WONDER — The Mystery
Zero Resultant Force Can Still Turn a Coil
Equal and opposite forces on separated coil sides form a couple. In uniform B the closed coil has zero resultant magnetic force, yet can have a nonzero torque. A simple brushed d.c. motor uses a split ring to reverse its coil connections near each half-turn.
Model: For N identical planar turns in uniform B, torque magnitude is |NIAB sinθ|, with θ between the chosen area normal and B. The vector magnetic moment is NIA n and torque is μ × B. Opposite forces cancel as a resultant but their moments can add. Dead-centre zero torque does not instantly stop an already moving rotor.
PREDICT — Commit to Your Answer
DOK 2 — PredictA freely mounted coil has equal and opposite forces whose lines of action are separated. Starting at rest, what can happen?
Commit to both a prediction and a reason before revealing the explanation.
Step 1: Pick your answer.
STOP! Before revealing — why did you pick that?
Correct prediction and reasoning saved.
Translation responds to resultant force; angular acceleration responds to resultant torque. A couple has zero resultant force but can rotate a coil.
▶ PLAY — A Rotor Accelerating Under Its Actual Torque
DOK 2 — InvestigatePredict, measure and compare
Compare two current magnitudes at fixed turns, then two turn counts at fixed current. Compare commutated and uncommutated coils. Watch current reversals, changing torque and rotor speed.
Extension: N identical 0.0040 m² turns rotate in uniform B = 0.30 T about a fixed z axis. Inertia is 0.0010 kg m² and viscous drag is 0.0020 N m s. The geometric area normal makes angle α from +x field; initially α = 90° and angular speed is zero. Signed coil current is −I0 sign(sinα) with ideal split-ring commutation, or constant −I0 without it. Thus τz = −N A B Icoil sinα and J α″ = τz − b α′. Numerical integration follows 2.0 physical seconds over 6 real seconds. Contacts reverse at α = 0° or 180°, where torque is zero; inertia carries a moving rotor through these positions. Zero-drive trials start at rest. An ideal regulated source compensates induced e.m.f.; resistance, brush gaps and startup dead spots beyond this geometry are omitted. Drawn dimensions are schematic.
Status: Ready
Playback: 6 real seconds per run; read elapsed physical model time. Pause or Step for measurements.
Measurements
Load givens — then predict and run
Loading a setup earns no trial credit.
♢ DISCOVER — Couples, Angles and Commutation
DOK 1 — RecallFlip all 4 rule cards. Keep the quantities and model conditions clear.
Rule 1
Uniform-field coil torque
Click to flip
Uniform-field coil torque
For N planar turns, μ = NIA n and τvector = μ × B. The magnitude is |NIAB sinθ|. The angle is between area normal and B, not automatically between the coil plane and B.
Rule 2
Zero and maximum
Click to flip
Zero and maximum
At normal angles 0° and 180°, magnetic torque is zero. Magnitude is greatest at 90°. A moving rotor can pass through zero torque using inertia; a single-coil motor initially at a dead point may fail to self-start.
Rule 3
Simple brushed d.c. motor
Click to flip
Simple brushed d.c. motor
The split-ring commutator reverses coil connections near each half-turn, maintaining the intended torque sense between dead points. Brushes provide stationary contacts. Electronic commutation is used in other motor designs.
Rule 4
More turns versus smoother torque
Click to flip
More turns versus smoother torque
At fixed geometry and current, increasing identical N, area or B increases torque amplitude. Merely adding turns to the same coil does not smooth its normalized torque variation. Several coils distributed at different rotor angles can reduce torque ripple.
All rules explored.
MISCONCEPTION ATTACK — Destroy the Myths
DOK 2 — AnalyzeChoose TRUE or FALSE for each claim. The explanation appears after an attempt; only a correct answer completes the claim.
Myth 1: “At a zero-torque orientation a rotating coil must instantly stop.”
Correct — the claim is false.
False. Angular speed is continuous under finite torque; inertia can carry the rotor through a dead point.
Myth 2: “All d.c. motors require a mechanical split-ring commutator.”
Correct — the claim is false.
False. The simple brushed model uses one; other designs can use electronic commutation.
Both myths corrected. Continue to the instructor questions.
✦ THE SECOND “AHA!” — Torque and Angle Checks
DOK 2 — ApplyDefine the angle before calculating a coil torque.
Instructor Q1 — A Couple
Equal opposite forces on separated parallel lines give:
Instructor Q2 — Angle Convention
The coil plane is perpendicular to B. The normal is parallel to B, so torque is:
Instructor Q3 — Perpendicular Normal
N = 60, I = 0.50 A, A = 0.020 m², B = 0.40 T and normal angle 90°. Find torque magnitude.
Instructor Q4 — Tilted Normal
N = 20, I = 2.0 A, A = 0.010 m², B = 0.30 T and normal angle 30°. Find torque magnitude.
4/4 — Instructor Questions Completed
Zero resultant force, zero instantaneous torque and zero angular speed are three different statements.
✎ PRACTICE — Independent Motor Audits
DOK 1–3 — PracticeChallenge 1: Coil Torque
A 30-turn planar coil has area 0.010 m² and carries 0.80 A in uniform B = 0.20 T. Its area normal is perpendicular to B. Find magnetic torque magnitude.
Step-by-Step Solution
τ = 30×0.80×0.010×0.20 = 0.0480 N m.
Challenge 2: Plane Angle and Current
A 50-turn coil of area 0.020 m² is in uniform B = 0.40 T. The coil plane makes 30° with B. A torque magnitude 0.20√3 N m is measured. Find current magnitude and the torque magnitude when the same current is maintained but the normal becomes perpendicular to B.
Step-by-Step Solution
Normal angle = 60°. 0.20√3 = 50×I×0.020×0.40×(√3/2), so I = 1.0 A. At normal 90°, τ = 0.40 N m.
Challenge 3: Audit a Rotor Report
A 40-turn 0.015 m² coil carries 0.50 A in uniform B = 0.30 T, with normal angle 90°. Rotor inertia is 0.0020 kg m² and drag torque is initially zero. Find initial torque magnitude and angular acceleration magnitude. A report claims zero resultant force means no rotation, zero torque at a later dead point means instant stopping, and doubling turns on this same coil removes torque ripple. Correct all three claims and explain how commutation supports continued rotation.
Explanation checks are indicative. Compare your reasoning with the worked solution or your teacher.
Step-by-Step Solution
τ = 40×0.50×0.015×0.30 = 0.090 N m; acceleration = 0.090/0.0020 = 45 rad/s². A couple can rotate despite zero resultant force. Inertia carries motion through zero torque. More coincident turns scale torque but do not remove ripple; distributed coils can smooth it. Current reversal near each half-turn maintains the intended torque sense.
☷ CHALLENGE — What Does a Motor Change?
DOK 2 — ApplyWhat Does a Motor Change?
Select each statement and place it in its matching category. Judge the physical conditions.
0 / 6 correct
Physics Insight
Zero resultant force, zero instantaneous torque and zero angular speed are three different statements.
TEACH — The Feynman Technique
DOK 3 — TeachYour Final Mission: Explain the couple, angle convention, inertia at dead points, split-ring current reversal, energy conversion and the difference between more turns and distributed coils.
Use simple words and at least three short sentences. This checks effort; compare your physics with the Vault or your teacher.
Type Your Explanation (≥ 3 sentences)
Draw a labelled explanation with at least three purposeful strokes. This checks effort; compare your physics with the Vault or your teacher.
Cyan pen selected.
Final reward below
Hidden exam secrets inside — Crest's private notebook.
Crest’s Secret Notebook
Mission 11.12 — DC Motors
Reach the Peak of Understanding
1. Uniform-field coil torque
For N planar turns, μ = NIA n and τvector = μ × B. The magnitude is |NIAB sinθ|. The angle is between area normal and B, not automatically between the coil plane and B.
2. Zero and maximum
At normal angles 0° and 180°, magnetic torque is zero. Magnitude is greatest at 90°. A moving rotor can pass through zero torque using inertia; a single-coil motor initially at a dead point may fail to self-start.
3. Simple brushed d.c. motor
The split-ring commutator reverses coil connections near each half-turn, maintaining the intended torque sense between dead points. Brushes provide stationary contacts. Electronic commutation is used in other motor designs.
4. More turns versus smoother torque
At fixed geometry and current, increasing identical N, area or B increases torque amplitude. Merely adding turns to the same coil does not smooth its normalized torque variation. Several coils distributed at different rotor angles can reduce torque ripple.
5. Without commutation
With fixed coil current and damping, an unforced current loop can oscillate and settle with its magnetic moment aligned with B. Without damping it need not settle. Initial speed, load and circuit control matter.
6. Motor and generator
Many electromagnetic machines can operate in either mode with appropriate connections and control. The source supplies mechanical work in motor operation; mechanically driven motion can induce e.m.f. in generator operation.
Worked independent practice
C1: 0.0480 N m. C2: 1.0 A and 0.40 N m. C3: 0.090 N m and 45 rad/s²; distinguish couples, inertia, ripple and commutation.
Live investigation and access
Extension: N identical 0.0040 m² turns rotate in uniform B = 0.30 T about a fixed z axis. Inertia is 0.0010 kg m² and viscous drag is 0.0020 N m s. The geometric area normal makes angle α from +x field; initially α = 90° and angular speed is zero. Signed coil current is −I0 sign(sinα) with ideal split-ring commutation, or constant −I0 without it. Thus τz = −N A B Icoil sinα and J α″ = τz − b α′. Numerical integration follows 2.0 physical seconds over 6 real seconds. Contacts reverse at α = 0° or 180°, where torque is zero; inertia carries a moving rotor through these positions. Zero-drive trials start at rest. An ideal regulated source compensates induced e.m.f.; resistance, brush gaps and startup dead spots beyond this geometry are omitted. Drawn dimensions are schematic.
Run, Pause, Step and Reset work offline. Complete three matched measurements. Loading a preset is not completing a trial. Saved progress resumes paused. Reduced-motion Run gives a final snapshot; Step allows deliberate inspection. Hints and solutions require a genuine unsuccessful numerical attempt and never complete a task. Explanation rubrics are indicative; compare your physics with the solution or a teacher. Teaching submission checks effort rather than certifying scientific accuracy.
Course scope
Conductor force and motor-effect reasoning support A Level 9702 20.2 and AP Physics 2 12.3. Detailed coil torque, split-ring construction and rotational dynamics are applications/extensions, not separately claimed required objectives.
Sources: Cambridge International 9702 syllabus ; College Board AP Physics 2 CED. Detailed extension models are labelled in the mission.
✓ Crest’s Checklist
- I distinguish force and torque.
- I use the area-normal angle.
- I distinguish zero torque from rest.
- I qualify brushed motor commutation.
- I do not confuse turn count with distributed coils.
— Crest ☆ “Reach the Peak of Understanding”
Mission 11.12 Complete! · All 10 levels cleared · PHYSICS CREST
★ DC Motors Investigator
Zero resultant force, zero instantaneous torque and zero angular speed are three different statements.