WONDER — The Mystery
A Zero Integral Can Hide a Nonzero Field
A closed path may enclose no net steady current even though a magnetic field exists at every point on it. Ampère’s law fixes a circulation, not the field at every point. What extra information lets us turn that integral into a simple formula?
Model: In vacuum magnetostatics, ∮B·dℓ = μ₀Ienc. A chosen circulation fixes the positive surface normal by the right-hand rule; Ienc is the algebraic current through that surface. External currents can affect local B while contributing zero to this closed circulation. Symmetry is needed to extract B by simple algebra.
PREDICT — Commit to Your Answer
DOK 2 — PredictTwo long parallel wires pierce a chosen surface with currents +6 A and −4 A. A third 9 A wire lies outside it. What is the enclosed current for the closed boundary?
Commit to both a prediction and a reason before revealing the explanation.
Step 1: Pick your answer.
STOP! Before revealing — why did you pick that?
Correct prediction and reasoning saved.
Ienc = 6 − 4 = +2 A. The external wire can change the field on the boundary, but has zero net contribution to its magnetostatic closed circulation.
▶ PLAY — Move a Probe Around an Amperian Path
DOK 2 — InvestigatePredict, measure and compare
Measure two currents at one geometry setting, then two settings at one current. Watch a probe physically traverse the path and build the signed line integral. Also inspect the ideal solenoid and toroid cases.
A motor moves a passive, negligible-size vector-field probe around a prescribed closed path in six model seconds over six real seconds. It samples steady fields without perturbing their sources; the accumulated B·dℓ is a calculated spatial integral, not energy or magnetic material. Geometry 0 is an ideal long wire; 1 is an ideal infinite air-core solenoid; 2 is an ideal uniformly wound air-core toroid with N = 200 turns. Setting k gives r = 0.020k m for circular paths, or n = 200k m⁻¹ for the solenoid. Toroid inner/outer radii are 0.015/0.15 m, so circular paths stay inside its winding region. The solenoid rectangle has a 0.10 m internal side along +B and a 0.10 m outside side with B = 0 in the infinite model; perpendicular sides contribute zero. A steady field does not grow from zero when Run is pressed. Field-arrow lengths and drawing dimensions are schematic.
Status: Ready
Playback: 6 real seconds per run; read elapsed physical model time. Pause or Step for measurements.
Measurements
Load givens — then predict and run
Loading a setup earns no trial credit.
♢ DISCOVER — Circulation Is Not a Local Field
DOK 1 — RecallFlip all 4 rule cards. Keep the quantities and model conditions clear.
Rule 1
Magnetostatic law
Click to flip
Magnetostatic law
∮B·dℓ = μ₀Ienc applies to steady currents in the vacuum formulation used here. The left side is a signed closed line integral, with units T m. It is not magnetic flux, whose units are T m².
Rule 2
Signed enclosed current
Click to flip
Signed enclosed current
Count the algebraic current through a surface bounded by the path. Fix a circulation and compatible normal. Reversing both reverses the signs of the integral and Ienc. Currents outside are excluded from Ienc, but may contribute to local B.
Rule 3
Use symmetry explicitly
Click to flip
Use symmetry explicitly
A circle centered on an isolated ideal long wire has constant-magnitude tangential B, so ∮B·dℓ = B(2πr). An arbitrary path does not generally allow B times its entire perimeter. A solenoid rectangle has only one contributing long side in its infinite ideal model.
Rule 4
Zero circulation and broader scope
Click to flip
Zero circulation and broader scope
Ienc = 0 implies zero magnetostatic circulation, not B = 0 everywhere. In a symmetric ideal coax with equal opposite currents, cylindrical symmetry additionally permits the zero outside field. For time-dependent electric flux, the full Ampère–Maxwell law includes the displacement-current term.
All rules explored.
MISCONCEPTION ATTACK — Destroy the Myths
DOK 2 — AnalyzeChoose TRUE or FALSE for each claim. The explanation appears after an attempt; only a correct answer completes the claim.
Myth 1: “An outside current cannot affect the magnetic field at any point on an Amperian path.”
Correct — the claim is false.
False. It may affect local B; its magnetostatic contribution to the complete closed circulation is zero.
Myth 2: “Zero enclosed current always means zero field everywhere on the path.”
Correct — the claim is false.
False. A nonzero uniform field, for example, has zero closed circulation because opposite-segment contributions cancel.
Both myths corrected. Continue to the instructor questions.
✦ THE SECOND “AHA!” — Signed Current and Symmetry Checks
DOK 2 — ApplyKeep pointwise field, spatial integral and enclosed current distinct.
Instructor Q1 — An External Wire
A steady wire outside a closed path can:
Instructor Q2 — No Symmetry
Which statement is correct for an irregular path around steady currents?
Instructor Q3 — Signed Current Sum
A surface is pierced by +8 A and −3 A currents. Find Ienc.
Instructor Q4 — Wire Field
An isolated long wire carries 6.0 A. Find B at r = 0.040 m.
4/4 — Instructor Questions Completed
First establish the field’s symmetry and direction along each path segment. Only then simplify the integral.
✎ PRACTICE — Independent Integral Reasoning
DOK 1–3 — PracticeChallenge 1: Signed Current Through a Surface
In vacuum magnetostatics, a chosen positive normal has three piercing currents: +7.0 A, −2.0 A and +1.0 A. Find their algebraic enclosed current. A further 12 A wire is outside the boundary.
Step-by-Step Solution
Ienc = 7 − 2 + 1 = +6.0 A. The outside 12 A wire is not included in this sum.
Challenge 2: Derive and Compare a Toroid Field
An ideal uniformly wound air-core toroid has 150 turns carrying 2.0 A, with inner radius 0.030 m and outer radius 0.10 m. Find field magnitudes at circular radii 0.050 m and 0.080 m inside its winding region. Use circular symmetry about the toroid axis when applying the law.
Step-by-Step Solution
A symmetric circular path has ∮B·dℓ = B2πr and Ienc = NI. Thus B = μ₀NI/(2πr). At 0.050 m B = 1.20×10⁻³ T; at 0.080 m B = 7.50×10⁻⁴ T. Both radii lie within the winding region.
Challenge 3: Audit a Zero-Current Inference
A square path of side 0.20 m lies in a uniform steady field B = 0.0040 T directed rightward along its top edge. Traverse the top edge rightward and the bottom edge leftward. No current pierces the square. Find the top-edge contribution and the complete closed circulation in T m. A report concludes: “Ienc = 0 proves B = 0 everywhere; an external source cannot affect B; and any closed integral equals B times the entire perimeter.” Correct every inference. Contrast this square with an ideal symmetric coaxial cable carrying equal opposite currents.
Explanation checks are indicative. Compare your reasoning with the worked solution or your teacher.
Step-by-Step Solution
Top: +Bℓ = +8.0×10⁻⁴ T m; bottom: −8.0×10⁻⁴ T m; perpendicular sides: zero. Total circulation is zero despite nonzero local B. External sources can affect local fields. B times perimeter requires a constant tangential field around the entire path, which this square lacks. For the ideal concentric coax, cylindrical symmetry makes B tangential and constant at each outside radius; zero enclosed net current then implies B = 0 there. Zero current alone is insufficient without that symmetry.
☷ CHALLENGE — What Does This Statement Describe?
DOK 2 — ApplyWhat Does This Statement Describe?
Select each statement and place it in its matching category. Judge the physical conditions.
0 / 6 correct
Physics Insight
First establish the field’s symmetry and direction along each path segment. Only then simplify the integral.
TEACH — The Feynman Technique
DOK 3 — TeachYour Final Mission: Explain Ampère’s magnetostatic law, signed enclosed current, local field versus circulation, and why symmetry is essential when solving for B.
Use simple words and at least three short sentences. This checks effort; compare your physics with the Vault or your teacher.
Type Your Explanation (≥ 3 sentences)
Draw a labelled explanation with at least three purposeful strokes. This checks effort; compare your physics with the Vault or your teacher.
Cyan pen selected.
Final reward below
Hidden exam secrets inside — Crest's private notebook.
Crest’s Secret Notebook
Mission 11.8 — Ampère’s Circuital Law
Reach the Peak of Understanding
1. Magnetostatic law
∮B·dℓ = μ₀Ienc applies to steady currents in the vacuum formulation used here. The left side is a signed closed line integral, with units T m. It is not magnetic flux, whose units are T m².
2. Signed enclosed current
Count the algebraic current through a surface bounded by the path. Fix a circulation and compatible normal. Reversing both reverses the signs of the integral and Ienc. Currents outside are excluded from Ienc, but may contribute to local B.
3. Use symmetry explicitly
A circle centered on an isolated ideal long wire has constant-magnitude tangential B, so ∮B·dℓ = B(2πr). An arbitrary path does not generally allow B times its entire perimeter. A solenoid rectangle has only one contributing long side in its infinite ideal model.
4. Zero circulation and broader scope
Ienc = 0 implies zero magnetostatic circulation, not B = 0 everywhere. In a symmetric ideal coax with equal opposite currents, cylindrical symmetry additionally permits the zero outside field. For time-dependent electric flux, the full Ampère–Maxwell law includes the displacement-current term.
5. Ideal applications
Long wire: B = μ₀I/(2πr). Ideal infinite solenoid: B = μ₀nI inside, zero outside, using only the contributing internal segment. Ideal air-core toroid: B = μ₀NI/(2πr) within its winding region; ideal symmetric external field is zero. Coax: use the actual net enclosed current and cylindrical symmetry.
6. Full time-dependent law
In vacuum ∮B·dℓ = μ₀Icond + μ₀ε₀ dΦE/dt. The displacement-current contribution is needed for changing electric flux; it is not an extra stream of conduction charges in a capacitor gap. The simple steady-current law is a special case.
7. Material and geometry limits
A real ferromagnetic transformer core cannot be described universally by μ₀nI with one fixed iron multiplier. Finite geometry, return currents, saturation and hysteresis need suitable models. A path is a mathematical construction, not a required physical wire.
Worked independent practice
C1: +6 A. C2: 1.20×10⁻³ T and 7.50×10⁻⁴ T. C3: +8×10⁻⁴ T m on the top edge and zero total circulation. Nonzero local fields and zero circulation are consistent; a coax needs cylindrical symmetry to infer zero outside field.
Live investigation and access
A motor moves a passive, negligible-size vector-field probe around a prescribed closed path in six model seconds over six real seconds. It samples steady fields without perturbing their sources; the accumulated B·dℓ is a calculated spatial integral, not energy or magnetic material. Geometry 0 is an ideal long wire; 1 is an ideal infinite air-core solenoid; 2 is an ideal uniformly wound air-core toroid with N = 200 turns. Setting k gives r = 0.020k m for circular paths, or n = 200k m⁻¹ for the solenoid. Toroid inner/outer radii are 0.015/0.15 m, so circular paths stay inside its winding region. The solenoid rectangle has a 0.10 m internal side along +B and a 0.10 m outside side with B = 0 in the infinite model; perpendicular sides contribute zero. A steady field does not grow from zero when Run is pressed. Field-arrow lengths and drawing dimensions are schematic.
Run, Pause, Step and Reset work offline. Complete three matched measurements. Loading a preset is not completing a trial. Saved progress resumes paused. Reduced-motion Run gives a final snapshot; Step allows deliberate inspection. Hints and solutions require a genuine unsuccessful numerical attempt and never complete a task. Explanation rubrics are indicative; compare your physics with the solution or a teacher. Teaching submission checks effort rather than certifying scientific accuracy.
Course scope
The integral Ampère law, toroid derivation and Ampère–Maxwell comparison are enrichment beyond the listed A Level 9702 Topic 20 and AP Physics 2 Unit 12 requirements. Long-wire fields and current-field reasoning connect to their required material. Magnetostatic vacuum assumptions are explicit.
Sources: Cambridge International 9702 syllabus ; College Board AP Physics 2 CED. Detailed extension models are labelled in the mission.
✓ Crest’s Checklist
- I specify a circulation and compatible normal.
- I sum piercing currents with signs.
- I distinguish T m from Wb.
- I do not infer local zero B from zero circulation alone.
- I explain the symmetry used before extracting B.
— Crest ☆ “Reach the Peak of Understanding”
Mission 11.8 Complete! · All 10 levels cleared · PHYSICS CREST
★ Ampère’s Circuital Law Investigator
First establish the field’s symmetry and direction along each path segment. Only then simplify the integral.