WONDER — The Mystery
Water at the Top of the Circle
At the top of a sufficiently fast vertical bucket motion, water can stay in contact with the bucket floor. Gravity points downward, toward the circle’s center at that instant. What radial resultant is required, and what can the bucket’s contact force contribute?
Model: Use an inertial frame. Centripetal force means the inward radial resultant, not an extra interaction. For changing speed, a tangential resultant may exist as well. Vertical-loop contact results apply to a particle against the inside of an unrestrained smooth track.
PREDICT — Commit to Your Answer
DOK 2 — PredictA fixed-mass particle needs an inward resultant of 150 N at a particular speed and radius. At the same radius, what is required when its speed doubles?
Commit to both a prediction and a reason before revealing the explanation.
Step 1: Pick your answer.
STOP! Before revealing — why did you pick that?
Correct prediction and reasoning saved.
At fixed mass and radius, the required radial force increases by the square of the speed factor: 2² = 4. Required force is 600 N; a real source must be able to supply it.
▶ PLAY — Live Circle and Tangent Release
DOK 2 — InvestigatePredict, measure and compare
Measure two speeds at the same mass, radius and mode. Then change only mass from one of that pair. Run three matched setups. Use release mode to observe the path when the inward interaction is removed.
A particle moves on a frictionless horizontal plane. Weight and support cancel vertically. A controllable radial interaction supplies the entire horizontal force for uniform circular motion. Mode 0 measures one revolution; mode 1 switches that interaction off after a quarter revolution and follows force-free straight motion for another quarter-period. Speed is constant throughout. The physical angular rate is v/r; the sketch is rescaled to each radius. Arrow directions are exact; lengths are schematic.
Status: Ready
Playback: 2 simulation seconds per real second. Pause or Step for measurements.
Horizontal Force Component vs Time
Measurements
Load givens — then predict and run
Loading a setup earns no trial credit.
♢ DISCOVER — Radial Resultant and Real Interactions
DOK 1 — RecallFlip all 4 rule cards. Keep the quantities and model conditions clear.
Rule 1
Use a radial force equation
Click to flip
Use a radial force equation
ΣFinward = mv²/r = mac. Resolve real forces along the inward direction. Do not draw an extra centripetal force beside tension, gravity or normal force.
Rule 2
Separate radial and tangential changes
Click to flip
Separate radial and tangential changes
The radial acceleration v²/r changes velocity direction. A tangential acceleration changes speed. Only in uniform circular motion is the whole net force purely radial and perpendicular to velocity.
Rule 3
Check the contact model
Click to flip
Check the contact model
At the top of a smooth inside loop, mg + N = mv²/r. Unrestrained contact requires N ≥ 0. At the bottom, N − mg = mv²/r. Weight alone can supply the top’s radial force at the minimum contact speed.
Rule 4
State the reference frame
Click to flip
State the reference frame
An inertial-frame force diagram uses real interactions. A rotating frame can use an apparent centrifugal term when applying a modified equation of motion. That term is not another physical interaction.
All rules explored.
MISCONCEPTION ATTACK — Destroy the Myths
DOK 2 — AnalyzeChoose TRUE or FALSE for each claim. The explanation appears after an attempt; only a correct answer completes the claim.
Myth 1: “At constant speed around a circle, acceleration is zero.”
Correct — the claim is false.
False. Velocity direction changes. Its inward acceleration magnitude is v²/r even when the speed is constant.
Myth 2: “A ball on a string has tension plus an additional centripetal interaction force.”
Correct — the claim is false.
False. If tension supplies the horizontal radial resultant, it is the force used in the radial equation. Adding a separate centripetal force would count the same contribution twice.
Both myths corrected. Continue to the instructor questions.
✦ THE SECOND “AHA!” — Source, Direction and Contact
DOK 2 — ApplyAdd actual force components, rather than inventing a balancing outward interaction.
Instructor Q1 — Remove the Interaction
A particle in uniform circular motion on a frictionless horizontal plane loses its radial interaction. What path follows while no horizontal force acts?
Instructor Q2 — Top of an Inside Loop
For a particle in contact at the top of a smooth inside loop, which real forces have inward components?
Instructor Q3 — Radial Acceleration
A particle moves at 6 m/s on a circle of radius 3 m. Find the inward acceleration magnitude.
Instructor Q4 — Radial Resultant
A 2 kg particle requires inward acceleration 12 m/s². Find its inward radial resultant force.
4/4 — Instructor Questions Completed
Centripetal describes the inward radial resultant. Constant speed still allows acceleration because velocity direction changes.
✎ PRACTICE — Independent Circular-Force Cases
DOK 1–3 — PracticeChallenge 1: A Level Turn
A 1100 kg car moves at constant speed 14 m/s on a level circular path of radius 40 m. Find the required inward horizontal resultant force.
Step-by-Step Solution
ΣFinward = 1100 × 14²/40 = 5390 N. On a suitable level road, static tire–road friction supplies this horizontal resultant.
Challenge 2: A Timed Quarter Turn
A 68 kg runner travels a quarter of a circle of radius 9 m in 1.80 s at constant speed. Find speed, inward acceleration magnitude and inward resultant force magnitude.
Step-by-Step Solution
Arc distance = 2π × 9/4 = 14.137 m. Speed ≈ 7.854 m/s; ac ≈ 6.854 m/s²; inward resultant ≈ 466.065 N.
Challenge 3: Audit the Top-of-Loop Diagram
A 420 kg particle is at the top of the inside of a smooth, unrestrained vertical circular track of radius 8 m, moving at 12 m/s. Use g = 9.8 N/kg. A student draws a separate centripetal force in addition to weight and normal force, draws the normal upward, and says constant speed means zero acceleration. Find the inward radial resultant, track normal magnitude and inward acceleration magnitude at this instant. Explain all three errors.
Step-by-Step Solution
Resultant: ac = 12²/8 = 18 m/s², so ΣFinward = 420 × 18 = 7560 N. This is the sum of real radial components, not an extra force.
Contact: At the top, downward is inward. Weight = 4116 N and N = 7560 − 4116 = 3444 N downward; this positive normal is compatible with inside contact.
Acceleration: Even at constant speed, velocity direction changes, giving inward acceleration. A tangential component would be needed to change speed.
☷ CHALLENGE — Identify the Horizontal Radial Source
DOK 2 — ApplyIdentify the Horizontal Radial Source
Each card gives an ideal uniform circular-motion case in an inertial frame. Choose the real interaction providing its horizontal or orbital radial resultant.
0 / 6 correct
Physics Insight
More than one force can contribute to a radial resultant. Banked turns and vertical loops require resolving the actual forces.
TEACH — The Feynman Technique
DOK 3 — TeachYour Final Mission: Explain a passenger’s apparent sideways shift during a turn using an inertial road frame. Describe inertia, the contact force needed to turn the passenger and why a rotating-frame apparent force is a different description.
Use simple words and at least three short sentences. This checks effort; compare your physics with the Vault or your teacher.
Type Your Explanation (≥ 3 sentences)
Draw a labelled explanation with at least three purposeful strokes. This checks effort; compare your physics with the Vault or your teacher.
Cyan pen selected.
Final reward below
Hidden exam secrets inside — Crest's private notebook.
Crest’s Secret Notebook
Mission 5.1 — Centripetal Force
Identify the real forces. Add their inward components.
1. The inward radial resultant
ac = v²/r; ΣFinward = mv²/r
Use SI mass in kg, speed in m/s and radius in m. Radial acceleration is in m/s² and force in N. Centripetal means toward the local center of a circular path. It identifies a component of the resultant, not a new interaction.
2. Uniform versus changing-speed motion
In uniform circular motion, net force is purely inward and perpendicular to instantaneous velocity. It changes direction without changing speed or K. Its instantaneous power F·v is zero.
If speed changes, a tangential acceleration and tangential net-force component are also present. The radial component still satisfies mv²/r, but the entire resultant need not point to the center. Do not use one finite displacement angle to infer radial work over an arbitrary arc; use the instantaneous perpendicular relationship.
3. Name the real interactions
A level car can turn through static tire–road friction. A string can provide tension. Gravity supplies an ideal circular satellite’s radial resultant. At the top of a vertical inside loop, gravity and normal force contribute together. For a conical pendulum or banked surface, resolve components.
4. Vertical-loop contact
Top: mg + N = mv²/r; bottom: N − mg = mv²/r
For unrestrained contact inside a smooth track, N cannot be negative. At the top, N = 0 gives minimum contact speed √(gr). Below that value the assumed circular contact fails. A restrained roller-coaster car can have other constraint forces, so do not apply this contact limit indiscriminately.
For water remaining against a bucket floor at the top, gravity can supply the inward acceleration at the limiting speed; an additional bucket contact contribution is needed above it. A single tension force on a bucket is not the same force diagram as the forces on its water.
5. Compare factors carefully
At fixed radius and mass, double speed requires four times the radial resultant. At fixed speed and radius, double mass requires twice it. At fixed speed and mass, double radius requires half it. Holding angular speed instead of linear speed gives a different radius dependence: F = mrω².
6. Frame and release
In an inertial frame, draw actual interactions. There is no extra outward centrifugal interaction balancing the inward resultant. Inertia is not a force. A rotating-frame equation may include an apparent centrifugal term; it is a frame term rather than a new physical interaction.
If all horizontal force is removed in the lab, the particle follows its instantaneous tangent velocity in a straight line. A real released bucket or ball with unbalanced gravity would instead follow a projectile path, so the lab explicitly uses a supported horizontal plane.
7. Operate the live lab
Run, pause, step or reset. The angular rate is v/r, so changing radius changes the revolution time correctly. The circle period is T = 2πr/v. Mode 1 releases at T/4; force becomes zero and velocity continues tangent. Position and force components are measured in physical units; diagram and vector lengths are schematic.
The signed Fx–time graph shows the changing horizontal component of an inward rotating force. Its time area is x impulse, not work. K remains constant in both lab modes. Compare two speeds, then a mass change; loading a preset alone earns no measurement credit.
A Level 12.2 covers radial acceleration and force; AP Physics 1 2.9.A includes radial/tangential components and vertical-loop contact.
✓ Crest’s Checklist
- I draw actual interaction forces.
- I add inward components rather than an extra force.
- I distinguish speed from velocity.
- I state whether circular speed is constant.
- I check inside-track contact before using a loop model.
- I state the frame and the release assumptions.
— Crest ☆ “Identify the real forces. Add their inward components.”
Mission 5.1 Complete! · All 10 levels cleared · PHYSICS CREST
★ Master of Centripetal Force
Centripetal describes the inward radial resultant. Constant speed still allows acceleration because velocity direction changes.