PHYSICS CREST
Physics

Topic 5.1 · The Nuclear Model of the Atom

Gravity in calculations: near Earth, g ≈ 9.8 m/s² (9.8 N/kg). Use the value supplied by the question, page instructions or activity; use 10 when it is specified.

Count particles, compare identities, conserve A and Z, then turn every scattering observation into one precise conclusion.

Atoms & ionsA · Z · NScattering evidenceFission & fusionSimulation ATP
ATOMIC-MODEL EXAMINER DECODERCOUNTp · n · eA, Z, chargeCOMPAREsame Z?ion or isotopeCONSERVEΣA and ΣZnuclear equationINFERtrack → evidenceatomic modelCOUNT → COMPARE →CONSERVE → INFERCOUNT · COMPARE · CONSERVE · INFER
Four moves organise the whole topic: decode the particles, protect element identity, balance both number rows, and match evidence precisely.
2
Tiny centre · vast surrounding space

Atomic structure

NUCLEAR MODEL OF THE ATOM++++00000−−−−−−tiny positivenucleusnegative electronmostly empty space
Read this as a model, not a scale drawing: the real nucleus is far smaller relative to the atom.
WHAT THE MODEL MUST SHOW+++0000−−−nucleus central ·electrons outside
Marks come from correct location and charge, not from artistic orbit shapes.
ATOM MODEL: very small, positively charged nucleus + negatively charged electrons orbiting/surrounding it.
RegionParticlesChargeScale meaning
nucleusprotons and neutronspositive overalltiny; contains most atomic mass
surrounding spaceelectronsnegativeaccounts for almost all atomic volume
  1. Draw one clear central nucleus.
  2. Place protons and neutrons inside it.
  3. Place electrons outside, surrounding the nucleus.
  4. Label charge signs only when the question needs them.
Picture mnemonicTINY + CENTRE · NEGATIVE OUTSIDE

“Tiny” refers to nuclear size; “mostly empty” refers to atomic volume.

Drawing mark: an orbit is a representation. Do not claim that the drawn sizes and distances are to scale unless the question states this.
Language trap: the atom is not “made of empty space only”. It is mostly empty space and contains a small nucleus plus electrons.
Quick Check · Where is most atomic mass?
In the nucleus, because protons and neutrons have relative mass about 1 while electron mass is very small.
3
Location, charge and mass are different columns

Particle mass and charge

  • Protons have relative charge +1, neutrons 0 and electrons −1.
  • Protons and neutrons occupy the nucleus; electrons are outside it.
  • The nucleus contains nearly all mass but very little of the atom’s volume.
SUBATOMIC PARTICLE LEDGERparticlelocationrelative chargerelative massprotonnucleus+11neutronnucleus01electronaround nucleus−1very smallcharge: +1 · 0 · −1
Learn the three rows, but answer only the column named by the command word.
COUNTING WORKSPACEprotonnucleus · +1 · mass 1neutronnucleus · 0 · mass 1electronoutside · −1 · very smallmassp and n are nucleons · eis not
Nucleon means either a proton or a neutron.
ParticleSymbolLocationRelative chargeRelative mass
protonpnucleus+11
neutronnnucleus01
electronearound nucleus−1very small

NUCLEONS

$A=p+n$. Electrons never contribute to $A$.

CHARGE

For a whole particle, charge number = $p-e$.

ELEMENT

$Z=p$. The proton number names the element.

Charge mnemonicPLUS · PLAIN · MINUS

Proton is plus, neutron is plain zero, electron is minus.

Precision: say “relative nuclear mass” when the question refers to the nucleus. At this level it follows the nucleon number $A$.
Mass trap: zero charge does not mean zero mass. A neutron has charge 0 but relative mass 1.
Quick Check · Which particles contribute to both A and nuclear mass?
Protons and neutrons. Both are nucleons, each with relative mass about 1.
4
Only electrons cross the before/after arrow

Ions

  • Removing electrons makes positive ions; adding electrons makes negative ions.
  • Changing electrons does not change the element.
ATOM → ION CHARGE LEDGERbefore11 p11 eneutralafter11 p10 echarge = 1+one electron lostproton number stays fixed
Losing a negative electron leaves one more proton than electron: charge 1+.
ATOM → ION CHARGE LEDGERbefore8 p8 eneutralafter8 p10 echarge = 2−two electrons gainedproton number stays fixed
Gaining two negative electrons gives charge 2−.
charge number = number of protons − number of electrons
Neutral: $p=e$ · Positive ion: $p>e$ · Negative ion: $e>p$.
Interactive · Charge builder

Count first; name the sign second

charge = 2+ · positive ion
  1. Ignore neutrons when calculating charge.
  2. Write $p-e$ with the actual counts.
  3. Convert a positive result to $n+$ and a negative result to $n-$.
  4. State “lost electrons” for a positive ion and “gained electrons” for a negative ion.
Ion mnemonicLOSE − → BECOME + · GAIN − → BECOME −

Electrons move; the nucleus stays unchanged in ordinary ion formation.

Complete explanation: “The atom loses two electrons, so it has two more protons than electrons and forms a 2+ ion.”
Identity trap: losing electrons does not create a new isotope or element. Both depend on the nucleus.
Quick Check · 17 protons and 18 electrons: atom or ion, and charge?
A 1− ion. There is one more electron than proton.
5
Upper A · lower Z · subtract for N

Nuclide notation

  • In nuclide notation A is nucleon number and Z proton number.
  • Neutrons = A − Z.
  • A neutral atom has Z electrons.
  • Nuclear relative charge is +Z and nuclear relative mass is approximately A, because electron mass is negligible in this comparison.
NUCLIDE NOTATIONP3115A = nucleonsZ = protonsion chargeN = A − Z
Read the lower number first for protons; subtract only after identifying A and Z.
COUNTING WORKSPACEprotons pZ = 15neutrons nA − Z = 16electrons e15 if neutralnuclear charge+15A = 31 · Z = 15 · N = 16
One notation badge can produce several different requested quantities.
$p=Z$   ·   $n=A-Z$   ·   neutral atom: $e=Z$
Interactive · A–Z–N decoder

Build the complete particle ledger

p = 18 · n = 22 · e = 18
  1. Circle the lower number: it is $Z$ and therefore the proton count.
  2. Read the upper number: it is $A=p+n$.
  3. Subtract $A-Z$ for neutrons.
  4. Only then use neutral/ion information to find electrons.
Notation mnemonicA = ALL NUCLEONS · Z = PROTON ID · N = A − Z

The letters A and Z are labels, not algebraic unknowns unless the question makes them unknown.

Most common error: $A-Z$ gives neutrons, not electrons. Electron count comes from charge and proton count.
Quick Check · For $^{56}_{26}X^{3+}$, find p, n and e.
p = 26, n = 56 − 26 = 30, e = 26 − 3 = 23.

Pause · explain it yourself

A neutral atom has 17 protons and 18 neutrons. Give A, Z and electron count.

Your turn · A neutral atom has A = 40 and Z = 18. How many neutrons are in its nucleus?

Decimals and scientific notation are accepted. Compatible units are accepted.

7
Same element fingerprint · different neutron count

Isotopes

  • Isotopes have the same proton number and different neutron numbers, so they are the same element with different nucleon numbers.
  • An isotope is not automatically radioactive.
ISOTOPE FINGERPRINTX3517n = 18X3717n = 20same Z · different N →isotopes
Matching Z gives the same element; different A gives different neutron counts.
ISOTOPE FINGERPRINTR4018n = 22S4020n = 20same A is not enough · Zdiffers
Equal nucleon number does not make isotopes when proton numbers differ.
ISOTOPES: atoms/nuclei of the same element with the same proton number but different neutron numbers.
Choose a pair and apply the same-Z test.
  1. Compare $Z$ values. If they differ, stop: different elements.
  2. If $Z$ matches, compare $A$ or calculate $N=A-Z$.
  3. Different $N$ means isotopes; equal $N$ means the same nuclide.
  4. Ignore electron differences when deciding isotope identity.
Isotope mnemonicSAME Z · DIFFERENT N

Say both halves in an explanation. “Different mass” alone is incomplete.

Full-mark sentence: “They have the same proton number, so they are the same element, but different neutron numbers, so they are isotopes.”
Ion trap: two versions with different electrons but identical nuclei are different charge states of the same isotope.
Quick Check · Can two isotopes have the same A?
Not if they are isotopes of the same element: the same Z and same A would also give the same neutron count, making them the same nuclide.

Pause · explain it yourself

Why are carbon-12 and carbon-14 the same element?

Two isotopes of the same element must have which feature in common?

8
Read direction and frequency together

Alpha-particle scattering

  • Most alpha particles pass through thin metal foil with little deflection, supporting an atom that is mostly empty space.
  • A few undergo large deflections and very few return.
  • These rare events imply a tiny concentrated region containing most mass.
HISTORICAL ALPHA-SCATTERING SETUPsealedsourcethin foilscreenobserve track directionand frequency
Historical arrangement: a narrow alpha beam, thin foil and surrounding detecting screen.
SCATTERING TRACK BOARD++++00000straight: many ·large-angle: very few
The key pattern is not “some deflect”. It is many straight, some small-angle and very few large-angle/backward.
CLOSEST-APPROACH PATH++++00000+positive projectilecloser path → strongerdeflection
A very close approach to the compact positive nucleus can produce a large deflection.
Observed trackHow common?Immediate meaning
straight / almost straightnearly allmost incident particles cross empty space
small deflectionsomepositive projectile passes near the positive centre
large angle / backwardvery fewrare, very close approach to a tiny concentrated nucleus
Track mnemonicMOST STRAIGHT · SOME BEND · VERY FEW RETURN

Frequency is evidence about scale; direction is evidence about charge.

Historical evidence, safe learning: interpret diagrams, computer simulations or teacher-supplied track data. This is not a student source-handling practical.
Collision trap: do not say every deflected particle “hits” the nucleus. Electrostatic repulsion acts as a particle approaches.
Quick Check · Why use a thin target?
A thin target makes it more likely that a recorded deflection can be linked to one close nuclear encounter rather than many successive interactions.
9
Observation first · conclusion second

Evidence for the nuclear model

  • Positive alpha particles are repelled by the nucleus, supporting positive nuclear charge.
  • Separate observation from inference: most pass through is evidence, while mostly empty space is the model conclusion.
  • Uniformly spread charge would not explain the rare large deflections as well.
  • The experiment supplies evidence rather than a direct photograph of the whole atom.
OBSERVATION → INFERENCEmost pass straightatom mostly emptyfew turn stronglynucleus tiny + massivepositive paths repelnucleus positiveone observation earns oneprecise inference
Three observations support different parts of the nuclear model.
SCATTERING TRACK BOARD++++00000a large sample revealsrare events
Because large deflections are rare, a large number of incident particles is needed.
Select an observation to build its strongest inference.
  1. Quote the observation: include both direction and frequency.
  2. Name the inference: empty space, tiny nucleus, concentrated mass or positive charge.
  3. Add the mechanism only if “explain” is used: a close positive-positive interaction causes strong repulsion.

MOST STRAIGHT

The atom is mostly empty space.

FEW LARGE

The nucleus is very small and contains most mass.

REPEL

The nucleus is positively charged.

Evidence mnemonicSTRAIGHT → SPACE · RARE → TINY · REPEL → POSITIVE

Do not use “large deflection” as evidence that the atom is mostly empty; its rarity is evidence that the nucleus is tiny.

Two-mark construction: observation + inference. Example: “Very few particles return, so the region containing most mass must occupy a very small volume.”
Quick Check · Which observation supports “most mass is concentrated”?
The rare large-angle or backward deflections: only a compact massive centre can strongly change the motion of an incoming alpha particle.

Pause · explain it yourself

What observation supports a nucleus much smaller than the atom?

10
One heavy nucleus splits

Nuclear fission

  • Fission splits a large nucleus, often releasing neutrons and energy.
Fission example · conserve total A and total ZFission example · conserve total A and total Z²³⁵₉₂U + ¹₀n¹⁴¹₅₆Ba + ⁹²₃₆Kr + 3 ¹₀nA: 235 + 1 = 141 + 92 + 3 = 236Z: 92 + 0 = 56 + 36 + 0 = 92One heavy nucleus splits into smaller nuclei; energy is released.
Fission changes one heavy nucleus into two smaller nuclei plus other particles such as neutrons.
NUCLEAR EQUATION BALANCELEFT TOTALA235 + 1 = 236Z92 + 0 = 92RIGHT TOTALA141 + 92 + 3 = 236Z56 + 36 + 0 = 92split pattern + bothtotals conserved
The equation is checked twice: once for A and once for Z.
FISSION = SPLIT: a large nucleus splits into two smaller nuclei, with other particles possible.
  1. Recognise one heavy nucleus on the reactant side.
  2. Recognise two smaller nuclear products.
  3. Count every emitted neutron separately in the $A$ total.
  4. Check $Z$ independently; a neutron contributes 0 to $Z$.
Process mnemonicFISSION HAS AN “S” FOR SPLIT

The diagram direction matters more than memorising particular element symbols.

Equation method: never try to balance an equation by visual symmetry. Write one line for upper numbers and a second line for lower numbers.
Counting trap: a coefficient such as $3,^{1}_{0}n$ contributes 3 to total $A$, not 1.
Quick Check · In fission, what pattern identifies the process?
A heavy nucleus splits into two smaller nuclei. The number of extra neutrons can vary between equations, so it is not the defining feature.
11
Two light nuclei join

Nuclear fusion

  • Fusion joins light nuclei.
Fusion example · two hydrogen isotopes joinFusion example · two hydrogen isotopes join²₁H + ³₁H⁴₂He + ¹₀nA: 2 + 3 = 4 + 1 = 5Z: 1 + 1 = 2 + 0 = 2The helium nucleus contains two protons and two neutrons.
Fusion joins two light nuclei to make a heavier nucleus; another particle may also be produced.
NUCLEAR EQUATION BALANCELEFT TOTALA2 + 3 = 5Z1 + 1 = 2RIGHT TOTALA4 + 1 = 5Z2 + 0 = 2join pattern + bothtotals conserved
The familiar hydrogen-isotope example balances to helium-4 plus a neutron.
FUSION = JOIN: two light nuclei join to form a heavier nucleus.

FISSION

one heavy nucleus → smaller nuclei

FUSION

light nuclei → heavier nucleus

Classify the change from the nuclear pattern.
Process mnemonicFU-SION → FUSE → JOIN

First identify the direction of nuclear change; then use the A/Z ledger.

Particle trap: the neutron written on the product side is not the new heavy nucleus. Count it as a separate product in the A total.
Quick Check · Must fusion always show exactly one product?
No. The defining change is that light nuclei join to form a heavier nucleus; another particle can also appear, as in helium-4 plus a neutron.
12
Two conservation rows · no guessing

Balancing nuclear equations

  • Nuclear equations balance total A and Z.
NUCLEAR EQUATION BALANCELEFT TOTALA235 + 1Z92 + 0RIGHT TOTALA141 + 92 + xZ56 + 36 + 0ΣA left = ΣA right · ΣZleft = ΣZ right
Treat the upper-number equation and lower-number equation as independent checks.
NUCLIDE NOTATIONn10neutron: A = 1 · Z = 0
A free neutron changes the nucleon total but not the proton total.
ΣA on the left = ΣA on the right   and   ΣZ on the left = ΣZ on the right
Interactive · Missing-particle solver

Subtract known product totals

missing A = 3 · missing Z = 0
  1. Add every upper number on the left.
  2. Add all known upper numbers on the right; subtract to find missing $A$.
  3. Repeat with lower numbers to find missing $Z$.
  4. Identify the particle/nuclide only after both values are known.
  5. Re-add both sides as a final check.
Balance mnemonicTOP WITH TOP · BOTTOM WITH BOTTOM

Upper numbers never balance against lower numbers.

Show working: two short number equations can earn method marks even if the final nuclide symbol is wrong.
Symbol-count trap: conservation does not mean the same number of written nuclei on both sides. It means equal total A and equal total Z.
Quick Check · Known products are short by A = 1 and Z = 0. What particle fits?
A neutron, written $^{1}_{0}n$.
13
The syllabus requires the direction of change, not a mass–energy calculation

Nuclear mass and energy

  • In an energy-releasing nuclear reaction, total rest mass of products is less than reactants, with the difference associated with released energy.
  • Explain this qualitatively here; numerical mass–energy calculations are not required.
  • These nuclear processes differ from ordinary chemical changes involving outer electrons.
QUALITATIVE MASS–ENERGY CHANGEstarting nucleiproductsslightly greatertotal massslightly smallertotal masssmall decrease in total mass accompanies energy release
No numerical mass difference is required here: identify the direction of the mass change and the associated energy release.
products have a slightly smaller total mass → energy is released / transferred

A balanced nuclide equation conserves total nucleon number $A$ and total proton number $Z$. That does not mean the measured total mass must be exactly unchanged. For the fission and fusion processes in this topic, state qualitatively that the products have a slightly smaller total mass and that energy is released.

Interactive · Choose the correct qualitative statement

No numerical conversion is needed

Choose the statement that matches the syllabus.
Direction mnemonicMASS SLIGHTLY DOWN · RELEASED ENERGY OUT

Do not calculate a numerical mass difference or convert mass into energy in Topic 5.1.

Exam precision: keep two ledgers separate. Nuclide notation conserves total $A$ and total $Z$; the measured total mass can still be slightly smaller after the event.
Quick Check · Does equal total A guarantee exactly equal measured mass?
No. Equal total A means the nucleon count is conserved. The total measured mass of the products can be slightly smaller, with energy released.
14
Safe simulation · fixed physics · repeated samples

ATP Lab Lens: make rare scattering evidence reliable

SAFE SCATTERING SIMULATIONsame targetsame targetsame target50020008000incident tracks / runincident tracks / runincident tracks / runRecord the large-angle percentage for repeated runs.No physical radiation source is used.
Change sample size, not the atomic model, to study the reliability of a rare-event percentage.
RESULTS TABLE DESIGNincident tracks / runcountlarge-angle % · repeat 1, 2, 3...%mean large-angle percentage%range of repeated percentagespercentage pointslarge-angle boundary°
Keep raw counts and percentages, then use the spread of repeats to judge stability.
Interactive · Percentage processor

Convert a rare count fairly

large-angle percentage = 0.200%
  1. Choose several incident-track sample sizes for the same model.
  2. Keep the target, beam geometry, projectile speed and angle boundary unchanged.
  3. Repeat each sample size several times.
  4. Calculate the large-angle percentage for every run.
  5. Compare the mean percentages and the run-to-run range.
  6. A larger sample should usually give a more stable estimate, not a different underlying scattering model.
Uncertainty pair: rare events → increase sample size and repeat. Borderline angle classification → use a fixed digital overlay/template and one written boundary rule.
Strict safety: use a computer model, printed tracks or teacher-supplied data only. Students do not handle a radioactive source.
ATP mnemonicFIX PHYSICS · CHANGE SAMPLE · REPEAT · PERCENT · COMPARE

This keeps the investigation inside the syllabus evidence while still training reliable data handling.

Quick Check · Why compare percentages instead of raw large-angle counts?
The total number of incident tracks changes. A percentage divides by that total, so different sample sizes can be compared fairly.
1
See the task before touching the numbers

One examiner decoder organises every atomic-model question

ATOMIC-MODEL EXAMINER DECODERCOUNTp · n · eA, Z, chargeCOMPAREsame Z?ion or isotopeCONSERVEΣA and ΣZnuclear equationINFERtrack → evidenceatomic modelCOUNT → COMPARE →CONSERVE → INFER
First classify the demand: count particles, compare nuclei, conserve equation totals or infer a model from tracks.
COUNTING WORKSPACECOUNTp, n and e separatelyCOMPAREsame Z? same N?CONSERVEupper and lower totalsINFERobservation beforeconclusionfour routes · fourdifferent kinds ofevidence
The same words recur in diagrams, tables, equations and data questions.

Crest habit: write a tiny ledger beside the question. Use p, n and e for particles; A and Z for nuclide notation; use two total rows for a nuclear equation; and keep a Rutherford observation separate from its inference.

COUNT

$p=Z$, $n=A-Z$ and, for a neutral atom, $e=Z$.

COMPARE

Same $Z$ means same element; different $n$ means different isotope.

CONSERVE

Add every upper number and every lower number separately.

INFER

State what was observed, then the single conclusion it supports.

Choose a task to reveal the correct examiner route.
Master mnemonicCOUNT → COMPARE → CONSERVE → INFER

Never mix the ledgers: electrons decide charge, protons decide element, neutrons decide isotope, and track patterns decide the model.

Boundary trap: Keep Topic 5.1 focused on atomic structure, ion formation, nuclide identity, scattering evidence, fission and fusion. Radioactivity is treated separately in the next topic.
Quick Check · Which count decides the element?
The proton number, $Z$. Electron count may change in an ion and neutron count may change between isotopes, but changing $Z$ changes the element.
15
One-page examiner logic

Master the nuclear model by protecting four separate ledgers

ATOMIC-MODEL EXAMINER DECODERCOUNTp · n · eA, Z, chargeCOMPAREsame Z?ion or isotopeCONSERVEΣA and ΣZnuclear equationINFERtrack → evidenceatomic modelCOUNT → COMPARE →CONSERVE → INFER
Use the four-move route on every diagram, table, equation or data set.
ATOM → ION CHARGE LEDGERbefore12 p12 eneutralafter12 p10 echarge = 2+2 electrons lostproton number stays fixed
Particle ledger: $p-e$ gives charge; electrons change without changing the nucleus.
ISOTOPE FINGERPRINTX2412n = 12X2512n = 13same Z · different N →isotopes
Identity ledger: same Z and different N identifies isotopes.
OBSERVATION → INFERENCEmost pass straightatom mostly emptyfew turn stronglynucleus tiny + massivepositive paths repelnucleus positiveone observation earns oneprecise inference
Evidence ledger: match each track observation to the exact conclusion it supports.
NUCLEAR EQUATION BALANCELEFT TOTALA2 + 3Z1 + 1RIGHT TOTALA4 + 1Z2 + 0ΣA left = ΣA right · ΣZleft = ΣZ right
Equation ledger: verify A and Z on separate lines.
QUALITATIVE MASS–ENERGY CHANGEbeforeslightly greater massproductsslightly smaller masssmall mass decreasedifference corresponds toenergy released
Energy ledger: a slight fall in total mass accompanies energy release.

1 · Particle count

$p=Z$, $n=A-Z$, charge number $=p-e$.

2 · Nuclear identity

Same $Z$ = same element; different $n$ = isotope.

3 · Scattering evidence

Straight → space; rare strong turn → tiny massive nucleus; repel → positive.

4 · Nuclear change

Split = fission; join = fusion; conserve total A and total Z.

$p=Z$ · $n=A-Z$ · charge $=p-e$ · isotopes: same $Z$, different $n$ · equations: total A and total Z conserved
Final chainCOUNT · COMPARE · CONSERVE · INFER

Then add the last energy sentence: product mass slightly lower, energy released.

Final check · $^{37}_{17}X^{-}$: give p, n, e, nuclear charge and nuclear mass.
p = 17; n = 20; e = 18; relative nuclear charge +17; relative nuclear mass 37.
Interactive mastery: 0 / 9 explored

Explore all nine checkpoints, then move to the independent Practice and Exam Arena banks.