WONDER — The Mystery
A Smaller Scale Reading, the Same Gravitational Weight
A supported rigid cube is lowered through a liquid. Both face pressures rise as it goes deeper. Yet their resultant can remain constant, and the support scale can read less than the cube’s gravitational weight. What does the scale actually measure?
Model: Uniform incompressible fluid in hydrostatic equilibrium; rigid object with full fluid contact. Neglect drag and flow disturbance for the controlled lowering model. The cube moves at constant speed during the measured interval, so its acceleration is zero. Starting and stopping transients are outside this interval. True weight is mg; a support scale measures tension, not mass or buoyant force.
PREDICT — Commit to Your Answer
DOK 2 — PredictA rigid cube is fully submerged in a uniform incompressible liquid. It is lowered from a top-face depth of 1 m to 4 m without changing its volume. Gravity and liquid density stay the same. How does its buoyant force change?
Commit to both a prediction and a reason before revealing the explanation.
Step 1: Pick your answer.
STOP! Before revealing — why did you pick that?
Correct prediction and reasoning saved.
For a cube of side L, bottom and top differ in depth by L. Their pressure difference is ρgL, so the upward resultant is ρgL³. Common added pressure cancels.
▶ PLAY — Live Supported-Cube Depth Scan
DOK 2 — InvestigatePredict, measure and compare
Compare two target depths while keeping fluid density and cube side fixed. Then change only fluid density from one of that pair. Complete three runs. Watch the cube lower and compare absolute face pressures, their forces, buoyancy and tension.
The cube is fully submerged throughout. Its top starts 0.50 m below the surface and moves down at 0.050 m/s to the target depth; elapsed physical time depends on that distance. Each run plays over 8 real seconds. Surface absolute pressure is 100 kPa, g = 9.8 m/s² and cube density is 2500 kg/m³. Absolute face forces include surface pressure. All allowed fluids are less dense than the cube, so upper-support tension remains positive. The main depth scale is 36 pixels/m; the pressure-force inset is magnified. Arrows use a common face-force scale, while the separate net-force arrow is schematic.
Status: Ready
Playback: 8 real seconds per run; read elapsed physical model time. Pause or Step for measurements.
Measurements
Load givens — then predict and run
Loading a setup earns no trial credit.
♢ DISCOVER — Pressure, Displacement and Support
DOK 1 — RecallFlip all 4 rule cards. Keep the quantities and model conditions clear.
Rule 1
Pressure is not force
Click to flip
Pressure is not force
Pressure is scalar and acts normally on each surface. Multiply uniform face pressure by face area for force; add all surface forces as vectors.
Rule 2
Net pressure force
Click to flip
Net pressure force
For a horizontal-faced cube, equal side forces cancel and B = (Pbottom − Ptop)A = ρfluid gV. For arbitrary shapes, the resultant of pressure over the whole wetted surface gives the buoyancy.
Rule 3
Depth independence has conditions
Click to flip
Depth independence has conditions
With uniform fluid density, fixed g and a rigid fully submerged object, displaced volume is fixed. Deeper motion increases top and bottom pressures together; their difference stays fixed.
Rule 4
A support reading needs a force balance
Click to flip
A support reading needs a force balance
True weight is mg. In vertical equilibrium or constant-speed motion with only tension, weight and buoyancy, T + B − W = 0. Thus T = W − B. An upper rope cannot supply negative tension; different motion or extra forces need a different balance.
All rules explored.
MISCONCEPTION ATTACK — Destroy the Myths
DOK 2 — AnalyzeChoose TRUE or FALSE for each claim. The explanation appears after an attempt; only a correct answer completes the claim.
Myth 1: “A sinking object has no buoyant force.”
Correct — the claim is false.
False. A submerged sinking object still displaces fluid and feels buoyancy. Whether it accelerates also depends on weight, drag and any support forces.
Myth 2: “If buoyancy equals weight, the object must be floating at the surface.”
Correct — the claim is false.
False. A fully submerged neutrally buoyant object can also have B = W. Zero resultant means zero acceleration, not automatically zero velocity or surface flotation. Gases also exert buoyancy; vacuum does not.
Both myths corrected. Continue to the instructor questions.
✦ THE SECOND “AHA!” — Separate the Forces
DOK 2 — ApplyUse the fluid density for buoyancy and specify the motion before finding support tension.
Instructor Q1 — The Pressure Resultant
For a fully submerged cube in static liquid, which gives the vertical buoyant force?
Instructor Q2 — What Does a Scale Measure?
A cube hangs at rest underwater from an upper spring scale. What is the scale reading?
Instructor Q3 — Fresh Displaced Volume
An object displaces 0.0015 m³ of liquid of density 800 kg/m³. Use g = 10 m/s². Find buoyant force.
Instructor Q4 — A Supported Object
An object hangs at rest. Its true weight is 50 N and its buoyant force is 18 N. There are no other forces besides an upper tension. Find that tension.
4/4 — Instructor Questions Completed
Buoyancy is a net force from fluid pressure. A smaller tension does not mean smaller gravitational weight.
✎ PRACTICE — Independent Buoyancy Investigations
DOK 1–3 — PracticeChallenge 1: A Submerged Rigid Cube
A rigid cube of side 0.120 m is fully submerged in liquid of density 1000 kg/m³. Use g = 10 m/s². Find its displaced volume and buoyant force.
Step-by-Step Solution
Volume = 0.120³ = 0.001728 m³. Buoyancy = 1000(10)(0.001728) = 17.28 N.
Challenge 2: True Weight and Tension
A rigid object of volume 0.0020 m³ and true weight 32.0 N hangs at rest, fully submerged in liquid of density 900 kg/m³. Use g = 10 m/s². It has an upper support and no bottom contact or other forces. Find buoyancy, support tension and true mass.
Step-by-Step Solution
B = 900(10)(0.0020) = 18.0 N. At rest T + B = W, so T = 14.0 N. True mass = W/g = 32.0/10 = 3.20 kg.
Challenge 3: Audit the Face-Force Report
A rigid cube of side 0.200 m and density 2500 kg/m³ hangs at rest in liquid of density 1000 kg/m³. Its top face is 1.00 m below a surface at absolute pressure 100 kPa. Use g = 10 m/s². A report calls the bottom pressure force the buoyant force, uses cube density to calculate buoyancy, and says its smaller scale reading proves its gravitational weight decreased. Find the top downward force, bottom upward force, buoyant force and upper-support tension. Explain all three errors.
Step-by-Step Solution
A = 0.200² = 0.0400 m²; V = 0.00800 m³. Top pressure = 110000 Pa and bottom pressure = 112000 Pa. Top force = 4400 N downward and bottom force = 4480 N upward. Their difference, not the bottom force alone, is B = 80.0 N.
The displaced liquid density gives B = 1000(10)(0.00800), while cube density gives mass = 20.0 kg and true weight = 200 N. At rest T = 200 − 80 = 120 N. The support reading changes because buoyancy supplies part of the upward force; gravitational weight remains 200 N.
☷ CHALLENGE — Sort Pressure, Buoyancy and Support
DOK 2 — ApplySort Pressure, Buoyancy and Support
Place each statement with the quantity it explains.
0 / 6 correct
Physics Insight
Large absolute face forces can leave a much smaller net buoyant force.
TEACH — The Feynman Technique
DOK 3 — TeachYour Final Mission: Explain why lowering a rigid fully submerged cube through a uniform static liquid increases both face pressures but not buoyancy. Explain why a hanging scale reading can fall while true weight remains unchanged, and state the condition needed for T = W − B.
Use simple words and at least three short sentences. This checks effort; compare your physics with the Vault or your teacher.
Type Your Explanation (≥ 3 sentences)
Draw a labelled explanation with at least three purposeful strokes. This checks effort; compare your physics with the Vault or your teacher.
Cyan pen selected.
Final reward below
Hidden exam secrets inside — Crest's private notebook.
Crest’s Secret Notebook
Mission 7.6 — Buoyant Force
Find the pressure resultant. Keep true weight separate.
1. Buoyancy comes from fluid pressure
Fluid pressure acts normally on every wetted surface. In hydrostatic equilibrium pressure increases downward. For a horizontal-faced cube, opposite side forces cancel, and the upward bottom pressure force exceeds the downward top pressure force.
B = (Pbottom − Ptop)A = ρfluid gLA = ρfluid gV
For a general shape, sum pressure forces over its wetted surface. The simple top-minus-bottom equal-area derivation is specifically a prism example. Archimedes’ principle generalizes the result when fluid surrounds the displaced volume under the hydrostatic assumptions.
2. Absolute and gauge face pressures
Ptop = Psurface + ρgh; Pbottom = Psurface + ρg(h + L)
The common surface pressure cancels from the difference. Gauge pressures can find the same resultant, but an individual total face force must use absolute pressure. Do not call a gauge-only face force the entire physical force on that face.
3. When deeper does not mean more buoyancy
For uniform incompressible fluid, fixed gravity and a rigid fully submerged object, V and ρ stay fixed. Lowering increases both face pressures by the same amount. Buoyancy therefore stays constant. Compressible fluids, deformable objects or changing partial submersion can change the result.
4. True weight, tension and motion
Gravitational weight is W = mg. A spring scale in an upper support reads tension T. With upward positive, T + B − W = ma if these are the only forces. For rest or constant vertical speed, a = 0 and T = W − B.
This relation is not universal during acceleration, drag or bottom contact. An upper rope cannot exert negative tension: B greater than W requires another force or a different motion. B = W without other forces means zero acceleration, not necessarily rest or surface floating.
5. Independent checks
The 0.120 m cube displaces 0.001728 m³ and feels 17.28 N in the stated liquid. The supported 32.0 N object has B = 18.0 N, T = 14.0 N and true mass 3.20 kg.
The audited 0.200 m cube has face forces 4400 N down and 4480 N up: B = 80.0 N. Its cube density gives mass 20.0 kg and true weight 200 N. Its support reads 120 N. Using the bottom force alone or using object density for buoyancy is incorrect.
6. Live scan and its limits
The supported cube’s top moves from 0.50 m to the selected depth at controlled constant speed 0.050 m/s. Start and stop transients are excluded. The hydrostatic measurement approximation neglects fluid disturbance and drag. The animation position, face pressures, forces, buoyancy and tension all use the same physical time.
The main depth scale is 36 pixels/m; the force inset is magnified. The 8-real-second playback compresses a longer physical interval. Pause and Step inspect that state; Reset returns to the start. Compare depths, then liquid densities while other givens stay fixed. Three matched completed runs earn continuation.
7. Fluids include gases
Air also has hydrostatic pressure variation and gives buoyancy. Its lower density makes the effect smaller for equal displaced volume. Vacuum has no surrounding fluid pressure and therefore no fluid buoyancy. Objects that sink still experience buoyancy while submerged.
8. Course scope
Buoyancy and Newton’s laws directly support AP Physics 1 topic 8.3. Cambridge AS Level 9702 topic 4.3 includes deriving upthrust from pressure difference and calculating it as ρgV. Keep model conditions and fluid density explicit.
✓ Crest’s Checklist
- I subtract pressure forces to find their net resultant.
- I distinguish pressure in Pa from force in N.
- I use displaced fluid density for buoyancy.
- I qualify depth independence.
- I separate true weight and support tension.
- I state acceleration and additional forces before balancing.
- I recognize buoyancy in gases and on sinking objects.
— Crest ☆ “Find the pressure resultant. Keep true weight separate.”
Mission 7.6 Complete! · All 10 levels cleared · PHYSICS CREST
★ Buoyant Force Master
Buoyancy is a net force from fluid pressure. A smaller tension does not mean smaller gravitational weight.