WONDER — The Mystery
A Hollow Hull Changes the Excluded Volume
A dense solid can sink while a watertight hollow object of the same mass floats. Its material density has not changed, but its water-excluding volume has. How much must a floating object submerge to support its full weight?
Model: Rigid objects with full fluid contact, uniform fluid density, fixed g and negligible air buoyancy or surface tension. Use total mass divided by the relevant external water-excluding volume for average density. The density rule describes ideal unsupported buoyancy; real stability, flooding and additional forces need separate checks. Equilibrium fraction is a volume fraction, not a universal height fraction for arbitrary shapes.
PREDICT — Commit to Your Answer
DOK 2 — PredictA rigid uniform object of average density 600 kg/m³ floats freely at rest in liquid of density 1000 kg/m³. Neglect air buoyancy and surface tension. What fraction of its volume is below the surface?
Commit to both a prediction and a reason before revealing the explanation.
Step 1: Pick your answer.
STOP! Before revealing — why did you pick that?
Correct prediction and reasoning saved.
ρfluid gVsub = ρobject gVtotal gives Vsub/Vtotal = 600/1000 = 0.60. Its weight remains nonzero.
▶ PLAY — Live Release with Buoyancy, Drag and Contact
DOK 2 — InvestigatePredict, measure and compare
Compare two object densities while keeping fluid density and starting depth fixed. Then change only fluid density from one of that pair. Complete three runs. Watch rising, partial submersion, neutral release or sinking; inspect actual position, velocity and force balance.
A 0.200 m rigid cube starts fully submerged at rest, then is released. Downward depth and velocity are positive. Uniform fluid, fixed surface and g = 9.8 m/s² are used. Its liquid-displaced volume is face area times submerged height, clipped from zero to the full side. A specified linear drag force is −cv with c = 80 N·s/m. This phenomenological damping is a motion extension, not an ideal-fluid viscosity claim. Added mass, waves, air buoyancy and surface tension are neglected. A porous support rack at bottom-face depth 1.20 m preserves fluid contact below the cube and stops a sinking cube inelastically; rack reaction then joins the balance. RK4 uses steps no larger than 0.002 s. Eight physical seconds play over eight real seconds; depth scale is 170 pixels/m. A finite run need not reach exact floating equilibrium.
Status: Ready
Playback: 8 real seconds per run; read elapsed physical model time. Pause or Step for measurements.
Measurements
Load givens — then predict and run
Loading a setup earns no trial credit.
♢ DISCOVER — Density, Displacement and Motion
DOK 1 — RecallFlip all 4 rule cards. Keep the quantities and model conditions clear.
Rule 1
Compare average densities
Click to flip
Compare average densities
When fully submerged and otherwise unsupported, B/W = ρfluid/ρobject. A less dense rigid object accelerates upward from rest; a denser one accelerates downward. Equal densities give neutral buoyancy under the model.
Rule 2
Floating equilibrium is a balance
Click to flip
Floating equilibrium is a balance
For free rest at the surface, B = W and Vsub/Vtotal = ρobject/ρfluid. Use this fraction only when it is no greater than one and no extra vertical forces act.
Rule 3
Zero acceleration is not zero velocity
Click to flip
Zero acceleration is not zero velocity
Neutral buoyancy means the buoyancy-weight resultant is zero. An object released at rest can remain still; an already moving object need not instantly stop. Drag or contact changes the balance.
Rule 4
Hulls and ice need conditions
Click to flip
Hulls and ice need conditions
A watertight hull excludes water and can lower average density without changing material density. In the ideal equal-density freshwater model, floating ice melt replaces its displaced volume. Different melt/liquid densities give a correction; hull stability and flooding are separate issues.
All rules explored.
MISCONCEPTION ATTACK — Destroy the Myths
DOK 2 — AnalyzeChoose TRUE or FALSE for each claim. The explanation appears after an attempt; only a correct answer completes the claim.
Myth 1: “Floating means gravity stopped acting, and buoyancy and weight are a third-law pair.”
Correct — the claim is false.
False. Weight remains mg. Equal opposite buoyancy and weight act on the same object and balance; Newton’s third-law partners act on different objects.
Myth 2: “Neutral buoyancy guarantees any moving object immediately becomes stationary.”
Correct — the claim is false.
False. Zero resultant gives zero acceleration. Velocity persists unless another force, such as drag, changes it. The neutral preset starts at rest, which is why it remains still.
Both myths corrected. Continue to the instructor questions.
✦ THE SECOND “AHA!” — Flotation Conditions
DOK 2 — ApplyUse equilibrium only when the stated forces and motion justify it.
Instructor Q1 — The Relevant Density
For a watertight hollow rigid object, which density is relevant to maximum available liquid buoyancy?
Instructor Q2 — Balanced Forces
Weight and buoyancy balance on one floating object at rest. Are they a Newton’s-third-law pair?
Instructor Q3 — Fresh Floating Fraction
A free rigid object of average density 800 kg/m³ floats at rest in liquid of density 1250 kg/m³. Find the percentage of its volume below the surface.
Instructor Q4 — Density from Flotation
A free object floats at rest with 75% of its volume submerged in liquid of density 1200 kg/m³. Find its average density.
4/4 — Instructor Questions Completed
The actual submerged fraction changes during motion. The equilibrium density ratio is a destination under stated conditions, not an instant animation setting.
✎ PRACTICE — Independent Floating and Sinking Cases
DOK 1–3 — PracticeChallenge 1: Submerged and Exposed Volumes
An object of average density 720 kg/m³ floats freely at rest in liquid of density 1200 kg/m³. Neglect air buoyancy and surface tension. Find the submerged and above-surface percentages of its volume.
Step-by-Step Solution
Submerged fraction = 720/1200 = 0.600: 60.0% submerged and 40.0% above the surface.
Challenge 2: A Sealed Rigid Hull
A sealed rigid hull has total mass 4.50 kg and maximum water-excluding volume 0.00600 m³. It floats at rest in water of density 1000 kg/m³; g = 10 m/s². Neglect air buoyancy and keep hull volume fixed. Find its average density, current submerged volume and extra mass that brings it just to full submersion. This last value is an ideal threshold, not a recommended loading margin.
Step-by-Step Solution
Average density = 4.50/0.00600 = 750 kg/m³. At floating equilibrium Vsub = m/ρwater = 0.00450 m³. Full-submersion buoyancy supports a total mass 1000(0.00600) = 6.00 kg, so the extra mass threshold is 1.50 kg. At this limit there is no freeboard; real loading needs margins and stability analysis.
Challenge 3: Audit a Neutral-Buoyancy and Ice Report
A fully submerged sealed rigid object has volume 0.0040 m³ and density 1000 kg/m³ in liquid of density 1000 kg/m³; g = 10 m/s². At the instant considered it moves downward at 0.30 m/s and drag and other forces are absent. A separate 0.200 kg ice sample floats in liquid of density 1050 kg/m³ and melts to liquid of density 1000 kg/m³ with no mass loss or mixing-volume change. A report says the neutral object must instantly stop, its balanced weight and buoyancy are a third-law pair, and the floating ice must cause exactly zero volume change regardless of liquid density. Find object buoyancy, its instantaneous downward acceleration and the melt volume minus its former displaced volume. Explain all three errors.
Step-by-Step Solution
Object mass = 4.00 kg, W = 40.0 N and B = 40.0 N. With no drag or other forces, resultant and acceleration are zero, but the downward 0.30 m/s velocity does not instantly vanish. Balanced forces on the same object are not third-law partners.
Floating ice displaces 0.200/1050 = 0.000190476 m³. Melt volume = 0.200/1000 = 0.000200000 m³. The excess is 9.52381 × 10⁻⁶ m³, or 9.52381 mL. Exactly equal volumes require equal displaced-liquid and melt densities under this model; a universal zero-change claim is false.
☷ CHALLENGE — Sort Equilibrium, Motion and Model Limits
DOK 2 — ApplySort Equilibrium, Motion and Model Limits
Classify each statement by the issue it addresses.
0 / 6 correct
Physics Insight
Use the volume density ratio for equilibrium, then use Newton’s laws to describe how the object gets there.
TEACH — The Feynman Technique
DOK 3 — TeachYour Final Mission: Explain how a rigid low-average-density object rises from full submersion and approaches a partially submerged floating equilibrium. Distinguish the actual motion from the equilibrium fraction, explain neutral buoyancy, and give one condition needed for the melting-ice volume result.
Use simple words and at least three short sentences. This checks effort; compare your physics with the Vault or your teacher.
Type Your Explanation (≥ 3 sentences)
Draw a labelled explanation with at least three purposeful strokes. This checks effort; compare your physics with the Vault or your teacher.
Cyan pen selected.
Final reward below
Hidden exam secrets inside — Crest's private notebook.
Crest’s Secret Notebook
Mission 7.8 — Sink or Float?
Compare average density. Distinguish motion from equilibrium.
1. Density and available buoyancy
Use average density: total mass divided by external volume that can exclude water. For a fully submerged rigid object, B = ρfluid gV and W = ρobject gV. With only these forces, lower object density gives upward acceleration from rest; higher object density gives downward acceleration.
Material density and average enclosed-body density need not be equal. A watertight hull can exclude a large volume without much additional mass. Flooding reduces excluded volume; stability and freeboard are separate design concerns.
2. Free floating equilibrium
B = W ⇒ Vsub/Vtotal = ρobject/ρfluid
This relation needs no additional vertical forces and a ratio no greater than one. It describes volume, not generally object height. A vertical uniform prism does have proportional submerged height because its horizontal area is constant.
The 720 kg/m³ object in 1200 kg/m³ liquid has 60% of its volume below the surface. The sealed 4.50 kg hull has average density 750 kg/m³, displaced volume 0.00450 m³, and ideal full-submersion extra-mass threshold 1.50 kg. This is not a practical safety margin.
3. Weight, resultant and third-law partners
Floating weight remains mg. Weight and buoyancy can balance on the same object without either force vanishing. They are not a Newton’s-third-law pair. The gravitational interaction partner acts on Earth; the buoyancy interaction partner acts on the fluid.
Neutral buoyancy gives zero buoyancy-weight resultant in the ideal model. Zero acceleration preserves velocity; it does not imply that an already moving object stops. An object released at rest can remain at rest.
4. Live motion follows the forces
Downward bottom depth z and velocity v obey dz/dt = v. For the 0.200 m cube, submerged height is z clipped between 0 and 0.200 m. Buoyancy uses that height, not the future equilibrium fraction.
m dv/dt = W − B − cv − N; c = 80 N·s/m
N is upward rack reaction. Before contact N = 0. The porous rack at bottom depth 1.20 m preserves fluid underneath and catches a sinking cube inelastically. At rest on it N = W − B. Collision energy is lost; this is not a lossless motion model. The specified linear drag opposes velocity. Waves, added mass and air buoyancy are neglected.
RK4 steps no larger than 0.002 s integrate this stated model from rest. The 8-second interval ends where the model is at that time; floating residuals are not replaced by exact equilibrium values. Depth uses 170 pixels/m. Compare object densities, then fluid densities with other settings fixed; neutral rest is correctly stationary.
5. Melting floating ice
At free floating equilibrium a mass m displaces liquid volume m/ρliquid. After melting without mass loss, melt volume is m/ρmelt. The two match in the ideal equal-density freshwater model. Different liquid and melt densities give a volume difference.
The audit’s 0.200 kg ice displaces 0.000190476 m³ of 1050 kg/m³ liquid and produces 0.000200000 m³ of 1000 kg/m³ melt. Excess is 9.52381 mL in the stated simplified model. Do not turn equal-density reasoning into a universal ocean-volume claim; actual mixing, salinity and thermal effects need their own data.
6. Course scope
Buoyancy and Newton’s laws directly support AP Physics 1 topic 8.3 and Cambridge AS Level 9702 topic 4.3. The numerical drag-and-contact release is an explicit motion extension. Its drag coefficient and solver are not syllabus formulas to memorize.
✓ Crest’s Checklist
- I use average density and excluded volume.
- I state the free floating equilibrium assumptions.
- I distinguish volume fraction from height fraction.
- I separate acceleration from velocity.
- I identify third-law partners on different bodies.
- I include drag or contact when present.
- I qualify melting-ice volume comparisons.
— Crest ☆ “Compare average density. Distinguish motion from equilibrium.”
Mission 7.8 Complete! · All 10 levels cleared · PHYSICS CREST
★ Sink and Float Master
The actual submerged fraction changes during motion. The equilibrium density ratio is a destination under stated conditions, not an instant animation setting.