WONDER — The Mystery
A Longer Handle, the Same Push
A force applied to a wrench can have a turning effect about the bolt. Increasing the distance from the bolt helps only if the force has a perpendicular component. A large force directed along the handle can have zero moment about the bolt. What geometry determines the turning effect?
Model: Planar forces about a stated axis. CCW moments are positive. Radius r means axis-to-application distance; the moment arm is the perpendicular distance from the axis to the force’s line of action. The live lab uses a frictionless fixed axle and stated inertia to produce actual motion; torque alone does not determine a static swing angle.
PREDICT — Commit to Your Answer
DOK 2 — PredictA force of fixed magnitude is applied at a fixed distance from a pivot. For which angle between the outward radius and force is the torque magnitude greatest?
Commit to both a prediction and a reason before revealing the explanation.
Step 1: Pick your answer.
STOP! Before revealing — why did you pick that?
Correct prediction and reasoning saved.
|τ| = rF|sin β| is greatest at 90° between radius and force. At 0° or 180° the line of action passes through the pivot and torque is zero.
▶ PLAY — Live Lever and Force Line of Action
DOK 2 — InvestigatePredict, measure and compare
Complete two runs changing only application radius, then a third changing only force from one of that pair. Compare their torques and motion. Try angled, radial and clockwise-force presets. Watch the lever and the dashed perpendicular moment arm move together.
A lightweight adjustable lever is attached to a rotor with fixed total rotational inertia 3 kg·m² about a frictionless axle. It starts from rest and runs for 1.5 physical seconds, played over 8 real seconds. An actuator keeps the force at the selected angle β relative to the rotating outward radius, so torque is constant; force direction rotates with the lever. CCW is positive. The application radius uses 75 pixels/m; force arrow length scales with force. The dashed yellow segment is the perpendicular moment arm. Dynamics uses α = τ/I, developed in Mission 6.8.
Status: Ready
Playback: 8 real seconds per run; read elapsed physical model time. Pause or Step for measurements.
Measurements
Load givens — then predict and run
Loading a setup earns no trial credit.
♢ DISCOVER — Geometry, Signs and Net Moment
DOK 1 — RecallFlip all 4 rule cards. Keep the quantities and model conditions clear.
Rule 1
Define the moment arm
Click to flip
Define the moment arm
Torque magnitude = Fd⊥ = rF|sin β|. Here d⊥ is the shortest perpendicular distance from axis to the force line of action; r is the axis-to-application distance. They coincide only for a perpendicular force.
Rule 2
Radial force gives zero torque
Click to flip
Radial force gives zero torque
A force whose line of action passes through the axis has zero moment about that axis. A pedal at its lowest point under a vertical downward force is radial, not perpendicular: zero axle torque.
Rule 3
Add moments about one axis
Click to flip
Add moments about one axis
Use CCW positive and CW negative about the same stated axis. Zero net torque means no angular acceleration for a rigid body with fixed inertia, not necessarily zero angular velocity. Complete equilibrium also requires zero net force.
Rule 4
Torque, work and a couple
Click to flip
Torque, work and a couple
Torque is a turning effect, reported in N·m. Work is energy transferred by displacement, reported in J. Equal opposite noncollinear forces form a couple: net force zero but torque generally nonzero, with magnitude F times their perpendicular separation.
All rules explored.
MISCONCEPTION ATTACK — Destroy the Myths
DOK 2 — AnalyzeChoose TRUE or FALSE for each claim. The explanation appears after an attempt; only a correct answer completes the claim.
Myth 1: “A downward force produces maximum torque when a pedal is at its lowest point.”
Correct — the claim is false.
False. At the lowest point the force is along the radius and its line of action passes through the axle. With a horizontal crank, a vertical force is perpendicular and gives the greatest torque for the same force and radius.
Myth 2: “Zero net torque means the body cannot be rotating.”
Correct — the claim is false.
False. With fixed inertia, zero net torque means zero angular acceleration. A body already rotating can maintain constant angular velocity.
Both myths corrected. Continue to the instructor questions.
✦ THE SECOND “AHA!” — Perpendicular Distance and Couples
DOK 2 — ApplyAll moments are about the specified pivot, with CCW positive.
Instructor Q1 — Along a Wrench
A force points exactly along a wrench handle toward its bolt. What is its torque about the bolt?
Instructor Q2 — A Couple
Two equal opposite parallel forces act along different lines of action on one body. Which description applies?
Instructor Q3 — A Perpendicular Push
A 16 N upward force acts 0.45 m to the right of a pivot on a horizontal lever. Find the signed moment.
Instructor Q4 — Given the Moment Arm
A force of magnitude 24 N has its line of action 0.35 m perpendicular distance from an axis. Find its torque magnitude.
4/4 — Instructor Questions Completed
A line of action through the axis has zero moment, even for a large force. Force balance and moment balance are separate tests.
✎ PRACTICE — Independent Moment Calculations and Audit
DOK 1–3 — PracticeChallenge 1: A Hanging Load
A 130 N downward force acts on a horizontal beam 2.4 m to the right of a pivot. CCW is positive. Find its signed torque about the pivot.
Step-by-Step Solution
The force is perpendicular to the radius, so magnitude = 130(2.4) = 312 N·m. A downward force to the right turns clockwise: τ = −312 N·m.
Challenge 2: A Pedal at Two Positions
A rider applies a vertical downward force equal in magnitude to the weight of a 52 kg mass. Take g = 9.8 m/s². The crank radius is 0.18 m, and initially the crank points 40° above the horizontal to the right. Find the force magnitude and axle torque magnitude in this position. Then find the torque magnitude if the same downward force is applied when the pedal is at the lowest point.
Step-by-Step Solution
Force magnitude = 52(9.8) = 509.6 N. The vertical force line has horizontal moment arm 0.18 cos40°, so initial torque magnitude = 509.6(0.18 cos40°) ≈ 70.267725 N·m, clockwise.
At the lowest point both radius and force are vertical and downward. The line of action passes through the axle, so torque is zero. Maximum magnitude for this force occurs when the crank is horizontal: 509.6(0.18) = 91.728 N·m.
Challenge 3: Audit a Force-Couple Report
A horizontal bar receives an upward 5.0 N force at x = 0.40 m and a downward 5.0 N force at x = 0.80 m. Coordinates are measured rightward from pivot O at x = 0. CCW is positive. A report says equal opposite forces cancel their torques, adds the two application distances to get the couple arm, and calls the torque an energy in joules. Find the signed net vertical force, signed net torque about O and signed net torque about a new reference point at x = 2.0 m. Explain all three errors and why the torque is unchanged by moving the reference point in this case.
Step-by-Step Solution
Net vertical force = +5 − 5 = 0 N. About O, moments are +(0.40)(5) = +2 N·m and −(0.80)(5) = −4 N·m. Net = −2 N·m.
The couple’s perpendicular separation is 0.80 − 0.40 = 0.40 m, not their summed distances. Magnitude = 5(0.40) = 2 N·m, clockwise.
About x = 2.0 m, signed position distances are −1.60 and −1.20 m. Moments are −8 and +6 N·m, again net −2 N·m. A couple’s moment is independent of reference point because the net force is zero.
Torque describes a turning effect, not energy. Although its dimensions match those of work, report it in N·m; a joule denotes energy. A couple can change rotation despite its zero resultant force.
☷ CHALLENGE — Separate Force, Moment and Energy
DOK 2 — ApplySeparate Force, Moment and Energy
Sort each statement by the physical quantity or balance it describes.
0 / 6 correct
Physics Insight
Matching dimensions do not make two physical quantities interchangeable.
TEACH — The Feynman Technique
DOK 3 — TeachYour Final Mission: Explain why a longer wrench increases torque for the same perpendicular force, why pushing along it gives zero torque, and why zero net torque can coexist with rotation. Include the difference between radius and perpendicular moment arm.
Use simple words and at least three short sentences. This checks effort; compare your physics with the Vault or your teacher.
Type Your Explanation (≥ 3 sentences)
Draw a labelled explanation with at least three purposeful strokes. This checks effort; compare your physics with the Vault or your teacher.
Cyan pen selected.
Final reward below
Hidden exam secrets inside — Crest's private notebook.
Crest’s Secret Notebook
Mission 6.4 — Torque and Moment of a Force
Locate the axis. Find the perpendicular distance.
1. Moment of a force about an axis
Torque magnitude = Fd⊥ = rF|sin β|
r is the distance from the axis to the point where the force acts. The moment arm d⊥ is the perpendicular distance from that axis to the entire line of action of the force. A longer r increases torque only with a nonzero perpendicular force component. The angle β is measured between the outward radius and force direction.
The lab uses a signed planar angle, CCW positive: τ = rF sin β. For ordinary unsigned angles between vectors, rF sin β gives magnitude; assign clockwise or counterclockwise sense from the diagram. This mission does not require three-dimensional torque-vector calculations.
2. Components and zero moment
Signed tangential component = F sin β; radial component = F cos β
The tangential component contributes the axle moment rF sin β. The radial component has a line of action through the axis and gives zero moment about that axis. It can still contribute to forces or stresses; calling it universally “wasted” is misleading.
At β = 0° or 180° the moment is zero. At ±90° its magnitude is maximum for fixed F and r. At 30°, the perpendicular component is half the force, while the radial component is about 0.866 of it: the “other half” does not describe the radial component.
3. The pedal correction
For a vertical downward pedal force, the relevant moment arm is the horizontal distance of the pedal from the axle. With a horizontal crank this equals its radius and torque magnitude is maximum. At the lowest or highest pedal point the vertical line of action passes through the axle and torque is zero.
If a crank makes angle φ above horizontal, the vertical-force moment magnitude is Fr|cos φ|. The angle φ is not the angle β between radius and force; distinguish the reference directions in the diagram before choosing sine or cosine.
4. Sum moments consistently
Choose one reference axis and a sign convention. Add all signed moments about that same axis. Forces through the reference axis contribute zero moment there, but still belong in the force balance. Moving the reference point can change a single force’s moment.
Zero net moment does not mean no forces, nor no rotation. For a fixed-inertia rigid rotor it means zero angular acceleration. An initially rotating rotor can continue uniformly. Full static equilibrium requires zero resultant force, zero resultant moment and initially stationary motion. Mission 6.6 develops equilibrium.
5. A couple
A couple consists of two equal opposite parallel forces with separate lines of action. Net force is zero. The couple moment magnitude is F times the perpendicular separation between those lines, with the rotational sense determined from the diagram.
Do not add arbitrary axis-to-application distances: for two forces on the same side of a reference point, their relevant separation may be a difference. A couple’s net moment is independent of reference point because shifting the reference changes moments by a term proportional to the zero resultant force.
6. Torque and work
Torque is a turning effect about an axis, with unit N·m. Work is energy transfer, with unit joule. Their dimensions match, but their physical meanings differ. A force can have torque before any angular displacement occurs; this does not imply it has already transferred energy.
For a fixed-axis rotation, work from a constant torque can be τΔθ when signs and radians are consistent. This relationship connects different quantities without making torque itself energy. Work depends on displacement as well as torque.
7. The live torque lab
A lightweight lever acts on a rotor with fixed total inertia 3 kg·m². The actuator maintains the selected angle relative to the rotating radius, so the force direction itself rotates and the torque remains constant. The axle supplies any required constraint force through the pivot; it gives no axle moment. There is no frictional axle torque in the model.
The rotor starts from rest. Its angular acceleration is τ/I, and its angular position is ½(τ/I)t². This supplies a physical moving demonstration instead of an arbitrary swing angle proportional only to torque. A fixed direction force on a rotating lever would instead change its relative angle and generally produce varying torque; that is a different model.
Each run covers 1.5 physical seconds over 8 real seconds. The yellow dashed segment is the perpendicular moment arm; the cyan arrow is the applied force. Radius has a fixed drawing scale, and force arrow lengths scale with force. Run, pause, step and reset share the physical state. Three matched completed runs isolate radius and force effects.
8. Course boundary
Cambridge AS Level 9702 4.1 covers moments and couples, and 4.2 the principle of moments. The previous “4.4 torque” label was incorrect. AP Physics 1 topic 5.3 requires torque magnitudes and force diagrams; its boundary excludes formal torque direction-vector mathematics. Simple planar turning sense here supports the sign convention used in rotational dynamics without introducing vector algebra.
✓ Crest’s Checklist
- I locate the axis and force application point.
- I find perpendicular distance to the force line of action.
- I identify which reference direction defines an angle.
- I assign a consistent planar turning sense.
- I keep force balance separate from moment balance.
- I use separation between lines for a couple.
- I distinguish torque in N·m from energy in J.
— Crest ☆ “Locate the axis. Find the perpendicular distance.”
Mission 6.4 Complete! · All 10 levels cleared · PHYSICS CREST
★ Master of Torque
A line of action through the axis has zero moment, even for a large force. Force balance and moment balance are separate tests.