WONDER — The Mystery
The Tired Arms Puzzle
A person holds a box at constant height and carries it steadily across a room. Their arms feel tired. Under an ideal model with only an upward support force from their hands, what work does that force do on the horizontally moving box? Does feeling tired measure that work?
Model: Work by a specified force on a body undergoing translation. For a constant vector force, use displacement of its point of application and the angle between force and displacement. Work is a signed scalar. Carrying examples assume steady height, with no vertical bobbing or starting/stopping transitions.
PREDICT — Commit to Your Answer
DOK 2 — PredictA tray translates 10 m horizontally at constant height. The waiter’s support force is 50 N vertically upward throughout. Calculate work by that support force alone.
Commit to both a prediction and a reason before revealing the explanation.
Step 1: Pick your answer.
STOP! Before revealing — why did you pick that?
Correct prediction and reasoning saved.
The upward support force is perpendicular to the horizontal displacement, so its work is zero. This is a statement about that ideal support force on the tray, not about metabolic energy used by the waiter.
▶ PLAY — Selected-Force Work and Signed Area
DOK 2 — InvestigatePredict, measure and compare
Measure the same force and displacement at two angles. Then change only force from one of that pair. Run three matched setups. Compare positive, perpendicular and opposite-force work.
A guided body has a prescribed horizontal displacement over 4 s. A constant selected force acts at the stated angle above +x. The lab calculates only that force’s work; unmodeled guiding/driving forces maintain the prescribed path. This is not a prediction of acceleration from the selected force alone. The shaded signed area under Fₓ versus displacement equals accumulated work.
Status: Ready
Playback: 1 simulation seconds per real second. Pause or Step for measurements.
Parallel Force vs Displacement
Measurements
Load givens — then predict and run
Loading a setup earns no trial credit.
♢ DISCOVER — Work Without the “Cause” Shortcut
DOK 1 — RecallFlip all 4 rule cards. Keep the quantities and model conditions clear.
Rule 1
Specify force and displacement
Click to flip
Specify force and displacement
A force need not initiate the motion to do work. Work uses displacement of its point of application. A force opposing existing motion can do negative work.
Rule 2
Resolve along displacement
Click to flip
Resolve along displacement
For a constant force, W = Fd cos θ. Here θ is the angle between force and displacement. A perpendicular component contributes zero work but can still influence motion or direction.
Rule 3
Keep the sign and sum forces
Click to flip
Keep the sign and sum forces
Parallel gives positive work, perpendicular zero, opposite negative. One force’s positive work does not guarantee increasing speed: net work by all forces gives ΔK for the translating point-body model.
Rule 4
Use signed graph area
Click to flip
Use signed graph area
For a changing parallel force, add signed areas under F∥ versus displacement. Do not multiply the final force by the whole displacement unless that force was constant throughout.
All rules explored.
MISCONCEPTION ATTACK — Destroy the Myths
DOK 2 — AnalyzeChoose TRUE or FALSE for each claim. The explanation appears after an attempt; only a correct answer completes the claim.
Myth 1: “A force must cause the object to start moving before it can do work.”
Correct — the claim is false.
False. Work can be done on an already moving object. An opposing force can do negative work; the displacement need not have been initiated by that force.
Myth 2: “If one force does positive work, the object must speed up.”
Correct — the claim is false.
False. Other forces may do negative work. For the stated point-body translation model, the sum of all force work determines the change in kinetic energy.
Both myths corrected. Continue to the instructor questions.
✦ THE SECOND “AHA!” — Force Direction and Net Work
DOK 2 — ApplyRead which force is being assessed. Zero work by one force does not mean the force has no effect or that every energy transfer is zero.
Instructor Q1 — Opposing Force
A box already moves right while a force points left. Its point of application displaces right. What is the work sign for that force?
Instructor Q2 — Perpendicular Force
A force remains perpendicular to a moving particle’s velocity. Which statement is correct?
Instructor Q3 — Selected Work
A constant 60 N force acts along 3 m of point displacement. Find its work.
Instructor Q4 — Sum the Works
For a translating point-body model, an applied force does +180 J while friction does −45 J. All other forces do zero work. Find net work.
4/4 — Instructor Questions Completed
Work depends on force and point displacement, not on whether the force started the motion or how tired a person feels.
✎ PRACTICE — Independent Work Cases
DOK 1–3 — PracticeChallenge 1: Moving a Crate
A constant horizontal force of 92 N acts on a crate while its point of application translates 6.5 m in the same direction. Calculate the work by that force.
Step-by-Step Solution
Force and displacement are parallel. W = 92 × 6.5 = +598 J.
Challenge 2: The Angled Rope
A rope applies a constant 145 N force at 37° above horizontal to a crate. Its attachment point translates 7.2 m horizontally right at constant height. Find the work by the rope.
Step-by-Step Solution
Wrope = 145 × 7.2 × cos 37° ≈ 833.775 J.
Challenge 3: Audit the Work Ledger
A crate translates 5.5 m horizontally right at constant height. A constant 110 N rope force acts 32° above horizontal; a constant 70 N kinetic friction force acts left. Weight and normal force are vertical. A student reports: (i) rope work is the full force magnitude times distance; (ii) friction work is positive because distance is positive; (iii) rope work alone is net work. Calculate rope work, friction work and net work. Explain all three errors.
Step-by-Step Solution
Rope: W = 110 × 5.5 × cos 32° ≈ 513.069 J, using the parallel component.
Friction: W = −70 × 5.5 = −385 J because force opposes displacement.
Total: weight and normal do zero work here. Net work = 513.069 − 385 ≈ 128.069 J. For the translating point-body model this is ΔK, rather than rope work alone.
☷ CHALLENGE — Classify Work by the Stated Force
DOK 2 — ApplyClassify Work by the Stated Force
Classify work by the named force, using the displacement of its point of application. Each body undergoes translation in the scenario.
0 / 6 correct
Physics Insight
A force can do negative work without having initiated the motion. Friction’s work sign depends on the actual point displacement and selected force.
TEACH — The Feynman Technique
DOK 3 — TeachYour Final Mission: A younger learner’s arms are tired after an ideal steady horizontal carry. Explain why the vertical support force can do zero work on the box while the person still uses metabolic energy. Explain how lifting or vertical bobbing would change the statement.
Use simple words and at least three short sentences. This checks effort; compare your physics with the Vault or your teacher.
Type Your Explanation (≥ 3 sentences)
Draw a labelled explanation with at least three purposeful strokes. This checks effort; compare your physics with the Vault or your teacher.
Cyan pen selected.
Final reward below
Hidden exam secrets inside — Crest's private notebook.
Crest’s Secret Notebook
Mission 4.1 — Work
Choose the force. Follow its point of application.
1. Define the force’s work
For a constant vector force on a translating body:
W = Fd cos θ = F∥d
F is force magnitude in N; d is magnitude of the point-of-application displacement in m; θ is the angle between them. Work is a signed scalar in joules, with 1 J = 1 N·m.
2. Drop the “cause” shortcut
A force need not start the motion to do work. Friction opposing an already moving sliding body does negative work. Perpendicular force does zero work but may affect direction; uniform circular motion is an example.
3. Signs and angles
0° gives +Fd, 90° gives zero and 180° gives −Fd. Angles between 0° and 90° give positive work; between 90° and 180° give negative work. Zero force or zero point displacement also gives zero work.
The angle belongs to force and displacement, not to an arbitrary line in the diagram. A constant 40 N opposing force acting over 9 m does −360 J, even though the distance traveled is positive.
4. Carrying needs a model
In an ideal steady horizontal carry, the hand’s upward support force does zero work on the box because its point moves horizontally at constant height. Gravitational work is also zero for that interval. The person can use metabolic energy internally and generate thermal energy while maintaining muscle tension.
Real walking can include vertical bobbing, deformation and start/stop transitions. Do not claim every carrying task or every force does zero work. Raising a box, for example, gives positive work by upward lifting force.
5. Individual work versus net work
Sum the work by every force. In the translating point-body model, net work equals ΔK. Positive work by one force can be canceled by another’s negative work, leaving speed unchanged.
For extended bodies with rotation, deformation or distinct moving contact points, identify the point of application carefully; do not silently replace every actual work calculation with center-of-mass displacement.
6. Force–displacement graphs
Work is signed area under parallel force versus displacement. A constant force gives a rectangle; a force changing linearly gives a trapezoid or triangle. Area below zero contributes negative work. The final force multiplied by the whole displacement is not valid for a force that changed.
7. Operate the lab
A guided body translates through the chosen displacement in four seconds. The selected force is constant and may oppose the prescribed motion. Other unmodeled forces maintain that motion; the lab calculates selected-force work, not the body’s acceleration.
Pause or step to read displacement and accumulated work. The force vector uses a schematic origin; the lower position trace uses a fixed metre scale. The graph shades only the displacement already traversed. A zero-displacement setup records zero work during the observation interval.
AS 5.1.1 uses force times displacement in the force direction. AP Physics 1 3.2.A also includes work signs, the work–energy theorem and signed force–displacement graph area.
✓ Crest’s Checklist
- I name the force whose work is requested.
- I identify displacement of its point of application.
- I measure θ between force and displacement.
- I retain negative work signs.
- I sum all force work before claiming ΔK.
- I qualify ideal carrying and constant-force assumptions.
— Crest ☆ “Choose the force. Follow its point of application.”
Mission 4.1 Complete! · All 10 levels cleared · PHYSICS CREST
★ Master of Work
Work depends on force and point displacement, not on whether the force started the motion or how tired a person feels.