain launches a water parcel vertically upward from a nozzle with initial velocity +24 m/s. Model its flight after separation with no drag and uniform g = 10 m/s². Let the nozzle be y = 0 and +y upward. Find its signed displacement and signed vertical velocity at t = 3.0 s.
Step-by-Step Solution
Use aᵧ = −10 m/s². Δy = 24 × 3 − ½ × 10 × 3² = +27 m.
vᵧ = 24 − 10 × 3 = −6 m/s. It is above the nozzle and moving downward; height and velocity have different signs.
Challenge 3: Audit the Projectile Report
A ball is launched from a ledge 25 m above level ground with uₓ = +14 m/s and uᵧ = +30 m/s. Use g = 10 m/s², no drag, +x right and +y up. A student reports: (i) Δy at 4 s is 14 × 4 = +56 m; (ii) aᵧ = +10 m/s² because the ball initially rises, so vᵧ at 4 s is +70 m/s; (iii) ground-contact time is twice time to peak, giving 6 s. Enter the correct signed Δy and vᵧ at 4 s, and total time to the lower ground. Explain all three report errors.
Step-by-Step Solution
Component error: 14 m/s is uₓ, so 14 × 4 gives Δx, not Δy. Vertical motion needs uᵧ = +30 m/s and aᵧ = −10 m/s².
Sign error: gravity points down even during ascent. At 4 s, Δy = 30 × 4 − 5 × 4² = +40 m and vᵧ = 30 − 10 × 4 = −10 m/s.
Symmetry boundary: 6 s returns the ball to the ledge height, not to the lower ground. At ground y = 0: 0 = 25 + 30T − 5T². The positive root is T = 3 + √14 ≈ 6.74 s. The negative root is outside this flight.
☷ CHALLENGE — The Track Sort
DOK 2 — ApplySix Statements, Three Categories
Classify statements as horizontal (x), vertical (y), or symmetry. Use the ideal uniform-gravity, no-drag model. Select a card, then a category. Select a placed card to return it to the bank. All six must be correct.
0 / 6 correct
Physics Insight — Keep the Tracks and Conditions Clear
Each component uses its own initial velocity and acceleration, with one shared clock. Symmetry can shorten a calculation only when its conditions apply. A lower landing level requires extra downward travel after the launch height is crossed again.
TEACH — The Feynman Technique
DOK 3 — TeachYour Final Mission: your 10-year-old sibling says a video-game ball needs a continuous “forward thrust” while airborne or it will stop moving forward. Explain the ideal no-drag flight using the horizontal and vertical component equations and one shared time. Explain why a same-height symmetry shortcut needs checking before use.
Use simple words to distinguish force, velocity and displacement. State the model and explain the component equations. Type at least three short sentences or draw at least three purposeful strokes. This checks effort; compare your physics with the Vault or your teacher.
Type Your Explanation (≥ 3 sentences)
Draw a labelled projectile diagram with velocity components, downward gravity, and launch and landing levels. Use at least three purposeful strokes. This checks effort; compare your physics with the Vault or your teacher.
Cyan pen selected.
Final reward below
Hidden exam secrets inside — Crest's private notebook.
Crest’s Secret Notebook
Mission 3.9 — The Mathematics of Projectile Motion
The cliff jumper, the fountain and the symmetry shortcut.
Two tracks, one shared time
During ideal free flight, neglect drag and continuing thrust. Uniform gravity is downward. Choose +x right and +y up, with positive g.
aₓ = 0; aᵧ = −g
vₓ = uₓ; Δx = uₓt
vᵧ = uᵧ − gt
Δy = uᵧt − ½gt²
x = x₀ + Δx; y = y₀ + Δy
This mission uses g = 10 m/s². Use the value specified in each question. The acceleration component aᵧ is negative for these axes; g itself is a positive magnitude.
1. Sort the quantities before calculating
| Quantity | Horizontal | Vertical |
|---|---|---|
| Initial velocity | uₓ | uᵧ |
| Acceleration | aₓ = 0 | aᵧ = −g |
| Velocity at t | vₓ = uₓ | vᵧ = uᵧ − gt |
| Displacement | Δx = uₓt | Δy = uᵧt − ½gt² |
The component equations describe the same object during the same time interval. Changing only uₓ leaves vertical motion unchanged if uᵧ, height, g and landing level stay fixed. Changing uᵧ or the landing level can change the flight time.
A horizontal velocity cannot replace the vertical initial velocity in a vertical calculation. For example, uₓt gives horizontal displacement, not height. The general constant-acceleration equation is still valid horizontally; its acceleration term is zero in this ideal model.
2. Displacement, height and velocity differ
Vertical displacement is the change from the release position: Δy = y − y₀. Height above a chosen ground level is y. If a ball starts 20 m above ground and rises by 15 m, its height is 35 m; its displacement is +15 m.
A positive height does not imply upward motion. A ball above its launch level can already be moving downward, with Δy positive and vᵧ negative. Calculate each quantity from its own relation.
Likewise, a negative vertical velocity does not mean a negative speed. Total speed is the non-negative magnitude √(vₓ² + vᵧ²). A component velocity is signed.
3. A useful calculation routine
G — identify the givens, including the vertical launch condition and landing level. U — identify the unknown and its component. E — choose the relevant component equation. S — substitute values with consistent signs and SI units. S — solve and check the result against the physical situation.
Keep one shared t in both components. If landing time is unknown, the vertical position condition determines it; the horizontal relation then gives displacement during that time.
Example: a package is released horizontally at +15 m/s from 45 m above level ground. With g = 10 m/s², uᵧ = 0. Ground contact requires 0 = 45 − 5T², so T = 3 s. Thus Δx = 15 × 3 = +45 m. Just before contact, vᵧ = −30 m/s.
Use the positive elapsed time. A negative root may describe a mathematical extension before launch, rather than the flight being studied. Do not continue the free-flight equations through a ground collision.
4. Upward motion still has downward acceleration
For an upward launch, uᵧ is positive. Gravity makes vᵧ decrease at 10 m/s each second in this mission. On ascent vᵧ > 0; at the peak vᵧ = 0; after the peak vᵧ < 0. Acceleration stays aᵧ = −10 m/s² throughout free flight.
Example: a water parcel leaves a nozzle with uᵧ = +22 m/s. At 3 s, Δy = 22 × 3 − 5 × 3² = +21 m and vᵧ = 22 − 10 × 3 = −8 m/s. It is above the nozzle but moving down. Air drag and breakup of a real jet are outside this simple model.
At the highest point of an oblique flight, horizontal velocity remains uₓ. Total speed is |uₓ|. A purely vertical launch can have zero total velocity for an instant, but acceleration and weight are still downward.
5. Derive the symmetry shortcut
For an upward launch in uniform downward gravity, set vᵧ = 0 at the peak:
0 = uᵧ − gtₚₑₐₖ
tₚₑₐₖ = uᵧ/g
For a return to the same launch level, set Δy = 0:
0 = uᵧT − ½gT²
T(uᵧ − ½gT) = 0
T = 0 or T = 2uᵧ/g
The zero root is the launch instant. The later return time is T = 2tₚₑₐₖ, provided uᵧ > 0 and the object remains in free flight until that level is reached. The time up from that level equals the time down to it.
Example: uᵧ = +35 m/s, g = 10 m/s² and equal launch and landing heights give tₚₑₐₖ = 3.5 s and T = 7 s. Horizontal velocity sets horizontal range uₓT, but does not set the vertical return time.
6. Equal offsets around the peak
At a time τ before the peak, vᵧ = +gτ. At a time τ after it, vᵧ = −gτ. The vertical velocities have equal magnitudes and opposite directions; the heights match. With the same constant vₓ, total speeds also match.
These comparisons require uniform g, no drag, and both instants to be within the actual free-flight interval. Equal speed does not mean identical velocity: the vertical direction is different. Do not treat the word “speed” as a signed component.
If a projectile lands below launch level, the motion around the peak still has this symmetry, but the full launch-to-landing interval does not consist of equal times on either side of the peak.
7. Unequal launch and landing levels
Use the actual landing coordinate instead of automatically doubling the peak time. For launch height h above level ground and initial vertical velocity uᵧ:
0 = h + uᵧT − ½gT²
T = (uᵧ + √(uᵧ² + 2gh))/g
This is the positive first-ground-contact time for h > 0 in the ideal model. For h = 0 and uᵧ > 0, it reduces to 2uᵧ/g. A ground-level start with no upward vertical velocity has no airborne interval above the ground.
Example: h = 15 m and uᵧ = +10 m/s, with g = 10 m/s², give 0 = 15 + 10T − 5T². The roots are T = −1 s and T = 3 s. First ground contact after launch is at 3 s. Doubling the peak time would give 2 s, when the ball has only returned to its launch height.
For a landing above launch level, two positive crossings may be possible: one while rising and one while falling. The physical scenario determines which crossing matters. Always check that the height is reachable.
8. Read the Two-Track Tracker
The gold projectile combines both components. The cyan x-ghost moves at the launch height with x = uₓt. The green y-ghost remains at x = 0 and has y = h + uᵧt − ½gt². These are component constructions, not separate projectiles with extra forces.
Changing uₓ, uᵧ or h resets time and position to the selected launch conditions. Presets load givens without autoplay. Launch/Resume advances elapsed time; Pause freezes it; Step adds 0.25 s and caps at first ground contact; Reset repeats the same givens from t = 0.
The lab uses exact constant-acceleration expressions, equal metre scales on the position axes, and a common signed velocity scale. Each scale adapts to the full chosen flight, then remains fixed while it runs. Trails show only the elapsed motion; no ball wraps at the screen edge.
At first contact, readouts show the limiting free-flight values just before impact. A bounce, landing force or later motion is not simulated. A ground-level start with uᵧ ≤ 0 earns no flight credit.
To continue, finish a matched pair with the same uᵧ and height but different uₓ, plus a flight that changes only uᵧ from one of that pair. These comparisons distinguish the effects of horizontal and vertical initial conditions. Repeating identical givens adds no distinct trial.
Crest’s Exam Secrets
Keep g and aᵧ distinct
g is a positive magnitude. With upward positive, aᵧ = −g. Do not give g a minus sign and also subtract it in the same equation; that would reverse gravity twice.
Check what the question asks
Height y, displacement Δy, vertical velocity vᵧ and total speed are different quantities. Report the requested one, with the correct sign and unit.
Do not double time blindly
“Thrown upward” alone does not guarantee T = 2tₚₑₐₖ. The landing must be at the launch level for this full-flight shortcut. A lower landing usually adds downward travel after the launch level is crossed.
✓ Crest’s Checklist
- I state the ideal no-drag, uniform-gravity model.
- I choose positive directions and the coordinate origin.
- I use the correct initial velocity for each component.
- I keep one shared time in both components.
- I distinguish displacement, height, velocity and speed.
- I keep gravity downward even while the ball rises.
- I check the launch and landing levels before using symmetry.
- I select the physically relevant time root and stop at impact.
— Crest ☆ “Two tracks. One clock. Check the landing level.”
Mission 3.9 Complete! · All 10 levels cleared · PHYSICS CREST
★ Master of Projectile Math
You calculated signed components, checked symmetry boundaries and audited a projectile report.