WONDER — The Mystery
The Faster Jet Need Not Travel Farthest
A deeper hole in an open tank gives greater exit speed under the ideal large-tank model. But a lower hole also leaves less falling time before the jet lands. As the tank drains, which speed belongs to a parcel already in the air?
Model: Open tank and free jet at the same atmospheric pressure; incompressible inviscid flow, negligible losses and quasi-steady drainage. The tank area is much larger than the outlet area, so free-surface speed is neglected. Head h is surface height above the hole, not above the ground. A horizontal airborne parcel then follows projectile motion without air resistance. Side-hole drainage stops when the surface reaches the hole and leaves liquid below it.
PREDICT — Commit to Your Answer
DOK 2 — PredictTwo small outlets have vertical heads h and 2h beneath the same open-tank free surface. Under the ideal large-tank assumptions, how does the deeper outlet’s speed compare?
Commit to both a prediction and a reason before revealing the explanation.
Step 1: Pick your answer.
STOP! Before revealing — why did you pick that?
Correct prediction and reasoning saved.
Torricelli gives v = √(2gh). Doubling h multiplies v by √2. Outlet area changes ideal volume flow Q = av at a specified head, not this large-tank speed relation.
▶ PLAY — Live Draining Tank and Moving Jet Parcels
DOK 2 — InvestigatePredict, measure and compare
Compare two initial heads with tank area, hole area and hole height unchanged. Then change only hole area from one of that pair. Complete three runs. Watch the surface descend and jet parcels move. Compare changing speed, flow, drained volume and instantaneous range.
Tank area A = 0.050 m²; outlet area a is 0.00010–0.00050 m², so a/A is at most 0.01. g = 9.8 m/s². An open side outlet launches horizontally at fixed height z above the ground. The quasi-steady large-tank model gives dh/dt = −(a/A)√(2gh), with √h decreasing linearly until h = 0. Each airborne parcel keeps the speed corresponding to its own launch time and then falls under gravity. All above-hole volume is conserved through the outflow. Liquid below the hole remains. The run includes the last jet’s flight time after draining stops and plays over 8 real seconds. Lengths use one common 90 pixels/m scale; outlet diameter and marker sizes are schematic. The free-surface-speed correction is neglected under the stated small-area-ratio approximation.
Status: Ready
Playback: 8 real seconds per run; read elapsed physical model time. Pause or Step for measurements.
Measurements
Load givens — then predict and run
Loading a setup earns no trial credit.
♢ DISCOVER — Head, Approximation, Motion and Drainage
DOK 1 — RecallFlip all 4 rule cards. Keep the quantities and model conditions clear.
Rule 1
Torricelli’s speed
Click to flip
Torricelli’s speed
For a large open tank, small outlet, equal surface/jet pressure and negligible losses, v = √(2gh). Density cancels. Finite surface speed, pressure differences or losses can change the result.
Rule 2
Speed is not throughput
Click to flip
Speed is not throughput
Q = av. At the same head, a larger ideal outlet gives more volume per second. Over time, that greater outflow lowers the head faster and therefore changes later speeds.
Rule 3
Range needs falling height
Click to flip
Range needs falling height
For a horizontal jet launched from height z, flight time is √(2z/g) and R = 2√(hz). If a fixed free-surface height H gives z = H − h, then R = 2√[h(H − h)] and the midpoint maximizes range only for that geometry.
Rule 4
Drainage has a changing rate
Click to flip
Drainage has a changing rate
For constant tank area and a side hole, √h decreases linearly under the quasi-steady model. Head does not decrease linearly and flow is not constant. Time to reach the hole is (A/a)√(2h0/g); liquid below it remains.
All rules explored.
MISCONCEPTION ATTACK — Destroy the Myths
DOK 2 — AnalyzeChoose TRUE or FALSE for each claim. The explanation appears after an attempt; only a correct answer completes the claim.
Myth 1: “A larger outlet must give a greater exit speed at the same head in the ideal large-tank model.”
Correct — the claim is false.
False. Exit speed is set by head and g under those assumptions; area sets Q. A larger outlet can lower future head faster. For a finite-area tank or real losses, revisit the approximation.
Myth 2: “The middle hole always gives the greatest range in every tank setup.”
Correct — the claim is false.
False. The midpoint result assumes fixed surface height above a common landing plane, horizontal launches, negligible losses and nearly constant head during each launch. Holding hole height fixed while increasing surface head instead increases range.
Both myths corrected. Continue to the instructor questions.
✦ THE SECOND “AHA!” — Head and Rate Checks
DOK 2 — ApplyState the pressure, large-tank and launch assumptions before applying shortcuts.
Instructor Q1 — Which Height?
Which h belongs in the ideal Torricelli relation for an open tank?
Instructor Q2 — Four Times the Head
Under the same ideal conditions, initial head increases by a factor of four. What happens to exit speed?
Instructor Q3 — Fresh Head
A small hole has head 0.450 m in an open large tank. Use g = 10 m/s² and neglect losses. Find ideal exit speed.
Instructor Q4 — Fresh Throughput
Ideal exit speed is 4.0 m/s through outlet area 0.00030 m². Find volume flow rate.
4/4 — Instructor Questions Completed
Track the current head for new outflow, but retain each airborne parcel’s launch speed. A side hole drains only the volume above its level.
✎ PRACTICE — Independent Jet and Drainage Cases
DOK 1–3 — PracticeChallenge 1: Exit Speed and Volume Flow
An open large tank has a small ideal outlet 0.800 m below its free surface. Outlet area is 0.00020 m² and g = 10 m/s². Neglect surface speed and losses. Find exit speed and volume flow rate.
Step-by-Step Solution
v = √[2(10)(0.800)] = 4.00 m/s. Q = 0.00020(4.00) = 0.000800 m³/s.
Challenge 2: A Horizontal Jet to the Ground
An open large tank’s free surface is maintained 2.50 m above a level landing plane. A small side outlet is 0.900 m above that plane and launches horizontally. Use g = 10 m/s²; neglect losses, surface speed and air resistance. Find exit speed, flight time and horizontal range.
Step-by-Step Solution
Head = 2.50 − 0.900 = 1.60 m. Exit speed = √[2(10)(1.60)] = 5.65685 m/s. Fall time = √[2(0.900)/10] = 0.424264 s. Range = vt = 2.40 m.
Challenge 3: Audit a Side-Hole Drainage Report
A constant-area open tank has A = 0.040 m² and a small side-hole area a = 0.00020 m² at height 0.300 m above the tank floor. Initial head above the hole is 1.80 m. Use g = 10 m/s² and the quasi-steady large-tank approximation, with no losses. A report says head decreases linearly, uses the initial flow rate unchanged throughout drainage, and claims the side hole removes every drop from the tank. Find the time until the surface reaches the hole, head halfway through that time, volume drained by that halfway instant, and total tank volume remaining then. Explain all three errors.
Step-by-Step Solution
dh/dt = −(a/A)√(2gh) gives √h = √h0 − (a/A)√(g/2)t. The drainage-to-hole time is (A/a)√(2h0/g) = 200√(0.36) = 120 s.
At t = 60 s, √h is half its initial value, so h = h0/4 = 0.450 m. Drained volume = A(1.80 − 0.450) = 0.0540 m³. Remaining volume = A(0.450 + 0.300) = 0.0300 m³.
Head decreases quadratically, not linearly, because outflow slows as head falls. Initial Q cannot be used as a constant rate for the whole drain. The 0.0120 m³ below the side hole remains even after the surface reaches that hole.
☷ CHALLENGE — Sort Exit, Flight and Drainage
DOK 2 — ApplySort Exit, Flight and Drainage
Classify the relationship by the part of the physical model it describes.
0 / 6 correct
Physics Insight
The tank’s current speed is not retroactively assigned to every parcel in flight.
TEACH — The Feynman Technique
DOK 3 — TeachYour Final Mission: Explain why deeper head gives faster ideal outflow but not always longer range. Describe how a tank drains at a decreasing rate and how a parcel already in the air keeps its launch speed. State the approximation and explain why a side hole leaves liquid below it.
Use simple words and at least three short sentences. This checks effort; compare your physics with the Vault or your teacher.
Type Your Explanation (≥ 3 sentences)
Draw a labelled explanation with at least three purposeful strokes. This checks effort; compare your physics with the Vault or your teacher.
Cyan pen selected.
Final reward below
Hidden exam secrets inside — Crest's private notebook.
Crest’s Secret Notebook
Mission 7.11 — Torricelli’s Theorem
Use the vertical head. Separate exit speed, throughput and range.
1. Torricelli from Bernoulli
v = √(2gh)
Compare the open free surface and free jet, both at atmospheric pressure. Neglect the free-surface kinetic term because tank area greatly exceeds outlet area. With incompressible inviscid quasi-steady flow and negligible losses, gravity head becomes exit kinetic energy per mass.
This uses extra assumptions beyond merely writing Bernoulli. Finite surface speed, unequal pressures, viscosity and outlet losses can change the speed. h is surface height above the outlet, not outlet height above ground.
2. Square-root scaling and rate
Doubling head gives √2 times the speed; quadrupling gives twice the speed. At a specified ideal head, density cancels from speed. Outlet area gives Q = av and can change how quickly future head falls.
The first practice gives v = 4.00 m/s and Q = 0.000800 m³/s. A larger outlet at the same head gives greater Q under this model, not greater v.
3. Range and landing geometry
For horizontal launch: tflight = √(2z/g); R = 2√(hz)
z is outlet height above the landing plane. The second practice has h = 1.60 m, z = 0.900 m, speed 5.65685 m/s, flight time 0.424264 s and range 2.40 m.
If the free surface is fixed at height H above that plane, z = H − h and R = 2√[h(H − h)]. The product is maximized at h = H/2. This midpoint result depends on fixed H, horizontal launch, negligible drag/losses and nearly constant head during the launch. It is not a universal rule for every hole comparison.
4. Quasi-steady drainage
For constant tank area A and outlet area a, volume conservation gives A dh/dt = −a√(2gh). Integrating gives a linearly falling square root of head:
√h(t) = max[0, √h0 − (a/A)√(g/2)t]
Tto-hole = (A/a)√(2h0/g)
Head is quadratic during drainage. Halfway in time gives h0/4, not h0/2. Flow rate decreases as head falls; initial Q times the entire drain time overestimates the discharged volume.
The audit gives T = 120 s, halfway head 0.450 m, drained volume 0.0540 m³ and remaining total volume 0.0300 m³. Liquid below the side hole occupies 0.0120 m³ and remains when the above-hole head reaches zero. A drain at the floor is a different geometry.
5. Moving jet and one physical time
The live tank uses A = 0.050 m² and a/A no greater than 0.01. The free-surface-speed correction is deliberately neglected in the large-tank approximation. Its current h, v, Q and discharged volume share the analytical drainage state.
A parcel emitted at time te has horizontal speed √[2gh(te)]. At later age τ its horizontal distance is that speed times τ and its vertical drop is ½gτ². The current tank speed is not applied retroactively to earlier parcels. The run continues for the final flight time after head reaches zero.
Tank and flight lengths use 90 pixels/m; marker and hole sizes are schematic. The long physical drainage interval plays in 8 real seconds. Tracers represent parcels within the continuously flowing jet. Compare initial heads, then outlet areas while other givens stay fixed. Loading earns no completion credit.
6. Boundaries of the approximation
The model treats outlet area as the ideal flow area and neglects contraction and discharge losses. Real near-end drainage, pumps, sealed tanks and pressurized systems need additional conditions. Do not infer every water-tower tap speed or fuel-tank flow from head alone.
7. Course scope
Torricelli’s theorem is an application within AP Physics 1 topic 8.4. It is extension material beyond named Cambridge AS Level 9702 fluid content. The analytical drainage model extends the instantaneous theorem; its changing head and assumptions are stated explicitly.
✓ Crest’s Checklist
- I measure head from the surface to the hole.
- I state equal pressure and large-tank assumptions.
- I distinguish exit speed, volume flow and range.
- I use hole height for the flight time.
- I qualify the midpoint-range result.
- I conserve volume as head and flow change.
- I retain launch speed for airborne parcels.
- I account for liquid left below a side hole.
— Crest ☆ “Use the vertical head. Separate exit speed, throughput and range.”
Mission 7.11 Complete! · All 10 levels cleared · PHYSICS CREST
★ Torricelli Theorem Master
Track the current head for new outflow, but retain each airborne parcel’s launch speed. A side hole drains only the volume above its level.