WONDER — The Mystery
A Circle and an Ellipse
An ideal circular orbit has constant speed. An ideal bound elliptical orbit under central gravity changes speed around the path. What remains regular about the orbital period, and which distance belongs in each comparison?
Model: Core assessed calculations use circular orbits around a dominant central mass, with negligible satellite mass and gravity only. Elliptical paths, focus geometry and equal-area motion are clearly marked enrichment. The Newtonian two-body approximation excludes significant perturbations.
PREDICT — Commit to Your Answer
DOK 2 — PredictTwo negligible-mass satellites have circular orbits around the same central body. The second radius is 9 times the first. What is the second period as a multiple of the first?
Commit to both a prediction and a reason before revealing the explanation.
Step 1: Pick your answer.
STOP! Before revealing — why did you pick that?
Correct prediction and reasoning saved.
The period factor is √(9³) = 27. The central mass and units must be the same when comparing the coefficient.
▶ PLAY — Live Circular Orbits and Ellipse Enrichment
DOK 2 — InvestigatePredict, measure and compare
Measure circular orbits at two semi-major axes with the same central GM factor. Then change only central GM from one of that pair. Run three matched circular setups. Afterward, explore the optional eccentric orbits, changing speed and swept area.
Ideal dominant fixed center and a negligible orbiting mass. The reference gravitational parameter is defined as 4π² AU³/yr²; q multiplies it. For e = 0, semi-major axis a equals circular radius. The optional e > 0 modes solve Kepler’s equation, place the source at a focus and trace equal-area motion. Elapsed model time is in years; playback is accelerated and labelled. This is a defined reference-star model, not an exact claim about real planetary data.
Status: Ready
Playback: 0.25 simulation years per real second. Pause or Step for measurements.
Swept Area vs Elapsed Model Time
Measurements
Load givens — then predict and run
Loading a setup earns no trial credit.
♢ DISCOVER — Third Law and Its Boundaries
DOK 1 — RecallFlip all 4 rule cards. Keep the quantities and model conditions clear.
Rule 1
Use a circular radius in the core law
Click to flip
Use a circular radius in the core law
For a negligible satellite in circular orbit, T²/r³ = 4π²/(GM). r is distance from the central body’s center, not altitude above its surface.
Rule 2
Compare a common central source
Click to flip
Compare a common central source
For the same central mass, T2/T1 = (r2/r1)^(3/2). Across different central masses, include √(M1/M2). The coefficient has units and depends on the central GM; it is not universally 1.
Rule 3
Connect period to circular speed
Click to flip
Connect period to circular speed
Gravity gives v = √(GM/r) and T = 2πr/v. For fixed central M, increasing r lowers circular speed and increases period. The negligible satellite’s mass cancels.
Rule 4
Label ellipse enrichment
Click to flip
Label ellipse enrichment
A bound two-body orbit is an ellipse with a source at one focus; a circle is the zero-eccentricity case. Equal areas are swept in equal times. For an ellipse the third-law distance is semi-major axis a, not its changing instantaneous separation.
All rules explored.
MISCONCEPTION ATTACK — Destroy the Myths
DOK 2 — AnalyzeChoose TRUE or FALSE for each claim. The explanation appears after an attempt; only a correct answer completes the claim.
Myth 1: “T²/r³ is the dimensionless number 1 for every orbit around every central body.”
Correct — the claim is false.
False. The coefficient has units, changes with central mass and takes a convenient near-1 value only for a specified reference source and unit convention.
Myth 2: “A circular satellite must fire an engine continuously because gravity would otherwise stop its sideways motion.”
Correct — the claim is false.
False in the ideal gravity-only orbit. Gravity continuously accelerates the moving satellite toward the center; no continuous propulsion is needed. Real drag or perturbations may require corrections.
Both myths corrected. Continue to the instructor questions.
✦ THE SECOND “AHA!” — Central Mass, Radius and Period
DOK 2 — ApplyCore calculations use circular orbits. Do not treat a changing elliptical distance as a circular orbital radius.
Instructor Q1 — Change the Central Mass
Two central bodies have different masses. Must their circular satellites share the same T²/r³ coefficient?
Instructor Q2 — Define Circular Radius
Which distance belongs in the circular third-law equation for a satellite around a spherical planet?
Instructor Q3 — Double Circular Radius
A circular satellite has period 3 h. A second circular satellite around the same central body has twice its radius. Find the second period.
Instructor Q4 — Double Central Mass
At a fixed circular radius, a reference orbit has period 10 h. Find the period if central mass doubles and satellite mass remains negligible.
4/4 — Instructor Questions Completed
The third-law coefficient depends on the central gravitational parameter and units. Ellipse geometry is useful enrichment, with semi-major axis replacing circular radius.
✎ PRACTICE — Independent Circular-Orbit Comparisons
DOK 1–3 — PracticeChallenge 1: Two Circular Satellites
Two negligible-mass satellites orbit the same central body on circles of radii 9000 km and 14,400 km. The inner satellite’s period is 2.40 h. Find the outer period.
Step-by-Step Solution
Touter/Tinner = (14,400/9000)^(3/2). Touter = 2.40 × 1.60^(3/2) ≈ 4.857 h.
Challenge 2: Infer an Orbital Radius
A reference circular satellite at radius 12,000 km has period 4.00 h. Another negligible-mass circular satellite around the same central body has period 13.50 h. Find its orbital radius.
Step-by-Step Solution
r2/r1 = (13.50/4.00)^(2/3) = 2.25. New radius = 27,000 km.
Challenge 3: Audit Two Central Bodies
Satellite A orbits a central body of mass M at circular radius r with period 6.00 h. Satellite B has negligible mass and orbits a central body of mass 4M at circular radius 2r. A student says the T²/r³ coefficient is universal even for different central masses, says doubling radius always doubles period, and says doubling B’s still-negligible mass would double its period. Find B’s period and its circular speed as a ratio to A’s speed. Explain all three errors.
Step-by-Step Solution
Source: The coefficient is inversely proportional to central mass, so B’s coefficient is one quarter of A’s.
Period: TB/TA = √(2³/4) = √2. TB ≈ 8.485 h. Doubling radius is not a linear period rule.
Speed and mass: vB/vA = √(4/2) = √2. A negligible satellite’s own mass cancels, so doubling B’s still-negligible mass does not double its period.
☷ CHALLENGE — Separate Core Orbit Relations and Enrichment
DOK 2 — ApplySeparate Core Orbit Relations and Enrichment
Classify the statements by their role in this mission. The first and second laws are enrichment beyond the current AP Physics 1 required circular third-law outcome.
0 / 6 correct
Physics Insight
Bound Kepler ellipses approximate isolated two-body gravity. Do not extend these claims to every path or every multi-body system without checking the model.
TEACH — The Feynman Technique
DOK 3 — TeachYour Final Mission: Explain why a circular satellite keeps moving under gravity without continuous propulsion. Explain why a satellite at a larger circular radius around the same body takes longer, and why a different central mass changes the period comparison.
Use simple words and at least three short sentences. This checks effort; compare your physics with the Vault or your teacher.
Type Your Explanation (≥ 3 sentences)
Draw a labelled explanation with at least three purposeful strokes. This checks effort; compare your physics with the Vault or your teacher.
Cyan pen selected.
Final reward below
Hidden exam secrets inside — Crest's private notebook.
Crest’s Secret Notebook
Mission 5.3 — Kepler’s Laws
Compare the same central mass. State the orbit model.
1. Required circular third-law model
T²/r³ = 4π²/(GM)
Use the distance from the central body’s center, with consistent units. The central body dominates and satellite mass is negligible. The coefficient has dimensions time²/length³ and depends on central GM. It is not a universal dimensionless 1.
2. Derive from gravity and circular motion
Set GMm/r² = mv²/r and use v = 2πr/T. Cancel the negligible satellite’s mass and rearrange to GM T² = 4π²r³. This gives the third law and v = √(GM/r).
For a genuine two-body relative orbit with neither mass negligible, the gravitational parameter is G(M + m). The small-satellite approximation explains why its own mass drops out of our core tasks.
3. Compare periods
T2/T1 = (r2/r1)^(3/2) √(M1/M2)
For the same source, the mass factor is 1. Doubling radius gives √8 times the period; doubling central mass at fixed radius gives 1/√2 times the period. Recover radius by a two-thirds power. A larger circular radius around the same source gives slower orbital speed.
4. Enrichment: bound ellipses and the focus
Kepler’s first law describes an ideal bound two-body orbit as an ellipse, with the dominant source at one focus in the negligible-orbiting-mass picture. An ellipse has a center as well as two foci. A circle is its zero-eccentricity special case.
For an ellipse, use semi-major axis a in T²/a³, not the changing instantaneous source distance. The semi-major axis is half the longest diameter. Unbound parabolic or hyperbolic trajectories and strongly perturbed multi-body paths are outside this bound-orbit statement.
5. Enrichment: equal areas
A source-to-body line sweeps equal areas in equal times under central gravity. The body moves faster near periapsis and slower near apoapsis. Equal areas are curved orbital sectors, not a claim that every pair of arbitrary triangles has equal area.
Gravity points toward the focus; in an eccentric orbit it can have a tangential component relative to the velocity and change speed. It need not be perpendicular to velocity except at special positions.
6. The live reference-star model
The model defines μ = 4π²q AU³/yr², where q is the chosen central-GM factor. Thus T = √(a³/q) yr and the displayed coefficient is 1/q yr²/AU³. This convenient normalization is a stated model choice.
Core matched trials use e = 0. Optional e > 0 modes solve E − e sin E = 2πt/T, so changing speed and swept area follow the orbit dynamics. The source is drawn at the focus. The area graph is linear in model time, while the live marker changes speed along an eccentric path.
Run, pause, step and reset. Physical model time is years, with the playback rate shown separately. The orbit drawing and velocity-arrow length are schematic. Compare two circular radii, then a central-GM change before exploring enrichment.
7. Satellites and limits
An ideal orbiting satellite is continually accelerated by gravity while retaining sufficient sideways motion. Gravity does not need an outward balancing interaction. Continuous propulsion is unnecessary in the ideal vacuum model; drag and real perturbations can require station-keeping.
AP Physics 1 2.9.B requires quantitative circular Kepler-third-law analysis and explicitly excludes required knowledge of the first and second laws. A Level 13.2.3 requires circular-orbit analysis; the named first and second laws here remain enrichment.
✓ Crest’s Checklist
- I state the central source and negligible-mass assumption.
- I use center distance for a circular orbit.
- I compare coefficients in consistent units.
- I include central-mass changes in period comparisons.
- I use semi-major axis only in the labelled ellipse model.
- I keep required circular outcomes separate from enrichment.
— Crest ☆ “Compare the same central mass. State the orbit model.”
Mission 5.3 Complete! · All 10 levels cleared · PHYSICS CREST
★ Master of Kepler’s Third Law
The third-law coefficient depends on the central gravitational parameter and units. Ellipse geometry is useful enrichment, with semi-major axis replacing circular radius.