WONDER — The Mystery
Weigh the Fluid That Was Pushed Aside
Lower an irregular solid into a brim-full overflow can and collect the liquid it pushes aside. How does the collected liquid relate to buoyancy? Does density alone identify a particular contaminant in a sample?
Model: Hydrostatic buoyancy with uniform fluid, constant g, full fluid contact and negligible surface tension. Displaced volume is the volume excluded from the liquid, not automatically the entire object. Overflow measurements need a can initially at its spout level, no trapped bubbles and complete collection. A density difference can reject a supplied uniform-solid reference model but cannot uniquely establish composition.
PREDICT — Commit to Your Answer
DOK 2 — PredictAn overflow can and its water initially read 16 N on a scale. A 4 N object is gently added and floats freely at rest. All overflow drains to a collector off the scale. After overflow finishes, what is the can-scale reading? Neglect surface tension and air buoyancy.
Commit to both a prediction and a reason before revealing the explanation.
Step 1: Pick your answer.
STOP! Before revealing — why did you pick that?
Correct prediction and reasoning saved.
At rest buoyancy equals the freely floating object’s weight, 4 N. The object adds 4 N to the weighed system and 4 N of water leaves it, so the final reading is 16 N.
▶ PLAY — Live Overflow and Collection Lab
DOK 2 — InvestigatePredict, measure and compare
Compare two cube sides at the same fluid density and lowering speed. Then change only fluid density from one of that pair. Complete three runs. Watch partial submersion, overflow travel and collection; compare buoyancy with collected plus travelling fluid weight.
A rigid cube of density 3000 kg/m³ begins with its bottom at the liquid surface. An upper support lowers it at constant speed until fully submerged, then holds it. Starting and stopping inertia, drag and air buoyancy are neglected. g = 9.8 m/s². An ideal overflow can stays at its spout level. The transport model routes overflow to a separate collector with a prescribed 0.25 s delay; moving tracer dots show transport, not ballistic falling drops. Fluid still travelling is counted. Buoyancy equals the weight of collected plus travelling displaced liquid during entry, and collected weight alone once collection finishes. Tank lengths use 1000 pixels/m; collector fill is schematic. Each run includes the final delay and plays over 8 real seconds.
Status: Ready
Playback: 8 real seconds per run; read elapsed physical model time. Pause or Step for measurements.
Measurements
Load givens — then predict and run
Loading a setup earns no trial credit.
♢ DISCOVER — Displacement, Force and Evidence
DOK 1 — RecallFlip all 4 rule cards. Keep the quantities and model conditions clear.
Rule 1
Archimedes’ principle
Click to flip
Archimedes’ principle
Under hydrostatic full-contact conditions, buoyancy equals the weight of fluid displaced: B = ρfluid gVdisplaced. It is a force in N, not a mass in kg.
Rule 2
Use the submerged volume
Click to flip
Use the submerged volume
Full submersion of a sealed rigid object displaces its external volume. Partial submersion displaces only the volume below the surface. Open cavities filled with fluid do not exclude that fluid.
Rule 3
Track collection and the system boundary
Click to flip
Track collection and the system boundary
During transport some overflow may still be travelling. Full collection gives displaced-fluid weight. A freely floating object at rest displaces its own weight; an externally supported object need not.
Rule 4
Density tests have limits
Click to flip
Density tests have limits
For a fully wetted rigid solid with no trapped bubbles, collected volume gives excluded volume and ρobject = m/V. A mismatch can reject the reference density under the stated assumptions. It does not uniquely identify an alloy or prove a historical accusation.
All rules explored.
MISCONCEPTION ATTACK — Destroy the Myths
DOK 2 — AnalyzeChoose TRUE or FALSE for each claim. The explanation appears after an attempt; only a correct answer completes the claim.
Myth 1: “Buoyancy always equals the object’s own weight.”
Correct — the claim is false.
False. This equality applies to free floating equilibrium with no additional vertical forces. A supported submerged dense object can have B smaller than W.
Myth 2: “A lower measured density uniquely proves one particular contaminant.”
Correct — the claim is false.
False. Different mixtures, cavities, porosity, bubbles or measurement errors can change an apparent density. State what the controlled measurement establishes and what further evidence would be needed.
Both myths corrected. Continue to the instructor questions.
✦ THE SECOND “AHA!” — Displaced Fluid in Liquids and Gases
DOK 2 — ApplyKeep mass, weight, excluded volume and collection conditions separate.
Instructor Q1 — The Principle
Which is the general Archimedes relation under the hydrostatic model?
Instructor Q2 — Partial Submersion
A rigid cube is halfway below the surface, with air buoyancy neglected. Which volume enters the liquid buoyancy calculation?
Instructor Q3 — Collected Weight
After all overflow is collected, its mass is 0.24 kg. Use g = 10 m/s². Find its weight.
Instructor Q4 — Air Is a Fluid
A balloon excludes 20 m³ of air of density 1.2 kg/m³. Use g = 10 m/s². Find its gross buoyant force before subtracting any balloon-system weight.
4/4 — Instructor Questions Completed
Archimedes compares buoyancy with displaced fluid weight, not automatically with object weight or an unfinished collector reading.
✎ PRACTICE — Independent Displacement Evidence
DOK 1–3 — PracticeChallenge 1: Overflow in a Fresh Liquid
A rigid solid is fully submerged in a brim-full can. After complete collection, the overflow volume is 375 mL. The liquid density is 960 kg/m³ and g = 10 m/s². No bubbles or leaks occur. Find displaced fluid mass and buoyant force.
Step-by-Step Solution
375 mL = 0.000375 m³. Displaced mass = 960(0.000375) = 0.360 kg. Its weight, and hence buoyancy, is 0.360(10) = 3.60 N.
Challenge 2: Balloon System in Air
A balloon system excludes 120 m³ of air of density 1.2 kg/m³. Its total mass, including gas, envelope and payload, is 110 kg. Use g = 10 m/s². At the instant considered there is no drag or tether force. Find gross buoyancy, total weight and net upward force.
Step-by-Step Solution
Gross B = 1.2(10)(120) = 1440 N. Total W = 110(10) = 1100 N. Net upward force = 1440 − 1100 = 340 N at this instant. Subsequent motion or drag can change the force balance.
Challenge 3: Audit a Density-Test Claim
A solid sample of mass 0.800 kg is fully submerged in water of density 1000 kg/m³. Complete overflow collection gives 50.0 mL. There are no trapped bubbles, open pores, leaks or measurement uncertainty in this model; g = 10 m/s². A supplied uniform reference solid has density 20000 kg/m³. A report treats 50.0 mL as 50.0 m³, sets buoyancy equal to the sample’s weight, and claims the density uniquely identifies a specific added metal. Find displaced volume in m³, sample density and buoyancy. Explain all three errors and state what the comparison actually establishes.
Step-by-Step Solution
50.0 mL = 5.00 × 10⁻⁵ m³. Sample density = 0.800/(5.00 × 10⁻⁵) = 16000 kg/m³. Buoyancy = 1000(10)(5.00 × 10⁻⁵) = 0.500 N. Its weight is 8.00 N, so buoyancy is not equal to sample weight.
The report misses the mL conversion and confuses displaced-fluid weight with object weight. The measured density differs from the supplied 20000 kg/m³ uniform-solid reference under the stated ideal assumptions. Density alone cannot uniquely identify a contaminant or its fraction; that needs additional composition evidence.
☷ CHALLENGE — Sort Measurement, Force and Inference
DOK 2 — ApplySort Measurement, Force and Inference
Classify each statement by its role in the investigation.
0 / 6 correct
Physics Insight
A good investigation states both its measured result and the limits of its inference.
TEACH — The Feynman Technique
DOK 3 — TeachYour Final Mission: Explain how overflow measures displaced volume, why buoyancy equals the weight of that fluid, and why collection during transport may lag displacement. Explain the difference between gross balloon buoyancy and net lift, and one limit of a density-based material test.
Use simple words and at least three short sentences. This checks effort; compare your physics with the Vault or your teacher.
Type Your Explanation (≥ 3 sentences)
Draw a labelled explanation with at least three purposeful strokes. This checks effort; compare your physics with the Vault or your teacher.
Cyan pen selected.
Final reward below
Hidden exam secrets inside — Crest's private notebook.
Crest’s Secret Notebook
Mission 7.7 — Archimedes’ Principle
Measure the fluid displaced. Account for the whole system.
1. Archimedes’ principle
B = Wdisplaced = ρfluid gVdisplaced
The resultant fluid pressure force equals the gravitational weight of the fluid excluded by the object under hydrostatic, full-contact assumptions. The result applies to liquids and gases. It does not require the object to float.
2. What volume is displaced?
For a sealed rigid body fully submerged, displaced volume is its external excluded volume. At partial submersion use only the volume below the liquid surface. Fluid-filled open holes do not exclude their contained fluid. Trapped bubbles can add excluded volume and spoil an intended solid-density measurement.
1 mL = 1 cm³ = 10⁻⁶ m³. The 375 mL measurement is 0.000375 m³, giving 0.360 kg of the specified liquid and buoyancy 3.60 N.
3. Overflow conditions and transport
The can must begin at its spout level and all displaced overflow must be accounted for. During flow, collection can lag displacement. In the live prescribed-delay model, Vdisplaced = Vcollected + Vtravelling. Multiplying by ρg gives the corresponding force equality. After the cube stops and the final travelling liquid arrives, buoyancy equals collected-fluid weight alone.
The live cube enters at constant controlled speed. Submerged depth is clipped between zero and its side length; volume is face area times that depth. After full entry, the support holds it and the transport delay finishes. Cube density 3000 kg/m³ keeps upper-support tension positive for every allowed fluid. Neglect entry/stop transients, air buoyancy, drag and surface tension.
The transit delay is an explicit 0.25 s transport model, not a gravity-derived drop time. Moving dots represent travelling liquid. Main lengths use 1000 pixels/m; collector fill is schematic. Read physical time during the 8-second playback.
4. Floating and system boundaries
A freely floating object at rest with only gravity and liquid buoyancy has B = Wobject. It therefore displaces fluid of its own weight. If its overflow leaves a weighed can, object weight replaces equal removed water weight. The 16 N can remains at 16 N after a 4 N object floats and 4 N of overflow leaves.
An externally supported object need not displace its own weight. At zero acceleration, upper tension plus buoyancy equals weight when those are the only forces. An upper rope cannot give negative tension.
5. Balloons: gross and net
Air is a fluid. Gross buoyancy uses ambient air density and external excluded volume. Net lift subtracts the weight of gas, envelope, payload and other included parts. The practice balloon has B = 1440 N, W = 1100 N and instantaneous net upward force 340 N with no drag or tether.
6. Density evidence
ρsample = msample / Vexcluded
The audited sample displaces 50.0 mL = 0.0000500 m³, has density 16000 kg/m³ and buoyancy 0.500 N. Its weight is 8.00 N. The result differs from the supplied uniform 20000 kg/m³ reference. It does not uniquely reveal composition. Real measurement also needs uncertainty, bubbles, cavities and porosity considered.
A crown-and-bath story is a traditional illustration, not proof of its historical details. Displacement can measure irregular volume without relying on that story. Material identification needs more evidence than a single density number.
7. Course scope
AP Physics 1 topic 8.3 and Cambridge AS Level 9702 topic 4.3 directly include buoyancy/upthrust and ρgV. The collection-delay model is a measurement extension, not an extra equation to memorize.
✓ Crest’s Checklist
- I use displaced fluid weight, not automatically object weight.
- I use only excluded submerged volume.
- I convert mL and m³ consistently.
- I account for overflow still travelling.
- I define the system weighed by a scale.
- I subtract total system weight from gross buoyancy.
- I limit material conclusions to the available evidence.
— Crest ☆ “Measure the fluid displaced. Account for the whole system.”
Mission 7.7 Complete! · All 10 levels cleared · PHYSICS CREST
★ Archimedes Principle Master
Archimedes compares buoyancy with displaced fluid weight, not automatically with object weight or an unfinished collector reading.