WONDER — The Mystery
Falling Together
A passenger and an ideal elevator start with the same vertical velocity. Both then fall freely in the same uniform gravitational field. Gravity still pulls on the passenger. What happens to the scale reading and the passenger’s position relative to the floor?
Model: An ideal scale reports the upward support force in newtons. The vertical elevator model uses uniform g = 9.8 m/s², upward positive, and no air resistance, collisions or restraints. It separates acceleration from direction of travel. Ideal free fall can have gravity present; apparent weightlessness can also occur where external forces are negligible.
PREDICT — Commit to Your Answer
DOK 2 — PredictA 60 kg passenger moves downward at 3.0 m/s in an elevator whose acceleration is upward at 2.0 m/s². Take g = 9.8 m/s². While the passenger remains on the scale, what does it read?
Commit to both a prediction and a reason before revealing the explanation.
Step 1: Pick your answer.
STOP! Before revealing — why did you pick that?
Correct prediction and reasoning saved.
N = 60(9.8 + 2.0) = 708 N. The passenger is moving downward but slowing down. Gravitational force stays 588 N in this uniform field; the upward support force exceeds it.
▶ PLAY — Live Elevator and Passenger
DOK 2 — InvestigatePredict, measure and compare
Measure two accelerations at the same mass and initial velocity. Then change only mass from one of that pair. Compare three matched setups. Explore downward travel with upward acceleration, constant velocity and free fall. Watch the cabin and passenger move against a fixed shaft reference.
Upward is positive. Uniform g = 9.8 m/s²; the selected acceleration remains constant for a 2 s physical interval. Initial velocity is independent of acceleration. The passenger and cabin share position change and velocity. The acceleration range stops at −g: the floor cannot pull the passenger downward. At −g the scale force is zero. Each 2 s model run is shown over 8 real seconds. Motion is rescaled within each run; shaft markings stay fixed. The cabin has no boundary collisions in this ideal model.
Status: Ready
Playback: 8 real seconds per run; read elapsed physical model time. Pause or Step for measurements.
Signed Velocity vs Physical Time
Measurements
Load givens — then predict and run
Loading a setup earns no trial credit.
♢ DISCOVER — Gravity, Support and Shared Free Fall
DOK 1 — RecallFlip all 4 rule cards. Keep the quantities and model conditions clear.
Rule 1
A scale measures support
Click to flip
A scale measures support
Here apparent weight is the upward normal force N, measured in N. Gravity is mg downward. A display calibrated in kg divides support force by a calibration g; it does not show a change in physical mass.
Rule 2
Acceleration determines the reading
Click to flip
Acceleration determines the reading
With upward positive and sustained floor contact, N − mg = ma, so N = m(g + a). N = mg whenever a = 0: both rest and constant velocity. Downward velocity can coexist with upward acceleration and N > mg.
Rule 3
Ideal free fall has zero support
Click to flip
Ideal free fall has zero support
At a = −g, N = 0 while gravity remains mg. Passenger and cabin with equal initial velocities in the same uniform field have no relative acceleration. Floating relative to the cabin does not mean stationary in an inertial view.
Rule 4
Respect the contact limit
Click to flip
Respect the contact limit
An unrestrained floor can push upward but cannot pull downward. If the cabin is driven downward faster than g, N = m(g + acabin) would be negative and the contact assumption fails. The passenger detaches and accelerates downward at g until another contact occurs.
All rules explored.
MISCONCEPTION ATTACK — Destroy the Myths
DOK 2 — AnalyzeChoose TRUE or FALSE for each claim. The explanation appears after an attempt; only a correct answer completes the claim.
Myth 1: “A passenger moving downward must always have a scale reading smaller than mg.”
Correct — the claim is false.
False. Velocity gives direction of travel; acceleration determines the force difference. Downward motion slowing down has upward acceleration and N > mg.
Myth 2: “A zero scale reading proves both gravitational force and the passenger’s mass are zero.”
Correct — the claim is false.
False. In ideal free fall the support force is zero even though mass remains and gravity still acts.
Both myths corrected. Continue to the instructor questions.
✦ THE SECOND “AHA!” — Travel Direction Is Not Acceleration
DOK 2 — ApplyKeep the floor-contact condition, upward-positive signs and distinction between support and gravity explicit.
Instructor Q1 — Constant Downward Velocity
An elevator travels downward at constant velocity. A passenger stays on its scale. How does N compare with mg?
Instructor Q2 — Why an Astronaut Floats
In an ideal gravity-only orbit, the cabin and a nearby astronaut share the same local gravitational acceleration. Why can the astronaut float relative to the cabin?
Instructor Q3 — Infer Downward Acceleration
A 65 kg passenger remains on a scale reading 520 N. Take g = 9.8 m/s². Find the magnitude of the passenger’s downward acceleration.
Instructor Q4 — Gravity in Free Fall
A 75 kg astronaut is in ideal local free fall where gravitational field strength is 8.6 N/kg. Find the gravitational force magnitude, even though the support force is zero.
4/4 — Instructor Questions Completed
Zero scale force does not imply zero gravity or zero mass. Shared free fall explains ideal floating; acceleration determines the reading while contact persists.
✎ PRACTICE — Independent Support-Force Cases
DOK 1–3 — PracticeChallenge 1: Descending and Slowing
A 76 kg passenger stays on a scale in an elevator moving downward at 6.0 m/s and accelerating upward at 1.2 m/s². Take g = 9.8 m/s². Find the scale force magnitude.
Step-by-Step Solution
Use upward positive: N − 76(9.8) = 76(1.2). Hence N = 76(11.0) = 836 N. Downward travel is slowing; the reading exceeds mg = 744.8 N.
Challenge 2: Infer Motion from a Reading
A 92 kg passenger stays on a scale reading 680 N in a uniform field g = 9.8 m/s². The elevator initially travels upward at 5.0 m/s. The reading stays constant for 1.50 s. Find the downward acceleration magnitude and the passenger’s speed at the end of that interval.
Step-by-Step Solution
Upward-positive acceleration a = 680/92 − 9.8 ≈ -2.408696 m/s². Downward magnitude is 2.408696 m/s².
Final velocity = 5.0 + a(1.50) ≈ 1.386957 m/s upward, so the final speed is 1.386957 m/s. The passenger has slowed but has not yet reversed.
Challenge 3: Audit Three Elevator Claims
Use uniform g = 9.8 m/s² and a 64 kg passenger. In A the elevator moves downward at 5.0 m/s but accelerates upward at 1.6 m/s², with floor contact. In B passenger and cabin begin ideal free fall with equal initial velocities. In C an unrestrained passenger initially touches the floor with the same velocity, then the tall cabin is driven downward at 12.0 m/s² for 1.00 s; ignore collisions. A report says A must read below mg because it moves down, B has zero mass and zero gravitational force because the scale reads zero, and C keeps contact with a negative scale force. Find A’s scale force, the gravitational force in all three cases, B’s scale force and C’s passenger-to-floor separation after 1.00 s. Explain and correct all three claims, including C’s actual passenger motion.
Step-by-Step Solution
A: Upward acceleration gives N = 64(9.8 + 1.6) = 729.6 N, larger than mg = 627.2 N, despite downward velocity.
B: Support is zero in shared free fall, while mass stays 64 kg and gravitational force stays 627.2 N in this uniform field.
C: Imposing the cabin acceleration on the passenger would require N = 64(9.8 − 12.0) = −140.8 N. An unrestrained floor cannot pull, so contact is lost. Actual passenger acceleration is −9.8 m/s² and N = 0. Relative upward acceleration is 12.0 − 9.8 = 2.2 m/s². With zero initial relative velocity, the separation is ½(2.2)(1.00)² = 1.10 m. The tall-cabin model excludes a ceiling collision.
☷ CHALLENGE — Compare Support with Gravity
DOK 2 — ApplyCompare Support with Gravity
Sort the scale force compared with the gravitational force. Use g = 9.8 m/s² and sustained floor contact; ideal free fall has zero support.
0 / 6 correct
Physics Insight
The scale responds to the force needed for acceleration, not to a label such as “going down.”
TEACH — The Feynman Technique
DOK 3 — TeachYour Final Mission: Explain why a passenger can travel downward and feel heavier, why constant velocity gives the same reading as rest, and why a passenger and cabin starting with equal velocities can fall together with zero scale reading while gravity remains. State what changes if the floor is forced downward faster than g.
Use simple words and at least three short sentences. This checks effort; compare your physics with the Vault or your teacher.
Type Your Explanation (≥ 3 sentences)
Draw a labelled explanation with at least three purposeful strokes. This checks effort; compare your physics with the Vault or your teacher.
Cyan pen selected.
Final reward below
Hidden exam secrets inside — Crest's private notebook.
Crest’s Secret Notebook
Mission 5.6 — Weightlessness
Follow the acceleration. Separate gravity from support.
1. Two different forces
Gravitational force: mg downward · Apparent weight here: N upward
The ideal floor scale reports its normal support force in newtons. This is different from gravitational weight, although their magnitudes often match. A familiar feeling of heaviness comes mainly from support forces within the body. Do not claim that every non-contact force is impossible to sense.
Some bathroom scales display a mass-calibrated value, N divided by a calibration g. Physical mass does not change just because the lift accelerates or the display changes.
2. Choose a sign and state contact
Upward positive: N − mg = ma; N = m(g + a)
This equation uses the passenger’s acceleration. If the passenger remains on the floor, it equals the cabin acceleration. It assumes gravity and upward normal support are the only vertical forces on the passenger. Tension, restraints or a ceiling contact require a different force model.
For an unrestrained passenger on a floor, N ≥ 0. The contact formula is valid for cabin acceleration a ≥ −g under the stated initial contact conditions. A negative algebraic N signals loss of the contact assumption; it is not a downward push from the floor.
3. Velocity is independent of acceleration
N > mg for upward acceleration, N = mg for zero acceleration, and N < mg for downward acceleration in the contact range. N = mg at rest and at any constant vertical velocity. Zero acceleration does not require zero velocity.
A downward-moving cabin that slows has upward acceleration and a larger support force. An upward-moving cabin that slows has downward acceleration and a smaller support force. Use the acceleration, not the travel direction.
4. Shared ideal free fall
a = −g ⇒ N = 0; gravitational force remains mg
When cabin and passenger start with equal velocities in the same uniform gravitational field, their relative acceleration and relative velocity are zero. Both can move rapidly downward in an inertial view while maintaining their separation. A zero scale reading does not mean zero gravity, zero physical mass or no motion.
If the initial relative velocities differ, objects can drift or meet a wall even though both fall freely. Field gradients and real disturbances also prevent perfectly identical accelerations. The lab excludes these effects.
5. Floor driven faster than free fall
A cabin driven downward faster than g would need a negative normal force to keep an unrestrained passenger attached. The floor cannot pull. The passenger loses support and follows gravity-only acceleration −g until another interaction occurs, while the floor accelerates away faster.
For equal initial velocities: relative upward acceleration = −g − acabin
Calculate the growing gap from the two actual motions. Do not use the cabin acceleration in the passenger’s contact equation after detachment.
6. Ideal orbit and apparent weightlessness
Gravity remains in a gravitationally bound orbit and provides inward acceleration. The nearby cabin and astronaut share approximately the same local free fall, so an unsupported astronaut has negligible scale force. Orbital motion is motion in an inertial frame, even when the astronaut’s location relative to the cabin changes little.
Ideal free fall is gravity-only motion. Real spacecraft have small disturbances and field gradients, so “microgravity” describes small residual apparent-weight effects rather than a claim that the planetary gravitational field vanishes.
Apparent weightlessness can also occur where external forces are negligible. Gravity is required for the ideal gravity-bound orbit described here; it is not required for every possible situation with zero support force.
7. Use the live elevator
The model sets g = 9.8 m/s², mass from 40 to 120 kg, upward-positive acceleration from −9.8 to +12 m/s² and independent initial velocity from −6 to +6 m/s. Each run lasts 2 physical seconds, played over 8 real seconds. Pause, step and reset work without changing the chosen givens.
y = u t + ½a t²; v = u + a t
The cabin and passenger visibly move against the fixed shaft markings. The position scale is rescaled within each run and readouts supply exact physical displacement. Purple is the passenger; cyan is upward support and yellow is downward gravity. Force arrow lengths use one common force scale. At free fall the support arrow disappears while the gravity arrow remains.
The signed velocity graph develops over elapsed model time. Changing mass alone changes both forces proportionally but leaves displacement, velocity and the ratio N/(mg) unchanged. Changing acceleration alters the trajectory and ratio.
8. Model scope and syllabus
Gravitational force remains constant here because mass and uniform g are fixed within a run. It is not constant everywhere in space. Use local field strength for another altitude or planet.
AS & A Level 3.1 Newton’s laws supports the elevator application; A Level 13.2 supports circular orbital gravity. AP Physics 1 2.6.C explicitly covers normal force as apparent weight and ideal weightlessness; 2.9 supplies circular motion.
✓ Crest’s Checklist
- I distinguish mass, gravitational force and apparent weight.
- I use acceleration rather than travel direction.
- I include constant velocity among zero-acceleration cases.
- I state the sign convention and contact assumption.
- I explain shared free fall without removing gravity.
- I reject negative floor support and model detachment.
— Crest ☆ “Follow the acceleration. Separate gravity from support.”
Mission 5.6 Complete! · All 10 levels cleared · PHYSICS CREST
★ Master of Weightlessness
Zero scale force does not imply zero gravity or zero mass. Shared free fall explains ideal floating; acceleration determines the reading while contact persists.