WONDER — The Mystery
A Controlled Distance Test
For two fixed point charges, increasing their separation weakens the electric interaction. Doubling one charge magnitude doubles the force magnitude; doubling their separation divides it by four. These ratios assume the other factors and medium stay fixed. A neutral balloon–wall interaction involves polarization and must not automatically be treated as two fixed point charges.
Model: For nonzero point charges at positive separation in the same medium, F ∝ |qAqB|/r². Compare magnitudes with Fnew/Fold = |a b|/c² when charges scale by a and b and separation by positive c. Track signs separately for direction. This rule is not a claim that force is a conserved fluid spreading over a sphere.
PREDICT — Commit to Your Answer
DOK 2 — PredictTwo nonzero fixed point charges exert a force of magnitude 0.048 N. Their separation is doubled while their charges and medium remain unchanged. What is the new magnitude?
Commit to both a prediction and a reason before revealing the explanation.
Step 1: Pick your answer.
STOP! Before revealing — why did you pick that?
Correct prediction and reasoning saved.
The distance factor is 2² = 4. Therefore the new force magnitude is 0.048/4 = 0.012 N.
▶ PLAY — Live Controlled Separation Sweep
DOK 2 — InvestigatePredict, measure and compare
Complete two sweeps changing only A’s charge magnitude, then a third changing only the final separation. Watch the actuator move B away from fixed A while force readouts and arrows change. The motion is prescribed so it measures force versus separation rather than predicting acceleration.
A is fixed and an external actuator moves B from 0.15 m to the selected final separation over 4 model seconds. Charges are point models in vacuum or approximately air, in nC; k = 9.00 × 10⁹ N m²/C². A smooth prescribed displacement sets the instantaneous separation, and Coulomb forces are computed there. Supports and actuator supply the other forces; the movement is not free motion caused by the displayed electric force. Right is positive. Zero-charge B is a structureless point model with no polarization. Force-arrow length is capped for readability; readouts supply numerical values.
Status: Ready
Playback: 8 real seconds per run; read elapsed physical model time. Pause or Step for measurements.
Measurements
Load givens — then predict and run
Loading a setup earns no trial credit.
♢ DISCOVER — Ratios Need Controlled Conditions
DOK 1 — RecallFlip all 4 rule cards. Keep the quantities and model conditions clear.
Rule 1
Charge product
Click to flip
Charge product
At fixed separation and medium, each charge magnitude multiplies independently. Double one magnitude gives ×2 force; double both gives ×4. Reverse one sign to reverse direction while keeping magnitude.
Rule 2
Inverse square
Click to flip
Inverse square
At fixed charges and medium, scaling separation by c > 0 gives a magnitude factor 1/c². Double gives 1/4; triple gives 1/9. Separation is the point-to-point distance, not an arbitrary gap between extended surfaces.
Rule 3
Combine multiplicatively
Click to flip
Combine multiplicatively
If both charges and separation change, multiply the charge factors and divide by the square of the separation factor. Use positive magnitude factors and treat sign changes separately.
Rule 4
Model and force pair
Click to flip
Model and force pair
The point-charge law does not describe every charged extended or polarized object without further modelling. Mutual electrostatic forces are equal and opposite; electric-to-gravity strength ratios depend on the particles and are not universal.
All rules explored.
MISCONCEPTION ATTACK — Destroy the Myths
DOK 2 — AnalyzeChoose TRUE or FALSE for each claim. The explanation appears after an attempt; only a correct answer completes the claim.
Myth 1: “Tripling the separation divides the fixed-point-charge force by three.”
Correct — the claim is false.
False. The squared distance factor gives division by nine.
Myth 2: “Electric force is a conserved substance diluted over expanding spherical surfaces.”
Correct — the claim is false.
False. Coulomb force is evaluated at the test charge; force is not a conserved spreading substance. Point-source field geometry is a useful analogy when stated carefully.
Both myths corrected. Continue to the instructor questions.
✦ THE SECOND “AHA!” — Single and Combined Factors
DOK 2 — ApplyAll questions use nonzero fixed point charges at positive separations in an unchanged medium.
Instructor Q1 — Both Charges
Both charge magnitudes double while separation stays fixed. What is the force-magnitude factor?
Instructor Q2 — Reverse One Sign
Only the sign of B is reversed. What changes?
Instructor Q3 — Triple Separation
A force magnitude is 0.081 N. Separation triples with charges unchanged. Find the new magnitude.
Instructor Q4 — Two Changes
The initial force magnitude is 0.050 N. A’s charge magnitude quadruples and separation doubles; B’s charge and the medium stay fixed. Find the new magnitude.
4/4 — Instructor Questions Completed
Use the charge product and squared separation, with the point-charge and unchanged-medium assumptions explicit.
✎ PRACTICE — Independent Force-Ratio Problems
DOK 1–3 — PracticeChallenge 1: Distance Only
Two fixed point charges exert a force magnitude 0.072 N. Their separation doubles, with charges and medium unchanged. Determine the new force magnitude.
Step-by-Step Solution
Fnew/Fold = 1/2² = 1/4. Fnew = 0.072/4 = 0.018 N.
Challenge 2: Charges and Separation
The force magnitude between two point charges is initially 0.072 N. A’s charge magnitude triples, B’s doubles and their separation doubles. Signs and medium remain unchanged. Determine the new force magnitude.
Step-by-Step Solution
The factor is (3 × 2)/2² = 1.5. Fnew = 1.5(0.072) = 0.108 N.
Challenge 3: Audit a Scaling Report
A lies left of B; they are opposite nonzero point charges. Initially the force on A is +0.135 N with right positive. A’s charge magnitude doubles, B’s triples and their separation triples, with signs and medium unchanged. A report divides by 3 for the distance change, adds the charge factors to get 5, and says the heavier A exerts a larger force on B than B exerts on A. Find the new/old force-magnitude ratio and both new signed mutual forces. Explain all three errors.
Step-by-Step Solution
The factor is (2 × 3)/3² = 6/9 = 2/3. Attraction still acts right on A, so FA = +0.090 N and FB = −0.090 N.
Distance triples, so its squared factor is 9, not 3. Charge factors multiply to 6, not add to 5. The electric pair forces remain equal in magnitude and opposite in direction irrespective of unequal masses.
☷ CHALLENGE — Sort the Force-Magnitude Change
DOK 2 — ApplySort the Force-Magnitude Change
Assume nonzero fixed point charges, positive separation and unchanged medium.
0 / 6 correct
Physics Insight
Several simultaneous changes can cancel, but that requires computing their combined factor.
TEACH — The Feynman Technique
DOK 3 — TeachYour Final Mission: Explain the inverse-square point-charge rule and combine two charge factors with a distance factor. State what stays fixed, separate direction from magnitude, and explain why neither a polarized wall nor a universal electric-to-gravity ratio follows automatically.
Use simple words and at least three short sentences. This checks effort; compare your physics with the Vault or your teacher.
Type Your Explanation (≥ 3 sentences)
Draw a labelled explanation with at least three purposeful strokes. This checks effort; compare your physics with the Vault or your teacher.
Cyan pen selected.
Final reward below
Hidden exam secrets inside — Crest's private notebook.
Crest’s Secret Notebook
Mission 9.7 — Qualitative Electric Force
Change one factor at a time and combine charge and distance ratios.
1. Controlled comparisons
For two point charges in an unchanged medium, F = k|qAqB|/r² gives the magnitude. Separation r must be positive. Charge signs determine attraction or repulsion. This model can approximate small charged objects when size is negligible compared with separation, or a symmetric sphere outside under the appropriate conditions. Extended polarized bodies require further modelling.
2. Charge and distance factors
Double one charge magnitude: ×2 force. Double both: ×4. Triple separation: ×1/9. Halve separation: ×4. These comparisons require the other quantities to stay fixed.
Fnew/Fold = |a b|/c², with c > 0
Here a and b scale the charges and c scales the separation. Ratios using a nonzero old force require nonzero original charges. Reversing one charge sign changes direction; it need not change magnitude. When both magnitudes and separation all scale by the same positive factor, their magnitude effects cancel.
3. Avoid the spreading-force misconception
An isolated point source has a spherically symmetric electric field whose magnitude falls as 1/r². Spherical geometry helps visualize this field dependence, but electric force is not a conserved fluid divided among surface patches. A test charge experiences F = qE at its location. Light or sound intensity can follow an inverse-square rule for ideal isotropic point sources without losses; that does not make all waves or static forces interchangeable.
4. Force pair and gravity comparison
The mutual electrostatic forces are equal and opposite. Larger mass changes acceleration, not the force-pair equality. The ratio of electric to gravitational force between charged particles is k|qAqB|/(GmAmB); it depends on the specific charges and masses, so a single enormous ratio is not universal. Macroscopic matter can be nearly neutral despite its many charged particles.
5. Live controlled sweep
A is supported at a fixed position. An external actuator moves B from 0.15 m to the selected final separation over four model seconds, with smooth prescribed motion. Coulomb forces are recomputed at each separation using k = 9.00 × 10⁹ N m²/C² and nC = 10⁻⁹ C. The drawn motion is imposed by the actuator, not the free response to the electric force. Arrow lengths are capped; use numeric readouts.
A zero-charge point probe has no internal polarization and gives zero monopole force; it does not represent real neutral paper. Current/initial force ratio is undefined when both forces are zero. Four model seconds play over eight real seconds. Compare A charge at fixed other controls, then final separation with charges fixed.
6. Worked practice
0.072 N at twice the separation becomes 0.018 N. With charge factors 3 and 2 and distance factor 2, it becomes 0.108 N. In the report, the factor is 6/9 = 2/3; the new force on A is +0.090 N and on B −0.090 N. Multiplication, squaring and the mutual-force relation resolve the three errors.
7. Scope
AP Physics 2 topic 10.1 and Cambridge A Level 9702 topic 18.3 include point-charge electric force and inverse-square dependence. Neutral polarization is a separate model rather than an automatic application of this two-point-charge ratio.
✓ Crest’s Checklist
- I identify what stays fixed.
- I multiply the two charge factors.
- I square the separation factor.
- I separate signs from magnitudes.
- I respect the point-charge approximation.
- I use equal opposite mutual forces.
— Crest ☆ “Change one factor at a time and combine charge and distance ratios.”
Mission 9.7 Complete! · All 10 levels cleared · PHYSICS CREST
★ Qualitative Electric Force Master
Use the charge product and squared separation, with the point-charge and unchanged-medium assumptions explicit.